Chapter 89: Chapter Thirty Eight

Gabriel 

I knew I probably shouldn’t be so worried about Arian, but I was. There were so many things I wanted to know—about her life with her ex-husband and even before she married him—but I knew she wouldn’t tell me. If I hadn’t been there both times she had a trigger, I would never have known about them. And I couldn’t help but wonder what else might set her off.

I should have been working, but I couldn’t focus on the documents in front of me. Letting out a tired sigh, I leaned back in my chair and stared at nothing in particular. After a moment, I reached for the top drawer, pulling out the framed letter I had kept safe for nearly twenty-one years. I didn’t want it to get torn or the ink to fade, so I had it framed and locked away—hidden where no one would ever see it.

Tracing the words behind the glass with my fingers, I thought about how she had lied about meeting me again. I hadn’t known her surname back then, or I would have done everything in my power to find her. Mrs. Collins had refused to tell me her full name, too.

My memory of her face and this letter were the only things keeping me from forgetting her completely, even though I knew I should—as Dad always said. I was married, after all. Even though I loathed my wife more than the devil himself, I had no business thinking about another man’s wife.

The door to my home office suddenly swung open, making me nearly drop the frame. Kareena rushed in, dressed in her swimsuit. Quickly, I slipped the letter back into the drawer, shut it, and locked it before composing myself so she wouldn’t notice the melancholy look on my face.

"Hey, sweetheart," I greeted her with a smile. "Going for a swim?"

"Yes! I wanted to ask if you'd like to join me," she replied eagerly.

"Of course." I got to my feet, skirted the desk, and walked over to her. "We’ll play Marco Polo." I said.

"Yay!" She bounced excitedly on her feet.

"Will Arian be joining us?" I asked.

Kareena gave me a look. "Did you forget she went to church?"

"She’s not back yet?" I frowned.

Kary let out a beleaguered sigh and rolled her eyes. "Daddy, she said she was stopping by the orphanage to visit Mrs. Collins and Mrs. James. Did you forget?"

"She did say that," I murmured, more to myself.

"Are you okay, Daddy?" Her voice was laced with concern. "You never forget things."

"I’ve just had a lot on my mind," I reassured her with a smile. "I’m fine."

"Maybe swimming will help," she suggested.

"Maybe," I agreed. "Let’s go."

She placed her hand in mine, and we left my office together. We had a great time playing in the outdoor pool, but as the sky darkened and the clouds swelled with rain, we took our fun inside. 

We sang a few songs on her karaoke machine before settling into the home theater to watch her all-time favorite movie—Mulan… again—while munching on sandwiches.

"Is it raining, Daddy?" Kary asked.

"I don’t know," I replied. I could hear the distant rumble of thunder, but I wasn’t sure if the rain had started yet. I only hoped Arian would be fine. She had refused my offer to have Micah drive her to church and back this morning, and now I couldn’t shake the uneasy feeling settling in my chest that I should have insisted.

"Daddy?" Kary's voice broke the silence after a minute.

"Yes?" I looked down at her.

"I don’t think about her much, but what do you think she’s doing right now?" she asked.

"Lucille?" I asked.

"Yeah." She replied.

I shrugged. "Who knows? She’s probably having the time of her life." Truthfully, I didn’t give a damn what Lucille was up to in Bali. What mattered was that she never called me again.

"How did you meet her?"

I glanced down at her, surprised. "You’ve never asked me that before."

She gave a half-shrug. "I’m asking now so I won’t have to ask again in the future." She answered coolly.

I chuckled, nodding. If she ever brought this up again, I knew I wouldn’t want to revisit my past with Lucille, so it was best to get it out of the way now.

"My father—your grandfather—is friends with her father," I began. "I met her at her mother’s birthday party. We were introduced."

"Did you like her when you first met her?"

I could have lied and said yes, but GianCarlo had already made it clear how much I despised Lucille. There was no point in pretending.

"No," I admitted with a sigh. "After the initial 'Hello, nice to meet you,' I wanted nothing more to do with her. But she liked me… and she wanted me to date her."

Kary frowned slightly. "So… how did you end up marrying her if you didn’t like her?"

I exhaled, running a hand through my hair. "That’s a story I still can’t fully make sense of," I muttered, lost in thought. "She got pregnant with you, and I had no choice but to marry her."

"I won’t ask how I came to be," she stated matter-of-factly.

"Please don’t," I pleaded, and she giggled.

"I already know about the birds and the bees," she teased.

I shot her a disapproving frown. "Who told you that?"

"Grandma Ethel," she said, her voice turning somber. "No one else wanted to tell me."

