Chapter 95: Chapter Forty Four

Gabriel 

“You don’t believe her, do you?” Arian asked, watching me carefully. “I mean… Abigail is a gossip, sure, but she doesn’t strike me as someone who’d deliberately try to hurt you.”

I turned to Arian, surprised. I opened my mouth to respond, but no words came out, so I shut it again, overwhelmed. Abigail had started working for me around the same time Lucille moved in—after she told me she was pregnant. 

During that period, I’d never seen anything from Abigail except nervous clumsiness, and Lucille had been nothing but cruel to her. She called her a bumbling oaf and constantly demanded I fire her. 

So how in the world had Abigail become Lucille’s informant? It made no sense.

“She didn’t… Lucille hated her,” I finally managed to say. “Abigail was so clumsy, Lucille insisted I let her go—but I didn’t. So how could she have…?” My voice trailed off, the confusion tightening in my chest.

“Maybe Abigail’s talkative nature gave her away?” Arian suggested. “She probably assumed Theresa would never betray you. And Kelly… Kelly was around back then too, wasn’t she?”

“Rachel was the last person I hired,” I said thoughtfully, shaking my head. “I was looking for a nanny for Kary after the previous one left. Kelly told me about her cousin, Rachel. But when I met her… I knew she wasn’t cut out to be a nanny, so I hired her as a maid instead.”

I clenched my fist at the memory. “She and Abigail got along almost immediately. I used to catch them chatting when they should’ve been working.”

“Maybe you should just call Abigail and ask her directly,” Arian said gently.

“I’m just so furious!” I hissed. “If I see her right now, I swear I might strangle her.”

“Do you want me to talk to her instead? Honestly, I don’t think I believe Rachel either.” she offered.

“If you want to,” I replied, waving my hand dismissively. “This is the last straw for me.” I walked around my desk and sank into my chair. “I’m going to wait for Lucille to come back before moving ahead with the divorce. But if she refuses to sign those papers… I don’t know what I’ll do just to be free of her.”

Arian stood and walked to the door. “You’ll want to hear what Abigail has to say, so I’ll bring her in.” She opened the door and stepped out, shutting it behind her.

I opened my laptop and tried to get back to work, but I couldn’t focus. Frustrated, I stood and walked to the tall windows that looked out into the backyard. A knock sounded at the door, but I didn’t turn around.

“Come in,” I called, knowing it was Arian.

“Sir, Abigail is here,” she announced.

“You asked for me, sir?” Abigail said hesitantly.

“Not exactly.” I drew in a deep breath, trying to keep my emotions in check before I turned to face them. “I just want to ask you one thing.”

“What is it, sir?” she asked nervously.

“Rachel told me something I find hard to believe. It's ridiculous." I said, my tone sharper than intended. "She said you were Lucille’s spy?”

Abigail blinked, startled. “Spy? Sir, I don’t understand… what are you talking about?”

“Did you ever spy on me in the past?” I asked firmly, stepping away from the desk and walking toward her. “Because I can’t imagine how Lucille knew so much about me back then unless someone was feeding her information.”

“Sir, I—” she started.

“Rachel also said you told my wife to see a wizard—to get a love potion to control me.”

Abigail’s eyes widened. “That’s not true, sir. I swear—”

“Have you ever been to jail, Abigail?” I interrupted coldly.

She paled and turned to Arian with a desperate look, as if silently begging for help.

“If you don’t start talking,” I said in a low, threatening voice, “that’s exactly where you’ll end up.”

I noticed the cold sweat forming on Abigail’s face, and her bottom lip began to tremble as though she was about to cry.

"You should just tell Mr. Cruz the truth, Abigail," Arian said gently. "I'm sure he'll let you go if you do." She turned to look at me. "Right, Mr. Cruz?"

"That depends on what she has to say," I replied flatly.

"Go on," Arian encouraged her softly.

I watched Abigail’s throat bob as she swallowed hard and rubbed her hands nervously against her uniform. She glanced at me, but the expression on my face must’ve unsettled her—she quickly lowered her gaze to the floor.

