Chapter 99: Chapter Forty Eight
Gabriel
"The number you're trying to call is currently unavailable..." The automated voice echoed in my ear. With a frustrated sigh, I yanked the earbud out and tossed it onto the passenger seat.
I was supposed to be at the hospital, sitting with my family, waiting for my brother to wake up. But instead, I was on my way home—to Arian. She hadn’t answered my calls or spoken a word to me when I’d asked Theresa to pass her the phone. She flat-out refused to speak to me.
I couldn't stop thinking about her.
Theresa had filled me in earlier on what happened—how Penelope had lashed out at Arian and stormed off, ignoring Theresa’s call to come back. It was still hard to believe. Quiet, soft-spoken Penelope snapping like that without provocation?
“Guess you don’t really know someone until you truly know them,” I muttered under my breath.
I had every intention of confronting Penelope later. She’d gone too far, and she owed Arian an apology for being so cold and thoughtless.
I pulled up to the house just before midnight, killed the engine, and got out. After rounding the car, I jogged up the steps and into the house. I didn’t stop until I got to my room, needing a quick shower to wash off the day.
When I came downstairs again, Theresa looked surprised to see me but didn’t ask any questions—which I appreciated—as I made my way toward Arian’s room.
I knocked lightly and waited. Nothing.
“She won’t answer,” Theresa said from behind me. “Kelly’s tried getting her out too, but she won’t come. I think you should give her space for now, sir.”
I sighed, nodding. She was right, though I wanted nothing more than to see her, to make her smile—even if it was just a little. She looked beautiful, whether she smiled with joy or pain.
“How’s GianCarlo, sir?” Theresa asked gently.
“The surgery went well. No fatal injuries—just a dislocated shoulder, three broken ribs, a sprained ankle, and a fractured skull. He’ll recover.”
I knew it sounded like I was brushing off what had happened, and maybe I was. Giancarlo’s accident was serious, and Mom was still devastated. But I couldn’t stop thinking about Arian. Not even now. No matter how hard I tried.
“Thank God,” she said softly.
“Yeah...” I mumbled. “Was she very upset when Penelope said all those things?”
“She was... mostly shocked,” Theresa replied. “She tried to reason with Penelope, but the girl didn’t want to hear it. She left like she hadn’t done anything wrong.” Theresa’s face twisted in disapproval. “Acted like she was some saint. Typical.”
“That’s not like her,” I said, frowning.
“Well, good riddance,” she replied briskly. “Kelly and I can handle everything just fine, Mr. Cruz. We don’t need some high-and-mighty maid prancing around like she owns the place. Rachel tried that too, and I put her in her place quickly.”
I blinked. It was rare to see Theresa this worked up. Normally, she was the calmest presence in the house. I’d wager she was more upset than Arian herself.
“If you’re sure,” I said, a bit amused. “Why not ask Kelly?”
“We’re on the same page,” she replied without hesitation.
“Fine. I won’t hire anyone else.”
“Thank you, sir.” She gave a quick curtsy before walking off.
“Interesting,” I murmured, turning toward my home office. But then—
A soft sound. A door creaked open.
I turned and saw Arian standing in her doorway. She didn’t smile, just looked at me quietly.
I walked back toward her, offering a small smile of my own, hoping she’d mirror it—anything to soften the sadness on her face. But she didn’t.
“Welcome home, Mr. Cruz,” she said.
Her voice lacked any warmth. If anything, she sounded like someone who had given up on everything—like life had drained her, and now she stood at a crossroads, unsure of her next step.
“I just realized we never got around to finishing that movie,” I said, trying to lighten the mood. “We didn’t even make it through episode one.”
She stared at me blankly. It was a random comment, but I hoped it might lift her spirits—just a little. It didn't.
“If you're not too busy, maybe you could join me in the home theater?” I offered.
“I don’t feel like watching a movie,” she replied, shaking her head. She reached into her pocket, pulled out my credit card, and handed it back to me. “I didn’t end up using it.”
“Why not?” I frowned.
“The card machine was down at the supermarket,” she said flatly. “Someone else paid for me.”
“A woman?” I raised a brow.
“A man. His name was Gregory,” she answered. “I should’ve asked for his account number so I could reimburse him.”
