Chapter 12: Listed in Jerks
Milie's POV.
I glanced back at Alan, irritation bubbling up again.
"Asshole… Jerk," I mumbled under my breath. "How could he think something like this?"
"What?" Daxton stopped mid-step and turned to me.
"That idiot actually thinks I planned all of this," I said, exasperated. "Like I was dying to come with him. He said I set it up—me yelling, him showing up… everything."
Daxton's expression hardened.
"And then he just jokes about it as if nothing happened," I added, throwing my hands up.
His jaw tightened. "What I don't understand is… how you ended up in his car in the first place."
I paused. That question—I should have known coming.
"You messaged me that you would pick me, I know," I said. "But you would’ve had to come all the way in the opposite direction. So I asked Dad, and we were almost leaving when Alan showed up."
"And?" Daxton prompted, his tone quieter now but sharper.
"He asked Dad if he could drop me. Dad said yes."
"And you?" He asked, locking his gaze on mine. That's the answer he wanted.
I hesitated for a fraction of a second.
"I… said yes too."
That was all it took. He looked away, exhaling sharply, frustration slipping through despite his restraint.
A second later, he turned back and held my shoulders, his eyes steady on mine.
"Do you know why he thinks he can say things like that?"
I shook my head, looking back into his eyes.
"Because you let him get comfortable," he said, his voice firm but controlled. "You gave him that space."
That hit. Harder than I expected.
"I didn't—" I started, but stopped.
Because somewhere he wasn't entirely wrong.
"How long have you even known him?" Daxton continued. "A week?"
I swallowed. Images flashed—The car ride. The chocolates. The game night. The way he just slid into conversations like he belonged there. But he shouldn't, not yet.
"Milie," Daxton said, softer now. "Are you listening to me?"
I nodded slowly. "Yeah… you're right."
"And darling, you've never lied to me," he added. "Not about anything. Especially not about guys."
I looked down.
"But for him… you did."
There was no accusation in his tone, just a deep concern.
"You're letting him influence you," he said quietly.
"I'm not," I replied quickly—then faltered. "I mean… I don't think I am."
He didn't interrupt, and that made me continue.
"It's just…" I sighed, frustrated with myself. "Sometimes he’s so irritating, I want to kick his ass, but sometimes, he just acts normal. Like—genuinely good."
I frowned. "It's just so confusing."
Daxton's expression softened slightly. "Look, he might be good, but don't trust anyone this easily,' he said. "I just don't want you getting hurt."
I let out a small breath. "Why would I get hurt? I don’t even like him."
His eyes searched mine.
"Are you sure?" That question lingered for a second too long.
"Of course," I said quickly. "You know me. Boys are a strict no."
"Still," I added, more grounded now, "I'll keep my distance."
That seemed to settle something in him. He nodded and pulled me into a half-hug, careful of my leg.
"Fine… And I'm sorry about yesterday," he said.
"It's okay," I replied softly. And I meant it. For a moment, everything felt normal again, but then—
I remembered–Jenga. The terrace. The late-night game. Yeah? None of them he knew, and this was not going to go well.
"Dax… actually, I need to tell you something else."
He pulled back slightly. "What?"
Words almost came out when—
"Hey, girl!"
Suddenly, an arm hooked around my neck from behind, and I stumbled.
"Sammy—what the hell!" Daxton snapped, catching me before I lost balance.
"Oh shit—sorry, sorry!" Sammy immediately let go, panic flashing across his face. "I forgot about the leg."
He leaned in and pressed a quick kiss to my temple. "You okay?"
I glared at him. "No. You owe me lunch now."
He grinned. "Done. Anything for you, boss."
Daxton shook his head, finally smiling, which I thought I hadn't seen in ages. I couldn't help but smile.
And just like that—The moment passed. We headed to class.
Daxton was focused on the lecture, taking notes as if his life depended on it.
But Sammy and I? We were busy texting, and this was his first message.
Sammy: So… did u call ur neighbour boy last night? 👀
Milie: Don't. He's a jerk.
Sammy: Even jerks have a soft side, yk.
Even jerks fall for girls fr.
Milie: 🙄🙄
Sammy: Wow… such depth. such emotion.
Milie: Thought u liked silence.
Sammy: I thought I'd finally see u go on a date for once 💀
Milie: Sorry to disappoint
his dreams = cancelled
yours too
Sammy: WAIT
He asked u out???
Sammy: AND U SAID NO???
Milie: 🙄🙄
Sammy: Nah, you're actually impossible.
Milie: Cry about it
Sammy: Go to hell
Milie: Same ❤️
I bit back a smile and locked my phone.
By the time classes ended, Daxton and Sammy went to grab food for me. I stayed back, scrolling through TikTok, laughing at something stupid—
When my phone buzzed with a message from an unknown number.
Unknown: Still mad?
I frowned.
Me: Who is this?
Unknown: That hurts.
I straightened up, wondering who it could be.
Unknown: After everything we've been through? The trauma? The emotional damage?
I rolled my eyes.
Me: Alan?
Me: How did you get my number?
Alan: I have my sources.
Of course he did. Before I could reply, A soft knock on the classroom door. I looked up.
And there he was. Standing outside with the same irritating half-smile.
I didn't react. Just looked back at my phone.
Me: Sorry. I don't talk to jerks.
He chuckled, yet replied to my message.
Alan: Ouch. That hurts.
Me: Good. Mission successful. Now leave.
He chuckled again, stepping away from the door only to appear again a second later, and walking in.
"Bold of you to ignore me when I'm literally standing right here," he said, stopping beside my desk.
"I meant it," I replied flatly. "Don't talk to me."
"Okay," he nodded easily. "Then I won't."
Before I could respond, he placed a small paper bag on my desk. "Just accept this."
I frowned, looking at it.
"What’s this?"
"An apology," he said. "For morning."
"I don't want it. Take it back."
"I request."
I looked up at him. He just stood there. Calm, annoyingly calm.
I pushed the bag slightly toward him. He pushed it back. My eyes narrowed.
"I'm sorry." He said in a gentle tone.
"God. This guy."
I exhaled sharply and glanced at the bag again. That's when I noticed it— I'm sorry, written in slightly messy handwriting.