Chapter 15: The One Who Showed Up

Del opened the door wider only because she was too stunned to close it fast enough.

“…Oliver?”

He stared at her, blinking through wet lashes. Rain dripped from his jaw. “Wait—April? Stella?”

Her stomach dropped. Of all the people she expected to show up at her door, he was not even on the list. “Why are you here?”

“I—uh,” he shifted his weight, bag sagging from his shoulder, “Liza gave me this address. Said I could drop by to check the place out?”

Del’s eyes narrowed. “You're Liza’s co-worker?”

“…You’re Del?” Oliver looked genuinely thrown. “The one who ditched her own birthday party. It's something Liza said a few months ago.” He laughed softly, then instantly winced at himself. “Um, never mind.

“Liza didn’t mention that you were a guy,” Del said and, on instinct, started pushing the door closed. “Well, this is a mistake. Goodbye.”

But before the door could shut, Oliver stepped forward—not forcefully, just enough to stay in the gap.

“Wait—can I just… Can I stay here till the rain stops?” His voice had softened. “I didn’t bring an umbrella. And my cab dropped me off a few blocks away because of the flood.”

Del looked at him—sopping wet, drops of water now puddling under his shoes on the porch tiles. His tie hung uselessly from his neck.

She let out a breath through her nose. “Fine. But stay near the door. Don’t touch anything.”

“Wouldn’t dream of it.”

He stepped in carefully, dripping water on her entryway rug. Del closed the door behind him and immediately regretted it. The smell of wet cotton and rain came in with him, mixing into her space.

“I hate to ask,” Oliver said, glancing down at himself, “but do you, by any chance, have a spare shirt or something? I’m not trying to start a puddle in your living room.”

She gave him a look. “Do I look like someone who lives with a boyfriend?”

“Right,” he nodded. “Had to try.”

Del rubbed her temple, then gestured toward the hallway. “The bathroom’s that way. Just… wait there. I’ll get something.”

She went upstairs and yanked open her dresser drawers with more energy than necessary. The nerve of him. Showing up like this. Smiling like it was normal. Acting like he hadn’t flirted with her over coffee under a false name and then vanished for a week.

She grabbed an old towel, one of her oversized T-shirts—the navy one with the stretched collar—and a pair of sweatpants that barely stayed up on her anymore.

When she padded back downstairs, she knocked on the bathroom door once before nudging it open.

What greeted her was Oliver—shirtless, with his back to her.

She froze.

His skin glistened with rainwater, and her eyes, traitorously, took in more than they should have. Broad shoulders. A tapered waist. The kind of back that looked sculpted, not accidental. She didn’t even know people like him had backs like that in real life. She spotted faint scars—thin, pale lines near his shoulder blades. Old. He was reaching for the hand towel near the sink, his posture relaxed.

Del didn’t speak. She shoved the clothes and towel onto the small counter beside the sink.

He turned slightly, catching her eye in the mirror. “Thanks.”

She didn’t respond. Just turned and walked away before her brain could keep cataloging his abs.

In the living room, she dropped onto the couch and snatched up her phone. Liza answered on the second ring.

“What the hell, Liza.”

“What now?”

“Your ‘co-worker’ is Oliver.”

A pause. “Wait—You knew Oliver?”

“Your rain-soaked co-worker is currently half-naked in my bathroom. Liza, I thought you said it was a girl.”

“I never said that.”

“You said she was your co-worker.”

“I never said she! I just used neutral language!”

“You used ‘she’ the entire time!”

Liza was quiet for a second. “Okay… maybe I did. But come on, you know English isn’t my first—”

“Don’t give me the ‘language barrier’ crap right now.”

“Okay, okay, fair. That’s weak. My bad.”

Del pinched the bridge of her nose. “Well, now he’s here. In my house, and I gave him my clothes. Do you see how this is a problem?”

“Oh, so you gave him clothes? That’s kind of romantic—”

“Liza!”

“Okay, okay, sorry. Look, I swear I wasn’t trying to trick you. But since he’s already there…” Liza’s voice softened, almost pleading. “Can you please be nice to him? Just—try?”

Del scowled at nothing. “This isn’t some setup.”

“I know! I know. But you like him, don’t you?”

“I don’t know him.”

“Well, I do. He’s a good guy. Smart, funny, and respectful. Like, painfully respectful. And he’s super sweet. Like a Labrador. A very hot Labrador! But ignore the puppy-handsome face—focus on the person, okay? I promise he’s not a creep. He sure as hell doesn’t bring random girls home. He doesn’t even date, Del. There won’t be any girlfriend randomly dropping by, if that’s what you’re worried about.”

Del paused. “Wait, why doesn’t he date?”

“I don’t know. Trauma? High standards? Emotional constipation?” Liza sighed. “Point is, he’s safe. And I wouldn’t be pushing this if I didn’t think maybe… maybe this could be something good for you.”

Del didn’t answer. She just stared at the floor for a long second, then quietly ended the call.

She turned—only to find Oliver already in the living room.

He looked… clean. And weirdly comfortable in her oversized navy shirt and saggy sweatpants that were just slightly snug across his hips and calves. His hair was still wet but pushed back, and he was bent over, unzipping his soaked bag. He pulled out a laptop and phone, both damp around the edges, and gently set them on the coffee table.

When he looked up, they both froze.

For a few seconds, no one spoke.

Then Oliver offered a crooked smile. “So… Del.”

She raised a brow.

“I finally get your real name,” he said, soft and sheepish. “Not gonna lie, I had bets with myself. I thought it was something floral. Like Iris. Or Sage.”

“You lost.”

“I did.” He rubbed the back of his neck. “Del. It suits you.”

She crossed her arms. “Are you homeless?”

His smile faltered, caught off-guard. “Uh—about to be.”

Del tilted her head, expression unreadable. “Seriously?”

“Yeah. The place I was staying got sold. The new owner wants to gut the building or something. I’ve got until Friday to be out.” He let out a short breath. “So… this whole apartment hunt thing? It’s kind of desperate at this point.”

Del studied him, her eyes flicking to the towel around his neck and the way his shoulders were slightly hunched like he expected her to throw him back out into the rain.

They stood there, the soft hum of rain tapping on the windows between them. Then Del sighed and dropped her arms. “You want something to drink?”

Oliver blinked. “Wait—was that an offer?”

“Liza begged me to be nice.” She turned toward the kitchen. “Don’t push it.”

A smile slowly crept onto his face as he followed.