Chapter 76: Chapter 76

The hallway outside the principal’s office gradually fills up the empty void with people pretending to pass by but clearly slowing down, eyes flicking toward us, whispers trailing behind hands that don’t quite cover mouths properly.

It’s different now.

Before, the attention felt sharp, judging and certain. Now it feels… uncertain.

Like the story they thought they knew has been ripped open, and nobody knows what to believe anymore.

I should feel relieved but I don’t. Because uncertainty doesn’t erase damage. It just reshapes it.

Sofia nudges me lightly as we stand there, her voice low but pointed. “You’re staring.”

“I am not.”

“You are,” she insists, tilting her head slightly. “And it’s very obvious.”

I drag my gaze away from Ryder immediately, heat creeping up my neck. “I was thinking.”

“About him.”

“No.”

“Yes.”

I shoot her a look. She just smirks.

Annoying but unfortunately accurate.

Ryder stands a few feet away, talking quietly with my dad. His posture is still guarded, but not in that aggressive way I’m used to. There’s something more restrained about him now. Like he’s holding himself together instead of bracing to explode. God! He looked hot still.

And my dad...my dad isn’t looking at him like he’s a problem anymore.

He’s looking at him like he’s… evaluating.

That alone feels strange.

I catch fragments of their conversation.

“…not off the team yet,” my dad is saying, his tone firm but not hostile.

Ryder exhales, running a hand through his hair. “That’s not exactly reassuring.”

“It’s honest.”

A pause.

Then Ryder nods slightly. “Fair enough.”

There’s no argument or tension snapping between them and for some reason, that unsettles me more than when they used to clash.

Because it means something is changing.

And I don’t know what that means for me.

My dad steps back after a moment. “Focus on your recovery. Physically and mentally. That’s where your priority should be.”

Ryder’s jaw tightens faintly, but he nods again. “Yeah.”

Dad turns, his gaze landing on me briefly. Something unreadable flickers in his eyes before he gestures. “Let’s go.”

Sofia immediately grabs my arm. “Lets get lunch now. Before my brain melts from all this tension.”

I let her pull me away, but not before I glance back once more.

Ryder’s already looking at me.

Of course he is.

And this time there’s no hostility in his expression.

Just something quieter and warm. Something that lingers a second too long.

...

The cafeteria is louder than usual.

Not because anything dramatic is happening right now but because everyone is waiting for something to happen.

It’s in the way conversations dip when we walk in.

The way people glance, then pretend not to.

The way rumors seem to hang in the air like unfinished sentences.

Sofia drops into a seat with exaggerated exhaustion. “I hate this school.”

“You say that every week.”

“And every week I’m correct.”

I sit across from her, trying to focus on anything that isn’t the weight of a hundred eyes I can feel without even looking.

It doesn’t work. Nothing feels normal.

Even the way my fingers tap lightly against the table feels too loud.

“You’re thinking again,” Sofia says, narrowing her eyes at me.

“I’m always thinking.”

“Yeah, but this is different thinking.”

I sigh quietly, leaning back slightly. “Everything just… changed.”

“Obviously.”

“No, I mean…” I pause, struggling to put it into words. “It doesn’t feel like we’re fighting anymore.”

Sofia raises a brow. “You and Ryder?”

I nod slowly.

She leans forward slightly, her expression shifting into something more serious. “And that bothers you?”

“Yes....No.”

“Aria.”

I exhale, dragging a hand over my face. “I don’t know.”

Because I don’t.

The anger was easier, very clear and simple.

Now everything feels blurred and messy...again!.

Complicated in ways I don’t have control over.

Sofia studies me for a moment before her lips curve slightly. “You’re in trouble.”

“I am not.”

“You are,” she insists softly. “Because you don’t hate him anymore.”

I freeze.

Because that hits too close.

“I never said that.”

“You didn’t have to.”

I look away, my thoughts suddenly too loud again.

Before I can respond, the noise in the cafeteria shifts subtly but noticeable.

Conversations lower, heads turn and I don’t need to look to know why.

Ryder.

Of course.

He walks in with that same quiet intensity he always carries, but something about him feels different now.

Not softer.

Just… less closed off.

He scans the room briefly before his gaze lands on me and stays there.

My pulse stumbles slightly.

Sofia notices immediately. “Oh, this is getting interesting.”

“Stop.”

“I haven’t even started.”

Ryder hesitates for a second.

Then he walks over.

My brain short-circuits slightly because this hasn’t happened before....I mean not in a long time.

Not like this.

Not without tension snapping between us.

Not without something pushing him away or me shutting him out.

He stops at the table, one hand resting lightly against the back of the empty chair beside me.

“You mind?” he asks, glancing between me and Sofia.

Sofia beams like she’s been waiting for this moment her entire life. “Not at all.”

