Chapter 56: Chapter Fifty-Five

“Who’s that?” Castiel asked me as we got off the elevator.

There was a girl sitting beside my front door with headphones in her ears and her eyes closed as she leaned against the wall, her arms folded in her lap. She had a backpack on the floor next to her and she didn’t look homeless. She was wearing jeans and high-end sneakers. Her brown hair was long and in a ponytail.

“No clue,” I said to him as we stood there looking at her. My address was listed but people couldn’t gain entry through the front lobby and I wondered how she’d gotten up here.

I stopped right in front of her and nudged her foot with my shoe. She opened her eyes and quickly stood up, smoothing her t-shirt out, clasping her hands in front of her like she was nervous. Castiel had this look on his face like she was a deranged fan.

“I’m Katrina,” she said.

I looked at her in confusion. The way she had said it felt like I was supposed to know who she was, but I’d never seen her in my life before. I looked at Castiel and he just shrugged as he took the key from my hand and unlocked the front door.

“Your sister,” she clarified, and I stopped in my tracks.

I was about to close the door in her face when she said those two words. Castiel had stopped walking too and now he really looked at her. She was young, certainly not eighteen yet, she still had that girl look, a little innocence in her eyes.

“I don’t have a sister,” I said to her.

“I’m Katrina Warren, Denise’s daughter,” she said and then I saw it, they had the same eyes.

“What do you want?” I asked her.

“I wanted to meet my brother,” she said looking taken aback at my curtness.

“I don’t want anything to do with Denise,” I said to her.

“That’s just because your father poisoned you against her,” she said haughtily.

“Excuse me?” I asked her and stepped forward as Castiel intervened.

“Why don’t we take this inside and get some coffee and talk like adults,” he said, looking at me.

I sat down on the couch and looked at this girl. I had a sister. Denise had had a daughter after me and kept her. She had thrown me away and kept her. I couldn’t help the immediate dislike I felt for this girl when I didn’t even know her.

“Why are you here?” I asked her.

“Mom’s sick,” she said. I wanted to laugh at that. Did Denise really think I’d care? Our first and last meeting after she’d left me had ended in anger and I had no desire to know anything about her. I didn’t care. I wanted nothing to do with the woman that ruined my life.

“I don’t care,” I said and gritted my teeth.

“How can you not care? She’s your mother! She cried for you, night after night after your father stole you from her,” she said.

“You have no clue what you’re talking about,” I said. Anger pulsed in my veins, and I could feel my heart rate increasing as I thought about it. This girl, my sister, clearly believed I was an asshole and she was the victim.

“Who are you exactly?” she asked Castiel as he sat down on the couch next to me and put his hand on my shoulder.

“He’s my brother,” I said, my voice taking on an edge of anger.

“I knew it was a long shot since you’ve never even called her, not even on her birthday,” Katrina said.

“I don’t know what Denise has been telling you, but I’ve never even met my biological father. I don’t know his name or where he’s from or what he looks like. I don’t care that she’s sick and I’ve never known when her birthday is and I don’t care to know,” I said.

“Wow, you really are an asshole,” she said.

“You don’t know a damn thing about him!” Castiel said angrily as he jumped up. “We were all adopted by the same man, maybe get your facts straight before you accuse him of anything!”

“I know that your father left Mom when you were almost five, he got custody of you because he’s rich and she never saw you again. He moved far away and refused to take her calls or let her see you,” Katrina said.

“Is that what she told you?” I asked her.

“She talks about you a lot,” she said.

“She left me in a park when I was five,” I said, and I hated that I had to say this to her. I hated that my privacy was being invaded like this and that Denise was spewing this bullshit to her daughter.

“She wouldn’t do that, she’s a good person,” Katrina said as she glared at me.

“Does she know you’re here?” I asked her.

“No, she thinks I’m on a trip with some friends,” she said.

“I’ll say this one more time. I don’t care about Denise, I don’t care if she lives or dies or how good a person you think she is, all court cases are public here, go look for that custody case, it will be at the family court since I was born in New York,” I said to her.

“She wouldn’t lie to me,” she said.

“She’s been lying to you your whole life. Call your mother and go home,” I said to her.

“So, because you’re mad at her you don’t want to get to know me?” she asked.

“How old are you? Seventeen?” I asked and she nodded. “You’re a minor that ran away from home. It’s not about me not wanting to get to know you, it's about me not wanting anything to do with Denise.”

“Why would she leave you in a park and lie about it?” she asked me.

“That you’ll have to ask her,” I said.

“I’m sorry I bothered you,” she said standing up.