Chapter 20: Unexpected visitor
Alan's POV
"Thanks," Daxton said, looking straight into my eyes. It sounded normal, but it wasn't.
There was hesitation in it as if he was grateful but not comfortable with me being the one standing there.
I could be wrong. But I don't think I was.
"No need, man," I said, keeping my tone casual. "She's my neighbour. Of course I'd help. And I—"
"Don’t you have classes?" She cut in, quickly.
I stopped and looked at her—topic change. Classic Milie!
A smile tugged at my lips despite myself. "Actually, I was planning a coffee date with you."
Her brows lifted. "Coffee date? Sorry, we’re not even having water together."
"Ouch." I tapped my chest. "Brutal."
"You’re crossing the line."
"It’s just coffee, Mils."
"Alan." Daxton's voice slipped in, firm enough to draw a line I hadn't crossed yet, but apparently, he thought I had.
"Thanks for helping her." He continued, and I already knew I wouldn't like what came next.
"But if you help her, don't attach conditions to it."
For a moment, I didn't react. I just looked at him. Not annoyed. Not defensive. Just assessing.
"I didn’t," I said.
"It definitely sounds like that."
I turned to Milie because her opinion matters the most.
She met my eyes and just shrugged. "Yeah."
It was a casual Yeah, but it landed heavier than anything else said in that moment.
"Hmm…. Got it," I said quietly. "My bad."
The ease, the lightness I carried dropped instantly.
I dragged a hand through my hair, exhaling slowly, trying to shake off something I didn't want to feel.
"If I made it uncomfortable… or came across wrong," I added, "that wasn’t the intention."
"I didn't do it for that." Saying it, I walked past them.
"Alan—" she called, but I didn't turn back.
Daxton not trusting me was fine. But her? Not expected.
I was not angry, but disappointed, not in her, but in how easily something genuine starts looking wrong when too many people believe it.
"You're doing too much," I told myself.
Showing up. Saying things. Standing where you weren't invited.
But then, she never asked me to leave either. That was the problem. One moment, she let me in. The next moment, she shut me out like I meant nothing.
I skipped staying back after class and went straight home.
"Hey, Nana," I said, pressing a quick kiss to her cheek.
She studied my face. "What’s wrong?"
"Nothing."
"Liar."
I sighed. "Not in the mood."
"Then cook," she said. "You'll feel better."
I nodded. Perfect distraction! I freshened up and walked into the kitchen.
I chopped, stirred, followed instructions, but my thoughts kept drifting back to her.
To the way she shrugged, to how easily she agreed just because her friend said.
Just then, Mom's voice floated in. "Mom, don't you think your grandson is acting strange?"
"For the first time I will agree with you—yes," Nana replied.
I scoffed under my breath. "Relax, ladies. I’m fine."
I wasn't. Not even close.
A minute later, the doorbell rang. Mom went to open it, and I didn't pay much attention until I heard her voice.
"Uh… Aunty, I’m Milie. I live next door."
My brows arched in confusion. "Why is she here?”
I didn't move. Didn't step out. Just listened.
"Is she here to apologize?"
"Stop it, Alan, don't get your hopes high."
I stayed where I was. But I could hear everything.
She walked in, her voice carrying the slight awkwardness.
"I was playing with a ball… it fell into your balcony…"
A weak excuse, and she knew it. Nana, of course, didn't let her go that easily.
"You're the girl with the injured leg whom my Alan helped. How is it, now?"
There was pride in her voice. Always was.
Milie laughed lightly. "It’s fine now. See…"
She smiled, twirled, and also acted, kicking the ball. I watched her from behind the wall.
I put control on my lips and stepped out. She paused, our eyes locked onto each other.
"Hey," she said.
"Hi."
"Alan, her ball is in the balcony. Go get it," Mom said.
Before I could move, she turned to Mom.
"No, no," she interrupted quickly. "I'll get it."
And just like that, she climbed the stairs. Like she had every right to. Like the house was familiar to her.
We all exchanged a look, feeling her behaviour weird.
And there she shouted dramatically. "Aunty! I think the latch is stuck!"
I frowned slightly. It wasn't, and now I doubted if she was actually here for the ball.
I rushed up. That's the chance I was waiting for.
The moment I stepped in, I saw she was standing there, holding my blanket, muffling her laughter against it.
"Peach?" she whispered, failing miserably at hiding her amusement.
I walked over and pulled it from her hands. "What’s funny?"
She poked my arm. "You don’t look like someone who sleeps with a peach blanket."
I gave her a flat look. "Take your ball and leave."
"There’s no ball."
"What?"
She extended her palm up toward me, her eyes dancing with mischief. "So you’ll have to give me one."
And just like that, it clicked. A slow smile spread across my face. "You came for me?"
She rolled her eyes, exploring the room's ceiling.
I stepped closer and closed the door behind me without breaking eye contact.
And then, slowly, backed her toward the table.
"Why do you do this?" I asked quietly. "Push… and then come back?"
"Alan, move," she said, her voice panicked. I could see her nervous, her heartbeat rising as mine did.
She pushed me, but I caught her wrist before she could pull away completely.
"Thank you," I said.
That caught her off guard. She looked up at me, something flickering across her face.
"Say that to Sammy," she replied. "If he hadn’t asked, I wouldn’t have."
I shook my head slightly. "Don't lie to me. That you came just because he said."
That made her smile. But it wasn't playful this time. "Don’t waste your time on me," she said warmly. "You’ll get nothing."
For a moment, I just looked at her. "My instinct says otherwise," I replied. "You like me. You're just stopping yourself."
She exhaled slowly, like she didn't even want to argue. "I don’t trust easily."
"I can see that."
"And I don’t think I like you," she added, then paused. "It’s just… complicated."
"Then explain it."
She shook her head. "Not today."
I let out a small breath. "Fine."
Her wrist was still in my hand. "Then I’ll wait."
That made her look at me again, intently this time.
"Maybe one day," she said. "But not today."
She pulled her hand and started to walk out.
"Wait." I grabbed a ball from the drawer and tossed it to her. "You came for this, remember?"
She caught it, a small smile forming. "Thanks."
She bounced it once, then pretended to throw it at me. I flinched instinctively.
She laughed. "Scared?"
I didn't answer. I just watched her, and she looked back at me before walking out.
"That smile. That ease... Ahhh... I'm liking every bit of it."