I sighed loudly and shook my head. "How old are you again?"

"I’m five! But I’ll be six in three months," she beamed. "And I want to dress like a princess."

"There are plenty of Disney princesses."

"Hmm… how about Elsa?"

"Wasn’t she a queen?" I raised a brow.

"I want to wear the dress she wore in the second movie—the white one."

I pretended to mull it over. "That sounds like a difficult dress to make."

"Not if you let Zia Layla design it," she scowled. "She’s the best fashion designer in the world!"

"Alright, Queen Kareena, I hear you." I teased with a lopsided grin. "Your wish is my command, milady."

"Thank you, my loyal subject," she said smugly.

I burst out laughing, shaking my head. "Are you sure you’re five? You could be my age for all I know."

"I could be," she agreed playfully, eyes twinkling.

"Oh dear," I muttered. "I think I’ll start calling you Sage Kareena."

She giggled before suddenly sitting up and wrapping her arms around my neck. "I love you, Daddy," she whispered. "Thank you."

"For what?"

"For being you."

My heart clenched at her words and I hugged her tightly. I kissed her hair, then pulled back to cup her face. "I love you more, sweetheart," I murmured. "And I’ll make sure your birthday is one you’ll never forget."

"You promise?"

"I promise."

She smiled, settling back down with her head on my lap, and we continued watching the movie in comfortable silence.

\~~~~~

I was surprised to find Arian in the hallway, curled up in the single wingback chair, her legs tucked up, arms resting on her knees, and head bowed. If the hallway had been completely dark, I might have walked past her on my way upstairs. 

But the soft glow from the lampshade beside the chair cast just enough light to illuminate her white nightgown, making her look almost ethereal—like a fallen angel. A sad one.

I hesitated, then walked toward her, crouching down in front of her. She didn’t lift her head, though I knew she sensed my presence. Instinctively, I reached out to stroke her hair but stopped myself, dropping my hand.

“Arian?” I whispered.

She stirred at the sound of my voice, slowly raising her head. Her eyes were swollen and red, her nose matching the telltale signs of crying. The sight almost made me smile—because she looked so much like a child who had been crying herself to sleep—but I didn’t.

“Are you okay?” I asked gently. “Can’t sleep?”

“I just… want to stay here for a while,” she murmured.

“You’ve been crying.” My voice hardened slightly. “Did someone do this to you?” If anyone had hurt her, I wouldn’t hesitate to make them regret it. 

The only thing stopping me from making threats was the possibility that the culprit was a woman. Even then, I’d have to figure out another way.

“I’m fine.” She sniffled, but I wasn’t convinced.

My brows furrowed. “We’re friends, aren’t we? You don’t have to keep things from me. A problem shared is a problem solved.”

She let out a weary sigh. “I’ve just been… emotional since this morning. It’s nothing for you to worry about.”

“It’s making me worry anyway.” I grumbled, leaning closer. “I won’t leave until you tell me what’s wrong. If I can help, I will.”

“You can’t help me. No one can.” She shook her head, her voice thick with pain.

“Why not?”

She pressed a hand against her chest, her voice breaking. “Because This hurts.”

I stiffened. “Your heart?” My own heartbeat stuttered. “Are you having trouble breathing?”

“I’m not sick.” she said quietly.

I exhaled heavily. “You’re killing me here, Arian. Just talk to me.”

“It’s a mess,” she whispered. “I just want to feel something other than pain. It doesn’t have to be love… just something. Anything. I just want to be happy, but he won’t let me.” Her voice cracked, and fresh tears slipped down her cheeks. “I can barely sleep without him invading my dreams. And I don’t want to be afraid anymore.”

I swallowed the lump in my throat. “Do you want to talk about it?” I asked, watching her carefully.

Her gaze met mine, searching for something—maybe reassurance, maybe strength. But whatever she was looking for, she decided against it. Her head dropped slightly as she whispered, “I can’t." Her voice trembled. "I want to… but I can’t bring myself to say it.”

She looked so lost, so utterly broken, that instinct took over. I reached for her, pulling her into my arms, hoping the embrace would ground her, even if just a little. She was trapped in the darkness of whatever hell her ex-husband had left her in, and I wanted—needed—to pull her out.

"I’ll always be here when you need me, Arian," I murmured against her hair. "Whenever you're ready."

She didn’t respond, but after a moment, her arms wrapped around me—hesitant at first, then tightening, like I was the only thing holding her together.

And maybe, in that moment, I was. In that moment, I realized something. I wanted to be the person she could depend on.