Chapter 129: Chapter Seventy Eight
Arian
People often said they saw their lives flashing before their eyes in moments of accidents or mortal danger. And while I wasn’t in any kind of accident, I swore I could see mine flashing right now — every poor decision, every stolen moment, every kiss that had led me here.
I had always known I was destined to be alone. It was safer that way — no ties, no vulnerabilities, no one to disappoint me or abandon me.
I never envisioned I would be capable of carving out space in my heart for another person.
And yet, I had.
I opened my heart to Kareena the day she told me she loved me. That same day, I vowed silently to be there for her for as long as she wanted me. She was pure light in a world I had long stopped believing in.
What I hadn’t imagined — what I couldn’t forgive myself for — was finding her father so irresistible. Sleeping with him. Losing myself so completely in him that everything else blurred — even Kareena’s feelings. Especially Kareena’s feelings.
We shouldn’t have done it. God, we shouldn’t have. But it was far too late to take it back now.
I braced myself for what was coming — the disgust in her eyes when she realized what was happening between her father and me. The hatred that would inevitably follow.
“Well?” Kareena prompted, wide-eyed, voice steady in a way that unnerved me. “What do you have to say for yourselves?”
Her eyes were so much older than five. Her grandfather had once said she was an adult trapped in a little girl’s body, and right now, I believed it.
In a few weeks she would be six, yet the way she stared at us made me feel like a child about to be scolded.
Gabriel drew a deep breath and stepped forward. He glanced at me, a silent promise in his eyes — I’ll handle this. I wanted to stop him, to beg him to soften the blow, but I couldn’t find my voice.
He sat on the bed beside her and spoke.
“You’re not seeing things,” Gabriel said evenly. “I was, indeed, kissing Arian.”
I blinked, stunned. He had said it. The truth. I had expected him to spin a white lie — she had something in her eye or it wasn’t what it looked like. That was the usual route, wasn’t it? But no. Gabriel had chosen honesty, and my heart thudded wildly.
“Do you like her?” Kary asked, tilting her head. “You only kiss someone you like, right?”
“That’s right.” Gabriel nodded. “I like Arian.”
Kary’s gaze shifted to me. I felt her question before she even asked it, the air thick with anticipation.
“Ari, do you like my daddy?”
My mouth went dry. Do I like him? That word felt so insufficient. Like didn’t cover the way my chest tightened every time he smiled, the way my pulse raced when he was near. But admitting that — to her — felt like treason.
“Um…” I faltered, unsure if I should answer.
“She wouldn’t kiss me back if she didn’t,” Gabriel answered for me, saving me from my own silence. “Are you okay with it? You’re not… mad at me, right?”
“Why would I be?” Kary asked, genuinely surprised.
“Arian is not… your mother,” Gabriel muttered, almost cautiously.
“I love Ari,” she said simply, smiling up at him. “Are you happy, Daddy?”
“Immensely.” The brightness of his smile sent my heart skittering.
“Then it’s okay,” she assured him with all the certainty in the world. “It’s more than okay.”
I didn’t realize I had been holding my breath until it escaped in a slow, shaky exhale. Relief crashed over me, leaving me lightheaded. All that fear I’d built up in my mind — useless.
I had underestimated the purity of a child’s heart. She loved unconditionally, wholly, without judgment. It was almost humbling.
“Thank you, princess,” Gabriel murmured, cupping her face and pressing a kiss to her forehead.
Kary looked between us again, suddenly thoughtful. “Daddy?” she called softly.
“Yes?”
“Is it because of this that you and Uncle Simon fought?”
The question stunned Gabriel into silence. I watched him struggle with it, saw the flicker in his eyes — the decision to tell her the truth again.
“Yes,” he said finally. “He didn’t say nice things about Arian.”
“Why? She’s the nicest person in the world.” Kary’s confusion twisted something inside me.
“I don’t know,” Gabriel sighed. “You can’t like everyone, and not everyone can like you, sweetheart.”
I studied Kary’s face as she frowned, her little brows furrowing in frustration. She couldn’t understand why anyone would dislike me — and that simple faith made my chest ache.
