Chapter 140: The Trust Plan
The question landed between them. Oliver rested his fork on the edge of his plate.
Del’s voice stayed steady. “How many rotten fruits have you removed?”
He didn’t answer directly. “Toby wasn’t the first,” he said after a moment. “And he wasn’t the only one.”
The confirmation settled over Del like cold water. She swallowed and forced herself to keep her voice calm. “How many?”
Oliver picked up his glass of water and took a drink instead of answering. Then he leaned back in his chair.
“You remember the nights you had nightmares.”
Del frowned slightly. “What?”
“You’d wake up shaking. You’d pretend you were fine, but you weren’t. I used to…cuddle with you until you fell asleep again.”
Her grip tightened slightly around the fork.
“I remember,” he said quietly. “You’d grab my arm like you were afraid I’d disappear.”
Del’s chest tightened despite herself. She forced her voice to stay flat. “What does that have to do with anything?”
“Those moments mattered to me. They mattered more than the rest of it.”
Del looked down at the table. “The rest of what?”
“The purpose I had before you.”
Del didn’t respond. But for a moment, the memory flickered across her mind anyway. The quiet nights they shared. The way he would wrap his arms around her until the panic passed.
The tenderness of those moments tried to rise again, but she pushed the thought away and looked back at him.
“What did you do with Wyatt. And Liza. And the other two men. Did you bury them?”
Oliver studied her face for a long moment. He seemed to be weighing something.
Finally, he exhaled slowly. “Wyatt had already planned the whole thing. He meant for me and Liza to die down there. I found the holes. In another room in the basement.”
Del felt her stomach tighten.
“Graves,” Oliver said quietly. “They had already dug them. So after everything happened, I used one of them.”
Del looked at him carefully. “You buried Wyatt.”
“In the grave he planned for me.”
She held his gaze. “And Liza.”
Oliver paused again. He watched her face closely before answering. “I called 911. I gave them the address of the house. Then I carried you out and left.”
Del leaned forward slightly, “You called the police. And then you ran…taking me with you.”
Oliver nodded.
Del shook her head slowly. “Why didn’t you wait. If you had waited, we could have told them what happened.”
Oliver didn’t speak.
“Wyatt orchestrated everything,” Del continued. “He kidnapped us. He killed Liza.”
Oliver’s jaw tightened.
“You killed him in self-defense…right?”
He shook his head slowly. “That’s not how they’d see it.”
“I would have vouched for you.”
“It wouldn’t have mattered, Del.”
“Why?”
“Because of the video. Wyatt showed you.”
She opened her mouth to argue. Then something clicked. Her eyes widened slightly.
“The house,” she said slowly.
Oliver didn’t respond.
“The basement,” she continued. “That house belongs to you. That place where Toby was tied up… it’s in your name.”
Oliver gave a small nod, and the realization spread across her face.
“So if the police found out about that…” Del leaned back in her seat. “And the video.”
For a moment, none of them said anything.
Then she looked up again. “So what’s your plan?”
Oliver’s eyes narrowed slightly. “What?”
“Wyatt and Liza are dead.”
He said nothing.
“People are going to notice. Someone must have reported us missing by now. So what happens next?”
He leaned back in his chair. “I have a plan.”
“What is it?”
He shook his head. “Not yet. Because it depends on you.”
Del frowned. “What does that mean?”
“I need you to trust me. When you trust me fully, we can move forward.”
Del took a deep breath and stopped talking. Throughout the dinner, Oliver had been gentle. His voice stayed soft, his eyes warm.
“I’m sorry about the other night,” he said quietly. “I got carried away.”
She looked down at her plate, tracing the edge of it with her thumb. “It’s okay. I… I’ve let you.”
Oliver’s gaze dropped to her mouth for a second, then lower, lingering on the way her shirt clung just under her breasts before he dragged his eyes back up.
He reached across the table but stopped short of touching her hand, fingers hovering so close.
“I want you so much, Del,” he said. “I can’t even think straight with how much I want you. But I’d never—” He swallowed. “I’d never do anything you don’t want.”
She wanted to snap that he was already doing the one thing she didn’t want—keeping her here, caging her—but she bit the inside of her cheek and reminded herself to earn the trust.
So she reached for his hand instead.
Her fingertips grazed his knuckles, then she slid her palm over the back of his hand, letting her fingers slip between his. The contact sent a visible shiver through him—his shoulders tightened, breath catching audibly.
Oliver’s eyes darkened. He turned his hand over, catching hers properly, and brought it to his mouth. One by one, he kissed her fingertips, lips parting so she felt the wet heat of his tongue brushing each pad. When he reached her index finger, he didn’t just kiss—he drew it into his mouth, sucking gently, letting his teeth graze the sensitive skin just under the nail before releasing it.
Del’s pulse slammed between her thighs. She hated how her body responded. How the memory of his mouth on other parts of her flared bright and sudden.
“Oh, Del…”
He lowered her hand but didn’t let go. Instead, he pressed her palm flat against his chest so she could feel the hard, rapid thud of his heart under her fingers.
He held her there, not forcing, just letting her feel his heart.
“See what you do to me?” he murmured. “You make my heart beat so fast.”
Inside, Del’s feelings tore in opposite directions. The bruised, swollen image of Toby’s face burned behind her eyes. But right beside it sat the softer, older memories with Oliver, the safety she’d once felt curled against him.
And now this… his heartbeat racing under her palm.
She didn’t pull away.