Chapter 120: Chapter Sixty Nine

Gabriel

The speed at which Arian sprang off my lap to throw her clothes on made me laugh—even though there was absolutely nothing funny about the situation. Still, I couldn't help it. We'd just had the best sex of my life, and she was the most amazing woman I’d ever known.

That kind of high had a way of fooling a man into thinking he was untouchable, like nothing in the world could ever go wrong. Like the world could crumble and he’d still be standing in the afterglow of something real.

For a brief moment, I actually believed that. That maybe, just maybe, I was allowed to feel this alive. This invincible. For the first time in years, I felt like I had nothing to fear. No judgment, no guilt. Just her.

I didn’t want anything—or anyone—shattering the euphoria coursing through my veins. That’s why I moved slowly, almost lazily, putting on my clothes as if I had all the time in the world.

But just as I reached for the doorknob, Arian stopped me, her fingers wrapping around my arm, halting me in my tracks. Her eyes were wide—round like saucers—and her voice came out in a nervous whisper.

“Is there any way to get out of here without your father seeing me?”

“Why?” I frowned, my voice laced with confusion.

“I’d rather he doesn’t know what we’ve been doing in here,” she mumbled, already looking over her shoulder like someone expecting to be caught in the act.

“He already knows about us,” I said plainly.

Her head snapped up, panic in her eyes. “He does?”

Before I could respond, a loud bang rattled the door. Dad.

“Don’t worry about it,” I told her, though my gut tightened. She had every reason to worry. Still, I unlocked the door.

The door flew open with force, and Arian and I stumbled back to avoid being hit. But Dad didn’t give a damn. His arm reared back, and without warning, his fist collided with my jaw so hard that the world spun as I lost my balance and hit the floor.

Pain exploded in my mouth, metallic and sharp, but Arian’s sharp yelp snapped me to focus faster than the hit did. Her hands flew up defensively as Dad turned to her, rage still simmering behind his eyes, his hand raised again.

No.

I was on my feet in an instant, stepping in front of her and shielding her with my body. I knew Dad wouldn’t hit her—but I couldn’t take that chance. Not with Arian. Not with someone who had already been through enough.

“You... son of a gun!” Dad growled, breathing hard. “How dare you hit your sister because of a woman? A woman who isn’t even your wife?”

My stomach sank. The reminder of what I’d done to Gabriella, the slap… it haunted me more than I could admit out loud.

I glanced at Arian, her body tense, eyes searching mine. She was scared—visibly shaken—and I hated that. I hated that I’d put her in this position.

I held up a hand to stall his growing tirade. Arian didn’t need to hear this—any of it. Not the accusations, not the judgment. Especially not from him.

“Let’s talk in private, Dad,” I said, voice firm but calm. Then, to Arian, “Leave.”

She hesitated, gaze flicking between us. She probably didn’t trust that Dad wouldn’t explode again. I could feel the fear in her, like she was a child again, unsure of where safety lived.

I motioned to him to move aside. He stepped aside with a scowl, and Arian slipped out the door like a child scurrying away from danger. Like she was running from a nightmare. I watched her until she was gone. My chest ached.

The moment she was gone, Dad slammed the door shut and leaned against it, arms folded, ankles crossed. He looked calm. Relaxed even. But I knew better. The man was seething.

“I’m sorry,” I said. My voice was low, remorseful. “No excuse is inexcusable. I shouldn’t have done that.”

“Yeah, you shouldn’t have… asshole,” he spat. “You did one better by beating up her husband too. All for what?”

There it was—the judgment, loud and clear in his tone and eyes. I sighed, swallowing the lump rising in my throat, the weight of disappointment pressing hard against my chest.

I clenched my jaw, the sharp tang of blood still lingering on my tongue from his punch. The ache in my face was nothing compared to the sting beneath my skin.

What was the point in explaining myself when his mind was already made up? When no matter what I said, I’d still be the one in the wrong. Still be the failure. Still be the son who never quite measured up.

“No matter how hard I try to explain it to you, you won’t understand,” I replied, stepping back, trying to keep my voice steady. “I’ll save my breath.”

“There’s nothing to understand here. You’re a married man, Gabriel,” Dad said, his voice now sharper than a blade. “You don’t get to covet another man’s wife. Your wife may be the devil’s queen, but you made vows—before God and man. You can’t right her wrongs with your own.”

I turned away from Dad, unable to meet his eyes a second longer. Whatever look was on his face—disappointment, judgment, indifference—I couldn’t bear it. Not now. My chest felt tight, like I was holding something in that had been dying to break free.

I walked slowly to the windows, each step an effort to stay composed. The sunlight spilled through the glass, and outside, the pool sparkled beneath the afternoon sun. The water danced, calm and inviting, untouched by the storm brewing inside me.

My gaze locked on it, and suddenly, I was no longer in that room. I was back there—barefoot on the edge, the cool water wrapping around me, Arian’s laughter echoing in the air. I could still hear it. Still feel the way she looked at me like I wasn’t too much. Like I wasn’t broken or complicated or a constant disappointment.

Just… me.

And in that moment, that one damn moment, everything had felt right. Safe. Real.

A smile tugged at my lips, trembling at the edges. It wasn’t a happy smile—it was the kind that came with longing, with the sting of knowing that something beautiful had slipped through your fingers and there was nothing you could do to bring it back.

God, I wanted to go back. Not just to the memory—but to the version of myself I was in it. The one who let himself feel. Who didn’t carry the weight of unspoken words and unmet expectations.

But time doesn’t care what you want. It keeps moving forward, dragging you with it. And all I could do was stand there, staring at that shimmering water, wishing it could wash everything else away.

I thought if I gave him space to say what he needed, he might burn out and leave. But no—he was just getting started.

“Gabriel!” he barked.

I turned around, the sharpness in his voice breaking through my patience. I threw my hands up in the air, my anger boiling over. “You keep judging me, Dad!”

His presence was heavy, a reminder of every impossible standard I was never able to meet.

“This is absolutely nothing in Lucille’s book, but I’m doing it now and I’m suddenly the bad guy?”

“Well, Lucille didn’t slap your sister because of a man, did she?” His voice was dipped in sarcasm.

I felt my pulse spike, blood roaring in my ears.

“I already apologized! What the hell do you guys want from me?” I shouted. “Am I not allowed to be happy? Is that it?”

That last question lingered in the air, echoing louder than any accusation could.

Am I not allowed to be happy? And there it was. The truth, naked and aching. All I wanted—after everything—was to be happy. But it seemed like happiness came with a price I’d never be allowed to pay.

Because right now, with everything I had sacrificed, with the lines I’d crossed and bridges I’d burned—I didn’t know if I’d ever be able to answer that myself.