Chapter 116: Chapter Sixty Five
Gabriel
I wouldn’t say I had telepathy, but it sure felt like it. Every time I got home from work earlier than expected, something was always off—like my instincts were pulling me back for a reason.
And without fail, I’d walk in on either my mom or my sister harassing Arian. Once was a fluke. Twice? That was a pattern, and I wasn’t going to let it slide again.
"What’s going on here?" I asked as I shut the door, already striding toward them. My eyes immediately landed on a white envelope on the floor between them. I stooped to pick it up, my gut churning with unease. "What’s this?"
"Nothing." Gabi made a grab for it, but I turned away before she could snatch it from my hand. That was all the confirmation I needed.
Her nerves were on edge, her actions screaming guilt. I frowned, wondering what she'd come to say to Arian that hadn't already been said in previous confrontations.
"It’s something if you’re shaking like this," I said, opening the flap. A folded slip of paper fell into my palm.
I knew what it was before I even turned it over—the weight, the feel, the tension in the room had already told me. When I looked up at Gabi, my expression hardened.
"It’s not what you think," she muttered. "I was only trying to help."
"Did she ask for your help?" I bit out, my tone clipped. I turned to Arian. "Did you ask for her help?"
"No," she said quietly, shaking her head.
"Then why are you giving it?" I snapped. My temper flared, white-hot. "You should really mind your own damn business, Gabriella."
"She’s not someone who’s worthy of you!" Gabi burst out, her face twisted with frustration. "Surely, you don’t want to make use of her ex’s leftovers!"
That was it. Before I could stop myself, I slapped her. The sound rang out, loud and horrible, and both Gabi and Arian gasped in shock.
I froze. Shame rushed in like a flood, cold and unforgiving. I hadn’t meant to hit her—I hadn’t even thought about doing it. It was like my mind had flashed back to Lucille, her voice, her cruelty, her poison.
In that split second, it wasn’t Gabi in front of me—it was her. But no justification could erase what I’d just done. Cowards hit women. I never wanted to be that man.
"I’m sorry," I rasped, my voice shaking. Gabi’s tears spilled over, her face red with hurt and disbelief. "I’m so sorry, Gabi." I reached for her, desperate to make it right, but she smacked my hands away.
"Don’t speak to me ever again," she spat. Her eyes flicked to Arian with icy disdain before she stormed off.
I stood there stunned, the weight of what I’d done anchoring me to the floor. Arian said nothing as I ran after Gabi, my heart pounding, my mind racing.
I’d beg her if I had to. Drop to my knees if that would help. Because I knew exactly what my father would say if he ever found out—he’d skin me alive. And he’d be right to.
"Fuck," I hissed under my breath when I returned, slamming the door behind me. Arian jumped in her seat. I’d scared her too.
I paused, my stomach knotting with guilt. Her ex had been violent—she’d told me that, and I’d promised she’d never feel unsafe again.
And now here I was, yelling, breaking things, striking my own sister. I was becoming the kind of man she feared most. How could I expect her to trust me after this?
"Did you get to talk to her?" she asked softly.
"She refused to listen," I muttered, pacing in frustration. "My dad will kill me."
"It was an accident, wasn’t it?" she said, her voice gentle—too gentle. I hated that she was trying to ease my guilt.
"Even so, I shouldn’t have done that." I ran my fingers through my hair, my mind spiraling. "I’ve never hit a woman before. I just—" I stopped, exhaling heavily. "This is crazy."
"This is all my fault," she murmured. "I should go before—"
"Don’t even think about it." I snapped, my tone sharp. "I’m the one who started all this in the first place. I’ll be the one to fix it."
"Well, your family won’t blame you. They’ll blame me," she said bitterly. "Your mother thinks I’m some kind of sorceress or something."
"That’s ridiculous." I scoffed, though a small part of me knew she was right.
"Tell that to them," she said. "I don’t want to put you in more trouble, Gabriel. I’m not worth all this heartache."
I crossed the room, cupped her face in my hands, and pressed a kiss to her forehead. Her honey brown eyes searched mine, filled with sadness.
I’d promised myself I would protect her from pain, from judgment, from the past that haunted her. Yet here I was—hurting her all over again.
"I wish you could see yourself through my eyes," I whispered. "You’re worth more than gold to me, Arian." She tried to shake her head, but I held her gently, refusing to let her retreat.
I kissed her lips—soft, lingering—and sighed against them.
"I’m not worthy of you," I said, the words raw and honest. And deep down, I meant them.
"That’s not true." She frowned. "Any woman—minus your stupid wife—would be lucky to have you in her life."
But you don’t want me, a voice echoed in my head, quiet but persistent.
"You think so?" I asked anyway, trying to hold onto something—anything.
"I know so," she said with conviction. But I wasn’t sure I believed her. Not after today.
I rested my forehead gently against hers and let out a long sigh, my eyes drifting shut. Her soft, citrus scent wrapped around me, warm and familiar, tugging at something primal inside. I muttered a curse under my breath when I felt myself harden against her.
Damn it, Gabriel, not now. This wasn’t the time to be thinking about that—about sinking into her, about losing myself in her touch, in her warmth, in her everything.
But the desire was there, as relentless as ever. She had that effect on me, even in moments like this. Especially in moments like this.
"Are you asleep, Gabriel?" Her voice, laced with surprise, pulled a soft laugh out of me.
I opened my eyes and smiled. "Of course not. You’d never be able to lift me if I was."
I pulled back slightly, just enough to see her face. God, she was beautiful. And somehow, I always wanted more time with her—more reasons to make her laugh or smile. "Do you want to go for a swim with me?"
"No," she said, flat as ever.
That made me grin. "Why not?"
"I almost drowned the other day, remember?" she replied, tone clipped.
My smile faltered. I blinked, genuinely confused. "Wait… I thought you could swim. I just figured you didn’t because of the muscle cramps you mentioned?"
"I almost drowned when I was ten," she said softly, eyes not quite meeting mine. "I was never taught how to swim."
My jaw slackened, and for a second, I just stared at her. What the hell?
"This is a prank, right?" I asked, still trying to wrap my head around it.
"No." Her voice was quiet now. Vulnerable. "I don’t know how to swim. I’ve always been afraid of water ever since then."
There was something in the way she said it—a shadow behind the words. I wanted to press, to ask what happened exactly, but I knew better. She'd tell me when she was ready. If she ever would.
"Will you let me teach you?" I asked, trying to keep my voice light but gentle. "It’s… important to know how to swim. You never know when it could save your life."
"I really don’t want to learn," she said, shaking her head. Her eyes searched mine, pleading quietly. "Please don’t make me."
I nodded, forcing myself to step back emotionally. She wasn’t ready, and I wasn’t going to push her.
"It’s fine," I said softly. "I just… sometimes I wish we’d met when we were younger. Maybe I’d have made you happy sooner."
Her lips curved into a small, sad smile. "I think so too."
There was a beat of silence between us. A kind of longing hung in the air—wistful, quiet, aching.
"So why are you home so early anyway?" she asked, raising an eyebrow. "Are you playing hooky?"
"Maybe I am," I replied, flashing her a lopsided grin as I walked away toward the pool. Truth was, I just wanted to be near her today. Work could wait. Life could wait. She couldn’t.
"I’m going for a swim. You can watch me."
"I won’t miss it for anything in the world," she called after me.
Her words stayed with me as I stepped outside. I knew she meant it, but there was something deeper behind her voice—something unspoken. I wanted to be everything she didn’t know she needed. And maybe, just maybe, I already was.