Chapter 16: Chapter Sixteen

I followed the man down the hallway, my body aching with each step. The sound of my bare feet against the cold floor echoed in the silence. My heart pounded in my chest, my mind racing with fear over what Theo wanted.

When we reached the door, the man knocked once before opening it and stepping aside. I hesitated for a moment, then entered the room.

Theo was sitting at his desk, his chair leaning back, a cigarette between his fingers. He took a long drag, exhaling the smoke slowly, his eyes never leaving me as I stood in the doorway.

"Well, well," he said, his voice dripping with sarcasm. "You look better than before. Did you finally get some rest?"

His smirk sent a chill down my spine. The smoke from his cigarette swirled around him, adding to the oppressive atmosphere in the room.

I didn't respond, too afraid to speak. Every word I said felt like it would make things worse.

Theo took another drag from his cigarette, the smoke swirling around him as he watched me. He leaned forward slightly, his eyes cold and calculating. "Have you eaten?" he asked, his tone casual, but there was an underlying menace in his voice.

I blinked, confused for a moment. "What do you mean?" I whispered, my voice shaky.

Theo's smirk widened as he leaned back in his chair again, flicking the ash off his cigarette. "Carino," he drawled, his voice dripping with mock sweetness. "Don't play dumb.

I know Bell snuck you a piece of toast." His smirk twisted into something darker, more sinister. "You think I wouldn't notice something like that? How sweet of her to care for you."

I felt my heart race, panic rising in my chest. There was nowhere to hide. "I… I didn't-" I stammered, but the words faltered on my lips. Whatever I said would just make things worse.

Theo leaned forward, tapping the ash from his cigarette onto the plate on his desk. "You know," he said, his voice laced with amusement, "I could punish her for that. But you know what? I think I'll let you decide. Tell me, Sofia-what do you think I should do with Bell?"

My stomach twisted in fear at his words. The thought of Theo hurting Bell made my chest tighten, and I struggled to breathe. My voice caught in my throat as I tried to find the right words to stop this from getting worse.

"I… I don't know," I whispered, my voice trembling. "Please, don't hurt her."

Theo leaned back in his chair, the smirk never leaving his face. He took another drag from his cigarette, the smoke curling in the air between us. "You don't know?" he repeated, his voice low and dangerous. "Well, that's not good enough, is it, Sofia?"

I stood there, my hands shaking at my sides, knowing there was no easy way out of this. My heart hammered in my chest as the seconds ticked by, the silence between us suffocating.

"Tell me what you want me to do," Theo pressed, his eyes cold and calculating. "I want to hear it from you."

I swallowed hard, feeling trapped. There was no answer that could make this better, but I had to say something, anything to keep Bell safe. "Please, Theo, I beg you," I whispered. "Just leave her out of this. It's me you want, not her."

Theo stared at me for a long moment, his expression unreadable.

Theo exhaled the last of his cigarette smoke, his eyes locked on me, cold and unfeeling. "Carino," he said softly, his voice dripping with mock affection. "That's not how the game works. Bell has to be punished. Pick a punishment, or else…" He paused for a moment, letting the threat hang in the air. "I will choose one for her."

My chest tightened, and I felt my stomach drop. The weight of his words hung over me like a dark cloud, suffocating all rational thought. I couldn't breathe. I couldn't think. All I could focus on was Bell-innocent Bell-and the horrible consequences she might face because of my actions.

I opened my mouth to speak, to beg him to spare her, but no words came out. The room felt colder by the second, and my mind raced, desperate for some way out.

Theo didn't give me time to think. He leaned back in his chair and waved toward the door. "Bring her in," he ordered flatly.

A few moments later, the door swung open, and two of his men stepped inside, dragging Bell behind them. Her eyes were wide with fear, her body trembling as they forced her forward. She looked at me, her face filled with confusion and terror, but I couldn't say anything to reassure her. The guilt I felt gnawed at me, and I knew I was powerless to protect her.

Theo looked from me to Bell, his eyes calculating. "Now, Sofia," he said, his voice slow and deliberate, "what will it be? What punishment will you choose for your friend?"

I trembled, my breath coming in short gasps as I looked at Bell, her wide eyes filled with fear. I felt a pang of guilt so sharp it nearly crippled me.

"Please, Theo," I begged, my voice breaking. "Don't hurt her. Hurt me instead. Please, don't do anything to her."

Theo stared at me for a long, tense moment, his cold eyes studying my every movement. Slowly, he leaned back in his chair, exhaling a cloud of smoke that seemed to hang in the air between us. "Carino," he said, his voice soft but filled with something darker. "I've already hurt you enough."

I froze, my heart pounding harder as I looked at him.

"Take a look at yourself," he continued, his gaze flicking over me briefly. "Any more punishment, and you could die. I'm not ready to lose you-not yet."

His words hit me like a cold wave, and I felt my knees weaken. The thought of Theo caring about me, in his twisted way, made my head spin. But Bell… she was still in danger.

"Please," I whispered again, my voice hoarse, desperate. "Don't do this."

Theo stared at me for a moment, his expression unreadable, then slowly began to count.

"One," he said, his voice calm but carrying an underlying threat.

I felt the seconds slip away, my mind racing. Bell's terrified gaze locked with mine, and all I could think about was how much I wanted to protect her. I couldn't let him hurt her.

"Two," Theo continued, his voice still cold, like he was enjoying every second of this.

I could feel the weight of time pressing down on me. Each number made my chest tighten, my heart pounding harder with each passing second. I had to make a decision, but I couldn't bring myself to say the words that might seal Bell's fate.

"Three," Theo's voice echoed in the room, the tension growing unbearable.

I could barely breathe, the air thick with the anticipation of what was about to come. My thoughts were clouded with fear and panic. I couldn't think straight, I could only focus on Bell and the crushing guilt that was threatening to break me.

"Four," Theo said slowly, still watching me intently.

I felt my body shaking, but I couldn't move. I was frozen, trapped in the moment, unable to act.

"Five," he continued, his eyes glinting with amusement, knowing he had me in this twisted game.

"Six," I heard, and I could feel my resolve crumbling.

I couldn't do this. I couldn't make this choice. Bell didn't deserve to suffer because of me.

"Seven," Theo said, his patience wearing thin, and I could feel the tension rise even more.

"Eight," his voice was getting louder now, and I knew I was running out of time. I had to say something. I had to do something.

"Nine," Theo counted, his expression growing colder, and my heart skipped a beat.

"Ten," he said finally, a dangerous edge to his voice. "Time's up. I'll decide what happens to her now."

My heart sank, knowing that whatever happened next, it was too late. I had failed.

Theo's expression shifted as he leaned forward in his chair, his eyes cold and calculating. He reached down to the side of his desk, and my heart stopped when I saw him pull out a gun.