Chapter 51

After the movie,as the guys got ready to leave,Jon pulled me into the hall.Before I knew it,he pressed me against the wall and braced his hands on either side of my head.He leaned in so close,I felt his breath,and licked my lips out of nervousness.

“I can’t quit thinking about you,Aaron,”he whispered as one of his hands played with my hair.“I know I once told you I wouldn’t go after a guy that likes someone else,but you’re so sexy and cute and sweet and I can’t wait to take you to the prom.I want to make you forget about that other guy.”

“You think I’m sexy?”I asked,surprised.

He chuckled.“Fuck,yes.”He pulled his hand from my hair and cupped my cheek.He leaned in and I closed my eyes,my heart pounding.His lips brushed mine.I didn’t see fireworks,but I shivered.

I opened my eyes to find him smiling at me.“So cute.”

I waved him off.“Thanks for all the help today.”

“No problem.Any time.”He backed away and met Kevin at the front door.“I’ll talk to you soon and we’ll figure out plans for prom.”

Jeff looked at me with surprise,then narrowed his eyes at Jon.But he didn’t say anything to them other than,“Good night.”

“I’m going to go put sheets on my bed,”I said.“I grabbed some from the house.”

“My mom already did.”

“Oh?That was nice of her.”I rubbed at my face and eyes,stifling a yawn.“I’m exhausted.Been a long day.Night.”

“I’ll be up in a few minutes.”

I made my way upstairs,feeling his gaze on me the whole time.When I entered my room,I saw that his mother had indeed put sheets and a blanket on the mattress.I stripped to my boxers before crawling into bed.

I was torn between anger with Jeff and excitement about my date with Jon.I just didn’t understand what Jeff had against Jon.And if I couldn’t go to prom with the man I wanted,then what was wrong with going with a hot guy who liked me?

It occurred to me maybe Jeff liked Jon,but that didn’t really make sense.He’d confessed he liked someone way before we even met Jon.Plus from what he told me about his type,Jon wasn’t it.

Jealousy ripped through me as I wondered about the mystery guy.If Jeff would just rip off the Band-Aid,so to speak,and tell this guy how he felt,the guy would probably be over the moon.It was almost as if Jeff had no idea how hot he was.

But a secret part of me felt glad he hadn’t made a move yet.I should’ve felt guilty for feeling that way,but I couldn’t bring myself to think about it.The longer he waited to tell this guy,the longer I could keep my secret crush on him alive.

That made me a terrible friend,but I couldn’t help it.I wanted him to be mine.I wasn’t even sure when it had happened,except that this year I’d started thinking of him differently.Noticing him in another light.Plus,after how he’d taken care of me and my sister,and how he’d done everything he could to help me through this hard time,how could I not fall for him?

My body reacted around him all the time.It took only a look or a word from him,even a brush of his body against mine,and I’d turn hard as a rock.Finding out he was gay made the fantasy more real,but I knew the reality could never be.If he had ever felt the same,he would have told me by now.

As I tossed and turned in my old bed—in my new room—I couldn’t stop thinking about Jeff.I hoped we could be roommates in college,but I wasn’t sure.Once he started dating,it might be too hard for me to see him with other guys.

Jon,however,had made his interest in me clear.I smiled in the dark.He was a nice guy and definitely sexy.I wouldn’t mind touching those abs.But I didn’t feel for him the way I felt for Jeff.

I turned onto my side and fluffed my pillow,but I couldn’t get comfortable.It took a while before it dawned on me why I couldn’t fall asleep.Jeff wasn’t in bed with me.I didn’t have his arms wrapped around me.

This new thing we had done at night—the holding each other—had been unexpected,but never felt wrong.In fact,it felt so right it was hard to believe we hadn’t slept like that before.Spooning against him every night seemed so natural.Even though we’d never talked about it,he seemed to feel the same way.

I closed my eyes and tried counting backward from one hundred,but when I got to one,I was even more frustrated than when I’d started.

If Jeff was asleep,maybe I could sneak into his bed.It wouldn’t be the same as when he held me,but it would be better than being alone.My mind made up,I climbed out of bed and slowly opened my door.I tiptoed down the hall to his room.

The door was closed.What if I woke him?What if he doesn’t want me in there?

My hand hovered over the handle until I took a deep breath and forced myself to turn it.The door opened easily,so I stepped inside and closed it behind me.

I looked at the bed to find Jeff sitting up,facing me.His eyes glittered in the moonlight streaming in through the blinds.I froze.Busted.

“What are you doing?”His voice sounded strange.Kind of gravelly.

I shrugged.“I couldn’t sleep.”I knew I sounded lame,but took a few tentative steps toward the bed.

“Why?”

I threw up my hands.“I don’t like my new room.I don’t like my old bed anymore.I…things are different and…I want to sleep in here.”It was all true,but it wasn’t the whole truth.I missed him.

I scrambled onto the bed and slid under the covers,facing away from him.He rolled over and pulled me close.

Finally.This is what I needed.

“What do you mean,‘things are different’?”he whispered.

“Why were you sitting up?Couldn’t you sleep either?”I asked,evading his question.

He stayed silent.

“Fine.We’ve never lied to each other,right?”

“Right,”he whispered.

Panic welled up in my chest,but I ignored it.“I couldn’t sleep because I missed you.”

His body begin to tremble,and I turned to face him.His wet lashes took me aback.

“What’s wrong,Jeff?If you don’t want me to sleep here,I can leave.I didn’t mean to upset you.”I closed my eyes,fighting against the notion that he thought me pathetic.“I’ll go.”

He only tightened his grip.“Stay.”

I sighed.I couldn’t figure him out,but I didwant to be in his arms.I settled into my usual position and he pulled me closer,resting his head on top of mine.

I closed my eyes,listening to Jeff’s breathing,as sleep finally came for me.