Chapter 5: Chapter 5
The next few days feel… different.
Not in a big, obvious way but enough that I notice.
Ryder doesn’t avoid me—but he doesn’t talk to me either. Whenever I’m around, his attention shifts somewhere else, like he’s pretending I’m not there. And somehow, that bothers me more than when we were arguing which makes no sense.
I should be relieved but instead, I feel… irritated.
“Okay, this is getting painful to watch,” Sofia says, dropping into the seat across from me at lunch.
I look up from my notebook. “What is?”
“You,” she replies immediately. “You keep looking at him and then pretending you’re not looking at him.”
“I am not—”
“You just did it again.”
I snap my notebook shut. “I’m observing. For my article.”
Sofia leans forward, resting her chin on her hand, clearly entertained. “Mhm. Observing the captain. Very professionally.”
I ignore her and glance across the cafeteria anyway.
The hockey team sits at their usual table, loud and relaxed like they own the place. Ryder is there, leaning back in his chair, listening to something one of his teammates is saying. He looks normal. Calm. Like nothing is wrong.
Like he didn’t warn me to stay out of his life.
My eyes shift slightly—
And that’s when I notice him.
Blake Carter.
He’s sitting a little closer to the center of the table than the others, his posture relaxed but deliberate, like he wants to be seen without trying too hard. He laughs at something, but his eyes aren’t on his teammates.
They’re on Ryder.
Watching.
Measuring.
Something about it feels… off.
“Who’s that?” I ask quietly.
Sofia follows my gaze and her expression changes instantly. “Oh. That’s Blake Carter.”
“What about him?”
She hesitates, like she’s deciding how much to say.
“He’s good,” she finally says. “Really good. Some people think he should be captain instead of Ryder.”
I look back at the table.
Blake says something to Ryder, leaning slightly closer. Ryder replies, but his body language shifts—subtle, but tense.
“Do they not get along?” I ask.
Sofia shrugs. “They’re teammates. But… it’s complicated.”
Complicated.
That seems to be a theme here.
Before I can ask more, Blake suddenly looks up and catches me staring.
Our eyes meet for a second.
Then he smiles. Not a friendly smile but something sharper. More intentional.
I immediately look away.
“…Yeah,” Sofia says under her breath. “Be careful with him.”
“Why?”
“He likes attention,” she says. “And he doesn’t like competition.”
I frown slightly.
“I’m not competition.”
Sofia gives me a look.
“You’re the coach’s daughter,” she says. “And you’re already involved with the team.”
I open my mouth to argue—then pause because she’s not entirely wrong.
Practice that afternoon feels heavier.
Like something in the air has shifted.
I sit in the stands again, notebook open, pen ready. The sound of skates cutting across the ice echoes sharply, players shouting to each other, the usual rhythm of practice.
But today—
There’s tension.
I see it in the way passes are harder. More aggressive.
And at the center of it—
Ryder and Blake.
They move differently around each other.
Every pass between them feels like a challenge.
Every glance lingers too long.
Then it happens.
Blake skates toward Ryder, fast, controlled. Ryder moves to intercept, their sticks clashing briefly as they fight for control of the puck.
It’s normal.
It should be.
But then Blake pushes—just slightly harder than necessary.
Ryder stumbles. Not enough to fall. But enough that I notice. Enough that he notices.
The rink goes quiet for half a second.
Ryder straightens immediately, his expression hardening.
Blake slows, turning back toward him with an easy smile like nothing happened.
“Careful, captain,” he says, his voice carrying just enough. “Wouldn’t want you getting hurt.”
Something in my chest tightens.
Ryder’s jaw clenches.
“I’m fine,” he says shortly.
Blake’s smile widens slightly.
“Good,” he replies. “Wouldn’t want the team relying on someone who can’t keep up.”
That’s not concern.
That’s a challenge.
The coach blows the whistle, breaking the moment before it can turn into something worse.
“Focus!” he calls. “Again!”
Practice resumes, but the tension doesn’t disappear.
If anything—it gets worse.
By the time practice ends, I already know one thing.
Blake Carter is a problem.
I close my notebook and head toward the hallway outside the locker rooms. Voices echo from inside, laughter mixed with exhaustion.
I lean against the wall, flipping through my notes.
