Chapter 98: Chapter 98

I spent the entire weekend pretending I wasn't nervous about my date with Ryder Hayes.

Unfortunately, nobody believed me.

Least of all Sofia.

"You've changed outfits three times."

I looked up from where I stood in front of my closet.

"I have not."

Sofia's expression was completely unimpressed.

"Aria."

"Okay, twice."

Her eyebrows rose.

I sighed.

"Fine. Four times."

She pointed at me triumphantly.

"Exactly."

I threw a pillow at her.

She dodged it with the ease of someone who had spent years annoying me professionally.

The traitor.

The absolute traitor.

"I don't know why you're acting like this," she said, flopping backward onto my bed. "You've literally kissed him already."

My face immediately became hot.

"Can you not say it like that?"

"Like what?"

"Like that."

Sofia laughed.

A loud, delighted laugh.

I considered throwing another pillow.

"What are you even worried about?" she asked.

I opened my mouth.

Then closed it.

Because the answer sounded ridiculous.

I wasn't worried about Ryder.

That was the problem.

I trusted him. I liked being around him. I liked talking to him.

Somehow, somewhere between all the arguments and eye-rolls and accidental moments of honesty, Ryder had become one of my favorite people.

That should have made this easier.

Instead, it made it terrifying.

Because suddenly I cared. A lot. And caring always came with risk.

Sofia's expression softened when she saw my silence.

"Oh."

I groaned.

"Don't."

"You really like him."

"Please stop talking."

Her smile grew.

"I knew it."

I buried my face in a pillow.

This was a mistake.

A huge mistake.

The date wasn't until the afternoon.

Which meant I had several hours to overthink everything.

An activity I excelled at.

By lunchtime, I had convinced myself of approximately twenty different disasters that could occur.

By one o'clock, I had reached thirty.

At one-thirty, my phone buzzed.

Ryder: Are you always late or should I be worried?

I stared at the message. Then immediately smiled.

Me: I'm not late.

The response came quickly.

Ryder: You're supposed to be here in thirty minutes.

Me: Exactly.

Ryder: That's cutting it dangerously close.

A laugh escaped me.

Me: Says the hockey player who once showed up ten minutes late to class.

Ryder: Allegedly.

Me: There were witnesses.

Ryder: Fake news.

I shook my head, smiling.

The nervousness eased slightly.

That was one thing Ryder was surprisingly good at.

Making things feel easy.

We had agreed to meet in town. Nothing fancy or dramatic.

Just a small café a few blocks away from school.

The kind of place students visited constantly.

Which was probably why Ryder had chosen it.

No pressure.

No expectations.

Just time together.

By the time I arrived, he was already there.

And somehow seeing him waiting made my heart skip.

He was leaning against the café window.

Hands tucked into his jacket pockets. Looking down at his phone.

Completely unaware that I had arrived. He was breathtaking.

For a second, I simply stood there.

Watching.

Because this version of Ryder still felt new. Not the athlete or the rival or the guy who constantly got on my nerves.

Just Ryder. Then he looked up and our eyes met immediately.

And the smile that spread across his face made my stomach flutter.

There it was again.

That smile.

The one that always felt genuine.

The one that somehow made everything else disappear for a moment.

"Hey."

His voice carried warmth.

The kind that reached all the way to his eyes.

"Hey."

For a brief second, both of us looked oddly nervous.

Then Ryder laughed.

A slightly embarrassed sound.

"Okay."

"What?"

"I had a speech prepared."

I blinked.

"You had a speech?"

"Not anymore."

I couldn't stop laughing.

"What happened to it?"

"You showed up."

His expression turned dramatically serious.

"Now it's gone."

I laughed harder.

The tension immediately broke.

Thank God.

The café was busy but comfortable. Students occupied several tables.

Music played softly overhead.

The smell of coffee and baked goods filled the air.

It felt normal and relaxed. Exactly what I needed.