"I... It started after she overheard me talking to Rachel about our neighbor’s husband who was cheating on his wife with their housemaid," she mumbled. 

"Mrs.Cruz asked if I wanted to make some extra money by feeding her updates about you while she was away. I agreed. I only ever told her who visited or who you spoke with. That’s all, sir."

"If it was about money, why didn’t you just ask for a raise?" I asked. "Haven’t I increased your salary every year?"

"You have, sir." She answered.

"Well, that’s beside the point now." I waved a hand dismissively. "You still haven’t answered the one thing I really want to know."

"What is that, sir?"

I stepped closer, lowering myself slightly to her eye level and stared directly into her eyes. She flinched at the intensity of my gaze, but to her credit, she didn’t look away. In another situation, I might’ve admired that.

"Did you tell my wife to go to a wizard to make a love potion?"

"I..." she hesitated.

"Think carefully about your next words," I warned.

"I only told her I knew someone who could help her... she wanted another baby, but you weren’t sleeping with her. I suggested taking her to a man who could give her something... to control you," she confessed quietly, her eyes full of shame. 

"But she refused. Instead, she said she’d put something in your drink on your birthday so she could seduce you—but she failed."

"I see," I murmured. "Thank you for your honesty."

"There’s something else," she added hesitantly. "I once overheard her bragging to a friend that she had drugged you on your birthday years ago… and that’s how she got pregnant."

"I figured as much," I nodded slowly. "You’re not going to jail… but you’re leaving my house. Immediately." I pointed toward the door.

"Mr. Cruz, please… I don’t have anywhere to go," she pleaded.

"You have your mother’s house," I said coldly. I walked over to my desk, opened a drawer, and retrieved an envelope. "I was going to give this to you as a bonus for your hard work—despite your talkative nature. Consider it your severance pay."

"I’m really sorry, sir. I promise I won’t do it again. I’ll do better from now on."

"I’ve had enough, Abigail," I said firmly. "Thank you for your service over the years. But this is where it ends. Pack your things and leave."

"Yes, sir," she whispered. She glanced at me one last time, then turned and walked out of my office.

"I knew it," I hissed, pacing. "I wasn’t sure before, but now that she’s confirmed it… maybe I can get this marriage annulled instead."

"Doesn’t annulment take a long time?" Arian asked. "Divorce is faster."

"That’s exactly what my lawyer said," I nodded. "Five more months and I’ll be free. I honestly can’t wait."

"What will you do now?" she asked.

"About what?"

"Well, it’s just going to be me, Theresa, and Kelly now," she explained. "But I won’t be able to help them much anymore. Taking care of Kary will take most of my time, and it might be too much for just the two of them."

"I’ll ask my mom or Gabi to find someone else to help out," I said. "You just focus on Kary. Don’t worry about the rest."

"Okay," she nodded. "So… how do you feel now?"

"I’m not upset anymore."

"Why?"

"Because I finally know the truth," I said. "I’ve been haunted for years, wondering if Lucille had drugged me that night. Now it’s confirmed—she did. I feel lighter… like a burden’s been lifted."

"That’s good," she said with a small smile. "Will you confront her about it?"

"Never," I shook my head. "When she gets back, I’ll serve her the divorce papers. That’s it. I’ll get my life back. Hopefully, I’ll move on."

"I’m happy for you, Mr. Cruz," she said softly. "I just wish I could move on too… but not everyone gets a second chance."

"You can—if you’re determined to be happy," I said, watching her closely. "Let me help you find your happiness, Arian."

"I don’t know if it’s even possible anymore," she replied, shaking her head sadly.

"As the Cheshire Cat from Alice in Wonderland Bakery would say, ‘There’s a possibility that the impossible is possible.’"

She laughed. "What?"

I shrugged. "I believe it. You should too."

"So you actually watch shows like that?" She teased.

"She makes me watch all her favorite shows," I said, rolling my eyes. "Sometimes it’s fun, sometimes I just endure it so she doesn’t get upset."

"You’re really the best dad in the world," she said with a chuckle.

"Don’t I know it," I grinned and winked at her, making her laugh again.