Chapter 39: Back in trembles
Chapter 39: Back in trembles
Audrey walked back to her hut with her arms wrapped tightly around herself, the sting of Tennessee’s words following her like a shadow she couldn’t outrun. His anger still rang in her ears, sharp, dismissive, accusing.
She replayed the moment again and again, wondering why she even bothered to speak, why she ever believed he might finally trust her. By the time she pushed open the wooden door of the small hut, her chest ached with a mix of humiliation and fury. She sat on the edge of her straw filled bed, staring blankly at the dirt floor as the dim lantern flickered weakly beside her.
She tried to breathe it out, but the pain sat heavy and unmoving. She had warned him. She wasn’t lying. And still he spoke to her as if she were nothing but a jealous nuisance.
A soft knock sounded. Then another, more subtle—Thomas’s knock.
She didn’t move.
“Audrey?” Thomas called from outside, his voice gentle. “Can I come in?”
She swallowed and said nothing. Her silence was answer enough. After a long moment, Thomas sighed quietly, the sound thick with concern. “I’m just outside if you need anything,” he said. His footsteps lingered, then faded.
Audrey leaned back, pressing her palms over her eyes. She wasn’t crying, she refused to cry again over Tennessee. But the ache behind her ribs felt sharp enough to draw blood.
Hours passed in stillness.
Night settled deep and cold over the farm. The air outside grew heavy, the kind that pressed against the hut walls like it carried warnings. Audrey was half asleep when the front door suddenly flung open with a force that made the hinges rattle.
She jolted upright.
Tennessee stood in the doorway, wild-eyed, breathless, his hair a mess as if he had been ripping his hands through it. Panic clung to him like sweat.
He didn’t wait for permission to enter. He barged in, slamming the door shut behind him. “Audrey,” he said sharply, voice breaking, “I need you to listen to me.”
She stiffened. “You shouldn’t be here. Please go, I don’t want to see you.”
He stepped forward anyway. “I found Celine’s doll in the woods,” he said, words tumbling out too fast. “The one she sleeps with every night. It was outside, on the ground, near the tree line. That means she was out there. Something happened. Something…” His voice cracked, and he dragged a shaky hand down his face.
Audrey rose slowly, keeping distance between them. “So now you believe something is wrong?”
Tennessee looked at her like a drowning man. “I’m not here to fight.”
“But you came in here shouting,” she shot back.
“I’m scared!” Tennessee lashed out, voice raw. “My daughter is missing and nothing makes sense. I’m trying to hold it together, Audrey. I’m trying, but I’m losing it.”
He inhaled sharply, trembling. Audrey had never seen him this unsteady, vulnerable, stripped down to bare bones.
She took a breath. “I told you,” she said quietly. “Gwen is not who she pretends to be. And I heard those men talking about a girl who fits her description. They mentioned her. They are watching us.”
Tennessee shook his head violently. “Stop. Just—stop.” He paced, running his hands through his hair again. “You don’t know Gwen. You don’t know what she’s been through.”
“And you don’t know what she’s doing behind your back,” Audrey answered, her voice steady. “She isn’t innocent. She’s lying to you. Unless you are pretending to be naive or you are her ally.”
He whipped around, anger flaring again. “Why would she lie? Why would she take Celine?”
“Why would the men chase me? Why would they be waiting on a girl to meet up with them? Why would they mention a clean up?” Audrey countered.
“Because you are making up crazy stories out of envy and jealousy!” he shouted.
Audrey’s eyes hardened. “I’m telling you what I heard. Whether you believe me or not doesn’t change the truth.”
Tennessee stopped pacing, chest rising and falling fast. He seemed torn between breaking apart and exploding again. He opened his mouth to speak but before a word could leave him, a scream sliced through the night.
A woman’s scream.
Both froze.
The sound was sharp, terrified, echoing across the dark farmland. Audrey’s heart dropped to her stomach. Tennessee bolted for the door, and Audrey was right behind him. The cold night air slapped their faces as they sprinted across the yard, Thomas appearing from the side of the barn, running toward the sound as well.
They all stopped at the edge of the main yard.
Gwen appeared, stumbling out of the trees with Celine clutched tightly in her arms. Her hair was disheveled, her clothes dirt streaked as if she had rolled on the ground. She was panting, shaking dramatically.
“A wolf!” Gwen screamed breathlessly. “A wolf chased us!”
Tennessee ran to her immediately, grabbing both her and Celine into his arms. “Oh my God… Gwen… Celine… are you hurt? What happened? Why were you out there?”
Gwen buried her face in his chest, sobbing hard, trembling like she was barely standing. “I took her out to get some fresh air but…Ten, the wolf came out of nowhere…I ran, God, I ran…”
Audrey stood several feet away, watching carefully. Gwen wasn’t just shaken. She was acting. Too perfectly, too rehearsed. Every sob felt placed. Every tremble felt timed.
Thomas came to stand beside Audrey, his breathing heavy, eyes darting between Gwen and Tennessee. He didn’t say a word, just waited.
Tennessee hugged Gwen tighter, running his hand over her back, checking her arms, looking for scratches. “You’re safe now,” he whispered into her hair. “Both of you.” He looked up at Thomas, desperate. “Did you see anything?”
Thomas shook his head. “No. I just heard the scream.”
Audrey folded her arms. “She’s lying.”
The words were quiet but sharp enough to cut through everything.
Tennessee turned around instantly, anger sparking again. “Audrey, don’t start.”
But she wasn’t looking at him. She was staring directly at Gwen. Gwen still pretending to sob into Tennessee’s chest, lifted her head just slightly, just enough so only Audrey could see her tiny smirk.
Cold. Triumphant. Mocking.
Audrey felt her stomach turn, but she didn’t flinch. She met Gwen’s smirk with an unwavering stare.
Tennessee didn’t see the exchange.
Thomas did. His jaw tensed.
Gwen lowered her face again, returning to her fake trembling.
Audrey stood still in the night air, the truth burning so hot inside her she felt it in her bones.