Then the door opens.
Blake walks out first.
Up close, he looks even more composed. Like everything he does is calculated.
He notices me immediately.
“Aria Bennett,” he says, like he’s been expecting me.
I straighten slightly. “Blake Carter.”
His lips curve into a small smile.
“So you know who I am.”
“I ask questions,” I reply.
“I like that,” he says, stepping closer. “It means you’re paying attention.”
Something about the way he says it makes me uneasy.
“I try to,” I say carefully.
He glances toward the locker room, then back at me.
“So,” he continues, voice lower now, “what do you think of the team?”
“They’re good.”
“But?” he presses.
I hesitate.
Because I know what he’s asking.
And I know what he wants me to say.
“There’s pressure,” I say instead. “A lot of it.”
Blake studies me for a second, then nods slowly.
“Yeah,” he says. “Especially on Ryder.”
There’s something in his tone.
Something deliberate.
“You don’t seem concerned,” I point out.
He chuckles softly.
“I’m always concerned,” he says. “That’s why I pay attention.”
A pause.
Then—
“You should too.”
My grip tightens slightly on my notebook.
“I do.”
His eyes flicker, like he knows there’s more I’m not saying.
“Good,” he says. “Because things change fast around here.”
Before I can respond, the locker room door opens again.
Ryder steps out.
And immediately—
The atmosphere shifts.
His eyes move from Blake—
To me.
And something in his expression hardens.
Blake notices.
Of course he does.
A slow, knowing smile spreads across his face.
“Captain,” he says casually. “We were just talking about you.”
Ryder doesn’t look at him.
His gaze stays on me.
“That so?” he says, his voice calm but tight.
Blake nods.
“Yeah,” he says lightly. “Your biggest fan here seems very interested in your performance.”
My stomach twists.
“I’m not—”
“Be careful, Aria.”
Ryder’s voice cuts through mine.
Sharp.
Controlled.
But there’s something under it.
Frustration.
Maybe even anger.
“People might start thinking you have favorites.”
The words hit harder than they should.
I frown.
“That’s not fair,” I say. “I’m just doing my job.”
“Then do it properly,” he replies.
Something in my chest tightens.
“Maybe I am,” I say, my voice quieter now but steady. “Maybe you just don’t like what I’m seeing.”
Silence.
Tense.
Heavy.
Ryder takes a small step closer.
“Then maybe,” he says, his voice lower now, “you should stop looking so closely.”
My heart skips.
Not because of what he said.
But how he said it.
Like he’s not just annoyed.
Like he’s worried.
Before I can respond, Blake lets out a soft laugh.
“This is interesting,” he says. “Didn’t realize the captain gets this defensive.”
Ryder’s expression darkens instantly.
“Stay out of it, Blake.”
Blake raises his hands slightly, still smiling.
“Relax,” he says. “I’m just observing.”
The same word I used.
But it sounds different coming from him.
Colder.
Sharper.
Ryder doesn’t respond.
For a moment, the three of us just stand there.
Caught in something unspoken.
Then Blake steps back.
“See you both around,” he says casually before walking off.
And just like that—
The tension doesn’t leave.
It stays.
Right here.
Between me and Ryder.
He exhales slowly, running a hand through his hair.
“You need to be careful,” he says, not looking at me this time.
“About what?”
“About him.”
I blink.
That wasn’t what I expected.
“Blake?”
Ryder nods slightly.
“He’s not what he looks like.”
Neither are you.
The thought crosses my mind before I can stop it.
“I can handle myself,” I say.
He finally looks at me again.
“I’m serious, Aria.”
Something in his voice makes my chest tighten.
“He doesn’t play fair.”
I hold his gaze.
“Neither do secrets,” I say quietly.
That hits.
I see it.
The tension returns instantly.
Stronger.
More personal.
For a second, I think he’s going to argue.
Instead, he just shakes his head.
“You don’t get it,” he mutters.
“Then explain it to me.”
There was silence. Long and heavy.
Then—
“I can’t.”
The honesty in those two words catches me off guard.
And for the first time—
I realize something.
This isn’t just about hockey.
This isn’t just about a story.
This is bigger.
Messier.
More dangerous.
And somehow—
I’m already in the middle of it.