We found a table near the window.

Conversation came surprisingly easily.

At first, we talked about school.

Then classes.

Then hockey.

Then somehow we ended up discussing the worst movies we'd ever seen.

Which led to a twenty-minute argument about whether one particular action movie counted as "so bad it's good."

"It absolutely does."

"It absolutely doesn't."

"It has a forty-three percent audience score."

"Exactly."

"That's not helping your argument."

I laughed so hard I nearly spilled my drink.

Ryder pointed accusingly.

"You laughed during the entire movie."

"Because it was ridiculous."

"Because it was entertaining."

"That's not the same thing."

His grin widened.

"I think you're wrong."

"I think you're impossible."

"That's fair."

The ease of it surprised me.

Not because I didn't enjoy talking to him.

Because I did.

A lot.

But because there was no awkwardness.

No pressure.

Just two people enjoying each other's company.

The realization settled somewhere warm inside me.

As the afternoon stretched on, conversation gradually shifted.

The joking remained.

But moments of honesty slipped through more often.

At one point, Ryder glanced down at his recovering hand almost absentmindedly. I noticed immediately.

Of course I did.

"How's physio?"

His expression softened.

"Good."

A small smile appeared.

"Genuinely good."

Relief washed through me. He leaned back in his chair.

"The therapist says I'm ahead of schedule."

My eyes widened.

"Seriously?"

He nodded.

The excitement in his face was impossible to miss.

"Coach is trying not to get his hopes up."

"And you?"

A laugh escaped him.

"I'm trying."

The answer made me smile. Because I understood exactly what he meant.

Hope was dangerous. Especially after disappointment.

But it was there anyway.

Growing stronger every day.

"I'll be back."

The certainty in his voice caught my attention.

For a second, I simply looked at him.

At the determination.

The resilience.

The quiet strength.

And suddenly I understood something.

Ryder wasn't fighting because hockey was easy.

He was fighting because he loved it.

The realization made my chest feel warm.

The afternoon passed far too quickly.

Eventually, we left the café and started walking.

The sky above us glowed gold and orange.

The streets were quieter now.

The weekend crowd slowly thinning.

For a while, neither of us spoke.

Not because things were awkward.

Because they weren't.

The silence felt comfortable and easy.

Then Ryder broke it.

"You know..."

I looked at him.

"What?"

His gaze stayed ahead.

A small smile touching his lips.

"This was better than my speech."

I laughed.

"The speech you forgot?"

"Exactly."

"High praise."

He smiled.

Then his expression softened slightly.

"I'm serious."

The teasing disappeared.

Just enough.

"I had a really good time today."

The honesty in his voice made my heart flutter.

Because I had too.

More than I wanted to admit.

More than I probably should.

But pretending otherwise felt pointless.

"So did I."

His smile grew.

Slowly and genuinely.

And for a second, neither of us looked away.

The world seemed quieter.

Smaller somehow.

Like the moment belonged only to us.

Then Ryder reached for my hand.

Carefully.

Giving me every opportunity to pull away.

I didn't.

Our fingers intertwined naturally and comfortably. Like they already knew how.

Warmth spread through me instantly.

The smile on Ryder's face softened.

And somehow, that simple gesture felt just as important as everything else.

Maybe more.

Because it wasn't dramatic.

It wasn't rushed. It was a choice.

A quiet one.

A meaningful one.

And as we continued walking side by side beneath the fading evening sky, I found myself smiling.

Not because everything was perfect.

Not because life had suddenly become simple.

Mike was still missing.

Questions still remained.

Hockey still stood between Ryder and complete recovery.

There were challenges ahead.

Plenty of them.

But for now?

Things felt good.

And sometimes, that was enough.

As our joined hands swung lightly between us, I glanced at Ryder.

He caught me looking.

His smile immediately returned.

And somehow, seeing it still made my heart race.

Some things, apparently, never changed.