Chapter 137: The Silence

The days after Oliver’s confession blurred together.

Nothing about the cabin really changed, but the air inside it felt different, heavier somehow. Del stopped speaking to him completely. When Oliver opened the door each morning or sometimes in the afternoon with a tray of food, she acted like he wasn’t there. Some days she lay on her back and stared at the ceiling. Other times, she sat on the edge of the bed with her hands in her lap, looking at the floor like she was trying to think her way out of the room.

When he walked in, she would usually turn toward the wall.

At first, Oliver still tried to talk to her.

He would set the tray down on the small table and linger for a minute, like he always had.

“It’s colder today,” he said once, glancing toward the boarded window. “Probably going to rain later.”

Del didn’t move.

Another time, he nodded toward the door behind him. “Saw a deer near the trees this morning. Just standing there staring at the cabin.”

Still nothing.

Once he pulled the chair closer and sat down across from her. “The lake’s quiet today,” he said. “No wind. Water’s completely flat.”

Del sat on the bed without looking up.

He waited a few seconds before trying again. “You should eat before it gets cold.”

No answer and not a glance.

Eventually, Oliver would stop talking, stand there for another moment as if deciding whether to say something else, and then leave the room again.

The routine repeated itself day after day.

And Del never spoke.

Del gave him nothing.

After a few days, he stopped trying.

He brought meals, let her shower while he waited outside the door, then locked the room again when she finished. Their interactions shrank into silence and routine.

Del’s silence was the only control she had left, and she held onto it tightly.

Her days were filled with the same small loop. She walked the room until her legs grew tired. She pressed on the window boards again, even though she already knew they would not move. She tested the door handle even though it remained locked.

And sleep rarely came.

When it did, it came in short, shallow pieces. And most nights she woke with the same images pushing into her mind. Toby was tied to the chair. The basement.

By the end of the week, the silence between them had turned cold and brittle.

One night, long after the lights outside had gone dark, Del heard the door unlock again. She checked the small clock beside the bed earlier that night. It had been after one in the morning.

When Oliver stepped inside the room, she noticed the smell before anything else.

Beer.

Not overwhelming, but enough that she could tell.

He looked different, too. His hair was messy, his eyes slightly red and puffy. The tiredness in his face made him look rougher.

Del didn’t move from the bed.

Oliver closed the door behind him and leaned against it for a moment like he needed the support.

“You’re awake,” he said quietly.

Del said nothing.

He walked farther into the room and sat on the edge of the bed near her feet. For a few seconds, he didn’t speak. He simply rested his hands together and stared at the floor. Then he reached out and lightly brushed his fingers across the blanket near her leg.

Del pulled her foot away immediately.

Oliver let his hand drop.

The silence stretched between them.

When he finally spoke again, his voice sounded rough. “You’re killing me with this.”

Del turned her head slightly and looked at him for the first time in days.

“With what?”

“The silence.”

She held his gaze for a moment. “You’re upset that I’m not talking.”

Oliver nodded slowly. “It hurts.”

Del let out a quiet breath. “You’re keeping me here against my will.”

"I don’t know what else to say.” Oliver rubbed his face with both hands. “You scare me.”

Del sat up straighter against the wall and stared at him. “I scare you?”

He looked at her again. “When you look at me like that,” he said, “I can’t breathe sometimes. I just… love you, you know?”

“You don’t understand love at all,” Del continued. “You think it’s possession. Control.”

“That’s not what this is.”

“You kill people—”

“Who deserves to be gone?"

“—And you think someone like that can love another person.”

Oliver’s jaw tightened. “So you’re saying I can’t love anyone.”

“I’m saying you don’t know how.”

He looked at her for several seconds before answering. “You’re calling me incapable of love because of what I do.”

“I’m calling you a murderer.”

He shook his head slowly. “You keep reducing it to that.”

“Because that’s what it is.”

He leaned forward slightly. “You’re ignoring the point.”

Del folded her arms. “We’re going in circles.”

“Because you refuse to see the difference.”

“What difference?”

Oliver gestured with one hand. “The police do the same thing.”

“What?”

“They kill people, too.”

“Oliver—”

“Think about it,” he said. “They’re trained to hunt people down. They carry guns. They kick in doors. They shoot suspects.”

“They do that within the law.”

“They get paid to do it.”

“That doesn’t make it the same.”

Oliver shook his head. “They eliminate threats.”

“They arrest people.”

“And when that doesn’t work, they kill them.”

Del stared at him. “You’re comparing yourself to law enforcement now.”

“I’m pointing out the hypocrisy. And I answer to the truth,” Oliver said quietly.

Del looked at him like he had just spoken another language.

“You’ve built an entire philosophy around murder.”

“I’ve built a system around removing people who destroy others.”

“And who decides that?"

Oliver met her eyes. “I do.”

Del shook her head slowly. “You’re unbelievable.”

He leaned back again. “The only difference between them and me is legality.”

“That difference matters.”

“Not to the victims of the people I stop.”

Del pressed her palms against her temples. “This is pointless.”

Oliver watched her quietly for a moment before speaking again. “You said something earlier.”

Del looked up at him, wary.

“You said that if I really loved you…” He began slowly, “I’d set you free.”

“Yes,” she said, her voice tight. “I did.”

Oliver didn’t answer right away. His gaze stayed on her.

Del swallowed. “So?” she asked. “Are you going to do it, Oliver?”