The love I felt for her tripled in that moment. I pitied her mother deeply — she didn’t even know what she was missing by not loving this child.
“That is not fair,” Kary huffed. “I thought he was different.”
“That shouldn’t change the way you see him,” Gabriel said gently. “Promise me you won’t treat him differently?”
“I promise,” Kary said.
In that moment, something inside me shifted. I had come into Gabriel’s life expecting to find nothing but chaos and heartbreak. Instead, I had found a family I never knew I needed.
And for the first time in my life, I let myself hope that maybe — just maybe — I deserved it.
“Good girl,” Gabriel murmured with a small smile. “Go to sleep.”
“Goodnight, Daddy. Goodnight, Ari.”
“Goodnight,” we both chorused in unison.
We stayed by her side until her breathing evened out, her tiny chest rising and falling steadily in sleep. There was something so peaceful about watching Kary like that — soft, unguarded, safe. I couldn’t help but wonder if she had any idea how much she’d just changed my life in a matter of minutes.
When Gabriel and I finally slipped out of her room, I pulled the door shut behind me with quiet care, almost reverence. The heavy tension that had hung between us earlier — the raw, consuming kind born of hunger and proximity — had dissolved into something softer. Still electric, but calmer.
We stepped into his bedroom, and as the door clicked shut behind us, silence settled. For a moment, we simply stared at each other, the weight of what had just happened pressing down.
“That was…” Gabriel paused, hands braced on his hips. He let out a shaky laugh. “I had this paralyzing fear that she’d flip out.”
“Me too,” I admitted with a quiet laugh. “I was already packing up my stuff… mentally.”
And I meant it, I realized. The second Kary’s wide, curious eyes had fixed on us, I had already pictured myself walking out of this house for good — not because I wanted to, but because I loved her too much to ever hurt her. Her opinion mattered more than my own happiness.
Gabriel chuckled softly, shaking his head as though we were both ridiculous for worrying. He exhaled and strode to his closet. When he returned a moment later, he held out a shirt.
“Thank you,” I said softly, taking it from him. The cotton felt warm, faintly smelling of his cologne — a scent I was starting to associate with comfort and chaos all at once.
“I guess… we can’t do anything tonight,” he muttered, a hint of disappointment in his voice. “Sucks.”
His expression made me laugh, the sound soft and warm in my own ears. I leaned up on tiptoe to press a kiss to his cheek. “Tomorrow,” I whispered, teasing him gently. “I’ll use the bathroom first.”
“Let’s shower together,” he suggested with a grin. “I promise to be on my best behavior. Scout’s honor.” He even pressed a hand to his chest as if to swear an oath.
I arched a brow. “Okay. I promise to be on my best behavior too.”
Before I could react, he swept me off my feet — literally — and I let out a startled squeal, clutching at his shoulders. My laughter echoed as he carried me toward the bathroom.
For a brief moment, I let myself sink into it — this stolen slice of happiness I hadn’t known I was allowed to have.
True to our word, we kept things innocent. Ten minutes later, we were under the covers, freshly showered and facing each other in the soft glow of the bedside lamp.
Gabriel drifted off almost instantly, his breathing deep and even, exhaustion finally claiming him after the day’s chaos. I, however, lay wide awake.
I should have been happy. I should have been relieved. Kary had accepted us without question. She hadn’t flinched, hadn’t pushed me away. Instead, she had smiled — and that smile had felt like forgiveness I didn’t even deserve.
But as I stared at Gabriel’s sleeping face, I couldn’t shake the quiet storm swirling inside me. Guilt and joy warred in my chest, colliding in ways I couldn’t untangle.
Was it selfish to want this? To want him — to want them — when I knew the world we lived in wasn’t built for fairy tales?
I reached out tentatively, brushing a stray lock of hair from his forehead. My fingers lingered for a moment before I pulled back, tucking my hands under my cheek.
For now, I told myself, I could allow this peace. Even if I didn’t believe I deserved it, I wasn’t ready to let it go. Not yet.