Chapter 18: Two Cinnamon Rolls
Del sat on the couch with her arms crossed, back rigid against the cushion. She’d opened the door for Liza ten minutes ago and hadn’t said a word since. The silence hung in the air like smoke, and Liza, to her credit, was trying her best not to suffocate in it.
“I brought cinnamon rolls,” Liza said, holding up the brown paper bag like it was some kind of peace treaty.
Del didn’t even glance at it. “You can feed them to your harmless Labrador.”
Liza groaned and dropped onto the armchair, letting her bag of offerings plop onto the coffee table. “Okay. I deserved that. But in my defense, I did try to tell you.”
“No, you tried to manipulate me,” Del said flatly. “Which worked right up until I opened the damn door and found some guy standing there, soaked through like he just walked out of a storm.”
Liza covered her mouth with both hands, trying—and failing—not to laugh. “Oh my gosh—he must’ve looked so hot.”
Del gave her a flat look. “Don’t.”
“I’m sorry, okay?” Liza said, leaning forward. “I didn’t mean to spring him on you like that. I just—I really thought he’d be a good fit. He’s looking for a place, you had a room, it just made sense.”
Del didn’t answer. She picked at the seam of her pants, jaw tight.
“And I swear,” Liza continued, softer now, “I wasn’t trying to pawn off my weekly visits or dump some random guy on you. I’m still coming here every week, whether you like it or not.”
Del side-eyed her. “You better.”
Liza grinned. “Of course. Who else is going to judge my life choices and call me out on my bullshit while serving me tea like a disapproving librarian?”
Del raised an eyebrow. “You want tea?”
“God, yes. Please.”
Del stood, walked to the kitchen in silence, and Liza let herself exhale. She waited until Del came back with two mugs and a small plate for the cinnamon rolls before she spoke again.
“For what it’s worth… I did have a thing for him. Like, when I first joined the firm.”
Del blinked. “Seriously?”
“Oh yeah. First month? Total crush. I mean, tall, sweet, and very attractive face, disarming smile, and actually listens when you talk? It was textbook. But then,” she shrugged, “it just kind of fizzled.”
“Why?” Del asked before she could stop herself.
Liza tilted her head. “He was too nice.”
Del gave her a look. “So you’re insane.”
“No, I just like… spice. Trouble. Something a little off. You know—guys who look like they haven’t slept in weeks and possibly have a secret gambling debt.”
Del snorted. “You have a problem.”
Liza smirked. “You think I’m kidding, but I’m not. Oliver’s the kind of guy who’d walk you home, send you good morning texts, and ask if you’ve eaten. And don’t get me wrong, that’s lovely, but after a while, I realized I wasn’t into lovely. I like my men a little... emotionally sun-damaged.”
Then she thought of Wyatt.
Del leaned back, sipping her tea. “So you saw Oliver as a golden retriever and decided you actually prefer a wounded Doberman instead.”
Liza clapped a hand over her heart. “Wow. That’s actually perfect.”
“You’re insane,” Del said again, but there was a faint pull at the corner of her mouth.
“I know,” Liza said brightly. “Anyway, Oliver can be a little flirty and maybe too friendly, but genuinely good. And he really does need a place.”
Del stared at her mug, then muttered, “Still would’ve been nice to know he was a guy.”
“I didn’t think it mattered.”
“Well, it does to me!”
“So, he showed up dripping wet, huh? Did you catch a look at those pants?”
“Shut up.”
They sat in silence for a while, the tea cooling on the table between them. Then Liza tilted her head. “Are you going to rent it to him?”
“Well, he’s asking for a one-month probation. He actually likes the house. The room.”
“Well, give him a chance.”
Del didn’t tell her that she had already messaged Oliver. And soon they were back to their regular programming—Liza curled into the couch with her phone held up in front of her face, Del half-lounging with her laptop balanced on her thighs, fingers flying over the keys. The room was quiet except for the soft tap of keys and the occasional dull hum from Liza’s phone speaker.
“You know,” Liza said, chewing thoughtfully as she scrolled, “I think people are actually getting worse at murder.”
Del didn’t look up. “That’s a weird take.”
“No, I mean—between phone pings, street cams, Ring doorbells, traffic light sensors, and random people oversharing on TikTok, how are they still trying to hide bodies like it’s 1995?”
“I don’t know,” Del said without looking up. “Maybe murderers have become smarter, too.”
“Yeah,” Liza muttered. “Like this one, a lawyer in the city has been missing for, like, weeks now, and still no new updates.”
That got Del’s attention. She paused her typing and glanced over. “Ariana?”
“Yeah.” Liza turned the volume up a notch. “Apparently, they found out she was sleeping with her client. Messy.”
Del raised a brow. “Married?”
“Mm-hmm. Husband’s now a prime suspect. The guy looks like a decent person and has good money, but apparently, he threatened to expose her and the client before she disappeared. Emails, texts, all that. It’s getting nasty.”
Del leaned her head back against the couch and stared at the ceiling for a second. “So he snapped.”
“Allegedly,” Liza said with her usual dramatic flair. “They don’t have a body. Just her car, ditched near a highway exit. Purse in the trunk, phone missing. No security cam footage. It’s like she vanished mid-errand.”
“Maybe she did.”
Liza glanced at her. “You think she ran?”
“No.” Del’s gaze dropped back to her screen. “I think people don’t just vanish unless someone makes sure they do.”
Liza chewed the inside of her cheek and stared at her phone. “It’s weird, though. This documentary said the city’s missing persons reports have gone up over the past five years. Not by hundreds or anything, but… steady.”
“That’s comforting.”
“It’s probably nothing,” Liza said quickly, trying to wave it off. “More people, more reports. It’s just strange. Like, you'd think with all this tech, fewer people would go missing. But it’s the opposite.”
Del didn’t respond immediately. She stared at her laptop screen, but her focus had already drifted. A thread of unease had started to wind its way through her stomach, slow and silent.