Chapter 39: Human Nature

Oliver paced his room, a towel knotted low around his waist. He raked a hand through his hair, muttering curses under his breath. He’d prepared his pants, shirt, and hoodie on the bed, cursing again when the towel shifted precariously.

His body wasn’t helping. Even after splashing cold water on his face, he was still hard, the faint tent in the towel an obvious reminder. He growled at himself, angry that a single accident could leave him so worked up.

A knock at the door made him freeze.

“Shit,” he whispered, fumbling to adjust the towel before cracking the door open.

Del stood there with arms crossed, chin slightly tilted. Oliver’s heart skipped. “Uh… hey,” he managed, clearing his throat. “Do you need anything?”

“If it were about groceries or laundry, I’d write it on the board. This is different. I wanted to say it face-to-face.”

Oliver straightened, trying not to look like a deer cornered in his own doorway. “Okay… what’s up?”

She exhaled, a quick puff of air, like she was forcing herself to just spit it out. “About this morning.”

His stomach dropped. “Del, I’m—”

“Don’t say you’re sorry,” she cut in. “It wasn’t your fault.”

Oliver shut his mouth, caught between relief and confusion.

“I know what it was,” she went on, her eyes flicking briefly downward before snapping back up. Her cheeks held the faintest pink, though her voice stayed steady. “It’s biology. You were asleep. And I was the one who asked you to stay. If you ended up in my bed, that’s on me. And… what happened after that wasn’t something you could control.”

For once, Oliver was speechless. He’d expected icy distance, maybe even anger. What he hadn’t expected was her calmly standing there, acknowledging what had happened with the kind of plain honesty only she seemed capable of.

Also, there was something different in her tone. Softer, almost. Less armor than when they’d first met. Back then, every word out of her mouth had been edged with defense, like she had to keep him at arm’s length. But now… now her voice carried a looseness, a quiet willingness to let him closer.

And he felt it. Not just in her words, but in the space between them.

“Thanks for saying that,” he said finally. “I… wasn’t expecting you to.”

She shifted on her feet, her gaze flicking away for a moment. “I just don’t want you making it into a big deal. It wasn’t.”

Oliver’s lips twitched, wanting to tease, but he swallowed it down. Her expression warned him not to push.

Then, the silence stretched. Neither of them seemed sure what else to add.

“Right, well… see you later?” Oliver said, scratching the back of his neck.

“Yeah,” she replied, just as quick. “Later. I mean… You live here. Sure.”

She turned, heading back down the hall. He shut the door with a sigh, pressing his forehead briefly against it. Then, deciding there was only one cure for the lingering tension, he hit the shower.

Steam filled the small bathroom, the spray pounding against his skin until his head finally cleared. By the time he stepped out, he felt more like himself. Upstairs, he tugged on his jeans, a shirt, and a hoodie, slinging his backpack over one shoulder before heading back down again.

When he reached the kitchen, Del was already at the table, hunched over a bowl of cereal. She didn’t look up right away, spoon moving lazily, but when she did, her eyes flicked over him like she’d been expecting him.

“Cereal’s on the counter if you want some,” she said, casual as anything.

Oliver grinned faintly. “Thanks. I’ll pick up groceries before I come back later.”

She tilted her head. “Where are you going?”

He shifted the strap on his shoulder. “A friend of mine needs help with a computer.”

Her expression gave nothing away, but she nodded once and returned to her cereal.

Oliver grabbed a bowl and slid into the chair across from her. Just like the night they’d shared ice cream, the silence settled in comfortably, broken only by the soft clink of spoons against their bowls.

Then, out of nowhere, Del set her spoon down. “Thanks,” she said.

Oliver glanced up. “For what?”

Her mouth twitched, but she shook her head. “For last night.”

His spoon hovered, then he slowly set it down. “Oh.”

“I don’t like people much. I’m sure you already know that, and I’ve kind of made that obvious,” she continued, her eyes fixed on her bowl. “But I’m not ungrateful. You stayed. You didn’t have to.”

For once, Oliver didn’t rush to fill the silence. He just watched her, taking in the honesty. Then, softly, he replied, “You’re welcome.”

The quiet stretched again, the kind that could either be comfortable or dangerous depending on who broke it first. Del, apparently incapable of letting her brain leave things unsaid, cleared her throat.

“And about this morning,” she began.

Oliver groaned instantly, dragging a hand down his face. “Del…”

“I told you, it’s fine,” she cut in quickly, like ripping off a bandage again. “I know what it was. Human nature.”

But something in her tone made him think. It wasn’t just dismissal. There was curiosity there beneath the flat words.

Del wasn’t finished. She studied him across the table, eyes direct in a way that made his stomach knot.

“Truth is…” She hesitated just long enough to make him sweat, then blurted, “I’ve never actually been with a guy, like, ever,” she paused. "I'm a virgin, okay?"

Oliver nearly inhaled his cereal. He coughed, choking.

“Are you okay?” she asked.

He cleared his throat, ears burning. “Yeah, I’m just—uh—go on?”

“So… yeah.” She shrugged, looking ridiculously calm. “I just wanted to say I’m not inconsiderate. I get it. Bodies do what they do. I guess what I’m really saying is… although I’m technically a virgin, we’re cool. I’m cool. So…”

Oliver stared at her, certain his face was doing a thousand expressions at once. Virgin. Cool. We’re cool.

And across the table, Del raised her brows, as if confessing her virginity to a guy was no bigger deal than running out of milk.

But Oliver nearly forgot how to breathe. It wasn’t just the confession—it was the fact she’d given it to him. Handed it over casually, like she didn’t realize what that kind of knowledge would do to a man who’d already been circling her in his head for weeks.

Now it lived under his skin. The thought of being her first and her only seared hotter than he dared admit. He slammed a wall up in his mind before it could spiral further, forcing his spoon to scrape idly at his cereal as if he weren’t combusting inside.

But the truth was out. She had placed it in his lap so simply, so carelessly, and now it pulsed through him. His brain wouldn’t stop now.

Del picked up her spoon again and dug back into her cereal. And Oliver sat there, stunned, realizing this was a turning point. Whatever walls she’d built, she’d just let him see past one of the biggest.