Chapter 25: A Foot In the Door

The two men stood across from each other, a current of tension charging the air between them. Oliver’s arm rested against the doorframe, his relaxed posture at odds with the flint in his eyes. Toby didn’t shrink back. He simply smiled—too calm, too confident—as if he were the one answering the door to someone else’s home.

Del appeared a moment later. Her eyes landed on Toby, and all color seemed to drain from her face.

“Toby,” she said, voice stiff. “What the hell are you doing here?”

Toby smiled faintly, like they were old friends running into each other at a grocery store. “Hey. Don’t freak out.”

Her jaw clenched. “How did you even know where I live?”

There was a tremor in her tone now. Not fear—Del wasn’t the type to scare easily—but something close. Discomfort. Panic. Like someone had breached a line she never wanted crossed.

Toby lifted his hands in mock surrender. “Relax, Del. I saw you get out of a cab a few months ago. I was in the neighborhood, visiting my uncle.”

Del narrowed her eyes. “Which uncle?”

He didn’t miss a second. “Roger Lim. He’s married to the lady who owns that plant nursery two blocks down. House with the maroon gate and the tree in front.”

Del blinked, visibly thrown. She did know that house. Mrs. Lim had given her chili seedlings last summer.

Toby tilted his head, as if that settled everything. “I’ve known for a while. Just never had a reason to drop by.”

Oliver let out a quiet scoff but didn’t say anything—yet. Del folded her arms, not satisfied.

“What street?” she asked.

“Lopez,” Toby said, without hesitation. “Corner lot. They’ve got that beat-up Honda with the dented bumper parked out front.”

Again, Del’s face shifted—this time to reluctant confirmation. She knew that car.

“Okay,” she said tightly. “So your story checks out. But that doesn’t explain why you’re here.”

This time, Oliver stepped forward, his voice calm but unmistakably firmer than before. “Yeah. Why are you here?”

There was a warning in his tone. Del glanced at him quickly, noting the sudden shift in his expression. The warmth was gone, replaced by something colder. Guarded. Possessive.

Toby looked between them, smile twitching. “Well, I was in the neighborhood again. Just left Uncle Roger’s. Thought I’d stop by. Since Del finally agreed to grab a coffee with me…” He turned back to her. “I figured I’d ask if you had a favorite place.”

The second he said coffee, Oliver’s shoulders stiffened. It was subtle, but Del caught it.

She sighed and rubbed her forehead. “Toby, I don’t care where we go. Just pick any damn place.”

Toby raised a brow. “You sure?”

“The only reason I agreed,” she said flatly, “was so you’d stop asking and leave me alone. So let’s make this clear: one coffee. Then that’s it. We’re done. You leave me alone.”

Toby’s grin didn’t fade. “Fair enough. But I plan to change your mind before the coffee gets cold.”

Del shot him a look. “You won’t.”

Oliver, still standing by the door, didn’t try to hide his scowl anymore.

Toby’s eyes drifted past Del, landing on Oliver, who hadn’t moved from his spot near the doorway. His brows lifted, just enough to look surprised. “Didn’t know you had someone else living here with you,” he said, his tone casual but loaded with implication. “Is he your cousin or something?”

“No. He’s my housemate.” Del’s lips thinned. “He just moved in today.”

Toby blinked. “Really?” His gaze slid to Oliver again, like he was sizing him up all over. “Huh. If I’d known you were looking for one, I might’ve volunteered.”

Del didn’t bother hiding the irritation on her face. “You can leave now.”

Toby opened his mouth like he had something else to say, but her expression must’ve finally gotten through to him. He hesitated—just for a second—then nodded and stepped back. “Alright. I’ll speak with you tomorrow about the coffee.”

“You don’t have to,” she said, already closing the door.

Toby just chuckled under his breath and turned away.

The moment the door clicked shut, Oliver turned to her, his posture shifting. The relaxed, playful air he usually carried had vanished.

“You don’t like him?” he said.

Del crossed her arms. “Isn’t it obvious enough?”

“You just agreed to go out for coffee with him.”

She exhaled through her nose. “I already explained it. I said yes so he’d stop asking. He’s been at it for months, Oliver.”

Oliver stepped in closer, not aggressively, just—anchored. “Yeah, and people like him? You give them an inch, they take the whole damn road. What if he asks again? What if he doesn’t stop?”

Del’s mouth opened—then shut. Her fingers flexed against her arms. Annoyance flickered across her face, not at him, but at the fact that he had a point. A good one.

Her eyes narrowed. “Why do you even care?”

“Because you’re letting him push you into something you don’t want.”

“I’m handling it,” she snapped.

Oliver scoffed under his breath. “That’s what handling it looks like?”

Del’s arms dropped to her sides, her voice rising. “Why are you questioning my decisions like you know me?”

He stared at her, but she didn’t stop.

“You just moved in. You don’t know anything about me. So don’t act like you’ve got me figured out.”

Oliver didn’t flinch, but his jaw set. “You’re right. I don’t know everything. But I know this—if you don’t like someone, you don’t force yourself to do what they want just to make things easier.”

She laughed, short and humorless. “Is that so?”

“Yeah,” he said, voice clipped.

Del stepped back, eyes hard. “Then explain why you are living here. I don’t like you, either.”

Silence.

Then Del turned without another word and walked up the stairs, her footsteps steady but her face blank.

She didn’t look back.

He stayed rooted in place, staring after her and not saying anything else because she was right.