I shoot her a look.

She ignores it completely.

Ryder sits close.

Not too close.

But close enough that I’m suddenly very aware of everything. The space.The air.

The way my heart is beating just a little too fast for no reason.

No one speaks for a second.

Then Ryder exhales quietly. “This is weird.”

Sofia snorts. “You think?”

He glances at her briefly, a faint smile tugging at his lips before his gaze shifts back to me.

And suddenly It’s just us again.

Even in the middle of a crowded cafeteria.

“Are you okay?” he asks.

The question is simple. But the way he asks it isn’t. His eyes are steady and focused.

Like he actually wants to know.

Like it matters.

“I’m fine,” I say automatically.

He raises a brow slightly.

Not buying it.

“You sure?”

There’s no pressure in his voice.

Just quiet insistence.

And that makes it harder to brush off.

“I just…” I hesitate, then shake my head. “It’s a lot.”

“Yeah,” he says softly. “It is.”

A pause settles between us.

“You handled it well,” I say after a moment.

He blink slightly. “Handled what?”

“Everything,” I says simply, his gaze not leaving mine. “In there. With the board. With Jason.”

Something shifts in my chest the moment I say that because after the sound of that he looked genuine.

“Thanks,” He say quietly.

His lips curve slightly, just enough to notice.

Sofia makes a small, dramatic choking noise beside me. “Wow. Growth and communication? I’m emotional.”

“Please don’t,” I mutter.

Ryder lets out a soft breath that almost sounds like a laugh again.

And there it is.

That feeling, that shift which was stronger now and more noticeable and way more dangerous because it’s not just tension anymore.

It’s something pulling instead of pushing.

Something neither of us seems ready to name.

The moment lingers.

Then suddenly a voice cuts through it.

Sounding sharp and unsteady.

“Aria.”

I turn.

Mia stands a few feet away.

Her eyes are red and her posture stiff.

Like she forced herself to walk over here even though every instinct told her not to.

The entire table goes quiet.

Sofia straightens slightly.

Ryder’s expression shifts, not hostile, but guarded.

Mia swallows, her gaze flicking briefly toward him before settling on me again.

“I need to talk to you.”

My jaw tightens slightly.

About what?

About everything, obviously.

I stand slowly.

“Give us a minute,” I say to Sofia.

She nods once, though her eyes scream tell me everything later.

Mia leads me a little further away, near the edge of the cafeteria where it’s quieter.

But not private enough.

Nothing is private here anymore.

“I’m sorry,” she says immediately.

The words come out rushed.

Like she’s been holding them in too long.

I don’t respond right away. I just look at her.

Really look at her.

She looks different.....shaken.

“I didn’t think it would go this far,” she continues, her voice trembling slightly. “I swear, Aria. I didn’t know Jason was doing all that.”

“You still helped,” I say quietly.

She flinches.

“I know.”

“You spread things,” I add, my voice tightening slightly. “You knew people were watching us.”

“I thought it was harmless!” she says quickly, her frustration breaking through. “Everyone talks about everyone in this school. I didn’t think....”

“That it would ruin people?” I cut in.

Her mouth closes.

Silence stretches between us.

Then she exhales shakily. “I messed up.”

Yeah.

She did.

But hearing her say it like that it doesn’t feel satisfying.

Just… heavy.

“What do you want from me?” I ask.

“Nothing,” she says quickly. “I just… needed you to hear it from me. Not from anyone else.”

I nod slowly.

Because I get that.

Even if I’m not ready to forgive her.

Not yet.

“Okay,” I say finally.

Relief flickers across her face.

She looked small and fragile.

Then she hesitates. “And… Ryder.”

My expression shifts instantly.

“What about him?”

She glances back toward the table briefly. “I told you I liked him.”

“I remember.”

Her lips press together. “I don’t anymore.”

That catches me off guard.

“Why?”

Mia lets out a quiet, almost self-deprecating laugh. “Because I don’t think I ever really did.”

I frown slightly.

“I think I just liked the idea of him,” she continues, her voice softer now. “The attention. The drama. The way everyone talked about him.”

That makes sense.

More than I want it to.

“But you...” she starts, then stops.

“What?”

She studies my face carefully.

And whatever she sees there makes something shift in her expression.

“You’re different with him,” she says quietly.

My stomach flips.

“I’m not...”

“You are,” she insists softly. “Even when you were fighting. It wasn’t normal.”

I don’t respond. Because I don’t know how to.

Mia exhales slowly. “Just… be careful.”

“Of him?”

She shakes her head slightly.

“No,” she says. “Of yourself.”

That lands deeper than I expect.

Before I can respond, she gives me one last look before walking away.

Leaving me standing there.

When I turn back toward the table Ryder’s already watching me.

And this time I don’t look away. I smiled.