“Which supermarket?” I asked, pocketing the card.
“Grace Supermarket.”
“GRACE, in all caps?” I asked, narrowing my eyes.
She looked confused. “Yes?”
“It’s an acronym—G for Gabriel, Gabriella, and GianCarlo; R for Raine; A for Aurora; C for Caitlyn; and E for Emeliana,” I explained.
“I know the three Gs. I know Aurora. But who are Caitlyn, Raine, and Emeliana?” she asked.
“Raine’s my dad. Emeliana Caitlyn was my… late baby sister,” I said quietly.
“Oh… I’m sorry to hear that,” she murmured, her voice softening.
“It’s alright. We never found out if the third baby was a boy or girl, but Mom felt it was a girl and named her Emeliana Caitlyn. She shared a birthday with Gian and Rory.”
“Wait—your family owns The GRACE?” she asked, eyes widening.
“Yeah.” I nodded. “Mom oversees that branch and a few others across the country.” I waved it off casually. “Now that you mention it, I should probably look into that payment issue. Do you remember the cashier’s name?”
“I didn’t check. No name tags or anything,” she replied. “I just grabbed a few snacks for Kary.”
“Just don’t give them to her before dinner,” I warned. “She’ll be bouncing off the walls.”
“Got it.” She nodded.
“I’ll let you get back to whatever you were doing,” I said, taking a step back. “I’m sure I’ll survive watching the movie alone.”
“I can spare an hour,” she said suddenly, and I smiled.
“Let’s go then.”
I headed down and she joined me just as I was placing microwaved popcorn and drinks on the table in front of the sofa. The TV was already on, the movie cued up and paused.
“That didn’t even take three minutes,” she remarked, eyeing the setup. “How did you do all that?”
I simply shrugged and motioned for her to sit. She did, and I joined her. I grabbed the remote and hit play, restarting the movie from where she’d dozed off the other day. Then I picked up the popcorn and placed the bowl on my lap.
“Popcorn?” I offered.
“Thanks.” She didn’t take the bowl—just reached in, scooped a handful, and popped it into her mouth. After chewing and swallowing, she looked at me in surprise. “This is really good.”
“Thanks,” I grinned. “You can have it all.”
“What about you?”
“I’m good.”
She didn’t argue, just kept eating as we focused on the screen. I wanted so badly to ask what happened with Penelope, but I didn’t want to pressure her. She’d talk when she was ready.
“Is your brother okay?” she asked after a while.
“He is. We’re not sure when he’ll wake up, but the doctors are optimistic.”
“Thank God,” she said softly.
“What about you?” I asked.
“I’m fine.”
I wanted to push, to ask again, but I’d learned that she only opens up when she’s ready—not a second before.
“That’s new,” she said, with a dry chuckle.
“What is?”
“You. Not insisting I bare my soul to you. That’s… unlike you.”
“I see.”
She tilted her head, studying me with an unreadable expression. She didn’t believe for a second that I wouldn’t press her further.
“Let’s just watch the movie, okay?” I said. “I only have an hour of your time, remember?”
She scoffed, but turned back to the screen. Ten minutes passed in silence before she gently set the bowl aside, turned toward me fully, and tapped me with her toe.
“Yeah?” I asked.
“I didn’t like how she compared me to… him,” she began quietly. “I was married to that man for ten years. I saw what he was capable of, lived through it. And yes, it changed me—but not in the way she thinks. I’m not like him.”
“I know that.”
“You’re probably the only one who does. Your parents looked at me like I was radioactive at the party. Like they were waiting for me to snap or do something wrong around Kary. And as nice as Kelly and Theresa are… I’m sure they wonder the same thing.”
“Don’t let it get to you,” I said. “Let it roll off your back. And if it doesn’t…” I let the sentence hang.
“If it doesn’t?” she prompted.
“Hold my hand,” I said in a sing-song voice. “I’ll do whatever I can to make it better. We’re friends, right?”
“Are we?” she asked, her eyes teasing.
“We are.” I assured her, matching her smile.
“I feel better,” she admitted, smiling faintly. “I like talking to you.”
“And I like listening to you.” I said simply.