Chapter 101: Chapter Fifty

Arian

Mr. Cruz was unusually quiet. He’d been that way ever since he got home from work, and even Kareena had picked up on the fact that something was off with her father.

I watched him absentmindedly push his food around on his plate, a faraway look in his eyes, and I couldn’t help but wonder what was running through his mind.

“Daddy, have you finished working on your speech?” Kary asked gently, giving his arm a soft tap to pull him back to the present.

He didn’t look up as he replied, “I’m not giving the speech anymore. Your aunt will do it.” he replied flatly.

Kary frowned with concern. “Are you okay, Daddy? Did you get into a fight with someone?”

“No, sweetheart,” he said with a small smile, trying to reassure her. “I’m fine. Just... have a lot on my mind.”

“It must be a lot if you can’t even eat,” she said seriously. “I’m a good listener, you know.”

He chuckled softly but didn’t meet her eyes. “Let me sort through my thoughts first, and then I’ll let you in on them.” he promised.

“Promise?” She raised her pinky toward him.

He stared at her pinky for a moment, visibly hesitant. It was the first time I’d ever seen him struggle to make a promise to her. Whatever it was, he clearly didn’t want her to know. And that only made me more curious.

“How about I talk to your dad first, and then I’ll explain everything to you?” I offered. “I promise I’ll tell you why he’s feeling this way.”

“I’m not sad,” Mr. Cruz cut in, pouting slightly. “Just... in a melancholy mood.”

“I’m pretty sure those mean the same thing, Mr. Cruz,” I said with a cheeky grin.

He blinked, caught off guard, then let out a reluctant chuckle and nodded in agreement.

“I don’t like seeing you sad, Daddy,” Kary murmured. “Please don’t be.”

“I know, sweetheart,” he replied, finally picking up his fork and began to eat. That simple act brought a smile back to her face.

After dinner, we all gathered in the living room to watch some TV until it was time for Kary to head to bed. Mr. Cruz carried her upstairs, and I helped her change into her pajamas before letting him tuck her in.

“Do you want to read us a story?” he asked.

“Not tonight,” she said, shaking her head. “Goodnight, Daddy. Goodnight, Ari.”

“Goodnight, Princess.” He leaned down to kiss her forehead, then rose and quietly exited the room.

“Will you talk to him now?” she asked sleepily.

“I will,” I whispered. “Sweet dreams.” I waited until her breathing slowed and she was fully asleep before turning off the lights and closing the door behind me.

I headed toward the stairs, hoping he hadn’t gone to bed to avoid the conversation. But I found him on the balcony, his elbows resting on the balustrade, head bowed as if he were watching something below.

I walked over and stood beside him, mimicking his posture, though I kept my gaze forward. I remained silent for a while, giving him space and also sorting through my own thoughts—until he spoke first.

“Have you ever felt like you knew someone better than you knew yourself,” he said quietly, “only to find out you didn’t know them at all when they say or do something completely unexpected?”

I shook my head. “Not really." I admitted. "Why?”

He sighed. “Earlier today, I thought I knew my sister. But she showed me I didn’t. I thought I knew my parents, too. But now I realize... they never really knew me—and I never truly knew them.”

"What are you talking about?" I asked, thrown off by his words. His words made no sense—had something happened with his sister?

"After the board meeting, I brought up Penelope to Gabi," he began in a dull, flat tone. "I wanted to know what she did after hearing what Penelope said to you... but she brushed it off and made me feel like a fool for defending you."

He paused, then added with quiet bitterness, his gaze distant. "As if that wasn’t enough, she straight up accused me —flat out—of sleeping with you—and told my parents the same thing. My mom said that even if I were going to cheat, I should’ve picked someone 'better.'"

My eyes widened as I stared at his face, trying to tell if he was joking. He wasn’t. His face was unreadably serious.

"Wait... the rumors Abigail started… they made it all the way to your sister?" I asked, my voice cracking.

"GianCarlo told her. And she confirmed it with Abigail." His voice was tight. "I was so furious, I couldn’t even defend myself." He clenched his jaw.

“I always had a feeling your sister didn’t like me,” I said quietly, shaking my head. “But I didn’t think she’d stoop that low.” I huffed a breath. “Honestly, I’d find the whole thing funny if I actually had any feelings for you.”

"I still don’t believe you don’t," he muttered.

"I don’t." I shot back, glaring at him. "Not for you, not for any man."

He turned to look at me, and for a moment, I couldn’t read the expression on his face. His eyes lingered on my lips, the intensity of his gaze making my breath catch. I took an involuntary step back.

"Why are you looking at me like that?" I asked warily.

"Like what?"

"Like you’re thinking about kissing me." I snapped, narrowing my eyes.

"That’s because I am," he admitted without flinching, unapologetic. "I mean, they’ve already accused us of sleeping together. Might as well make it true."

"Are you drunk?" I narrowed my eyes at him in disbelief. "You have to be, to ask me to be your mistress."

"A woman’s only a mistress if the man is married," he said calmly. "And I don’t consider myself married. So, you wouldn’t be my mistress."

"You’re wearing a wedding ring." I grabbed his hand to prove it, only to find his ring finger bare. "Wait… where is it?"

"I haven’t worn a ring in years." he said simply. "Took it off two hours after the church wedding and flushed it down the toilet."

"What?" A startled laugh burst from my lips, even though I knew I shouldn’t laugh. I couldn’t help it—I laughed until my eyes teared up. But I sobered instantly when I saw he wasn’t the least bit amused.

“Do you feel better now?” he drawled, clearly unimpressed.

I cleared my throat as I wiped my cheeks. "You may have flushed the ring, but you still got married in a church. The world still thinks you’re married. So yes, if we slept together, I’d be your mistress… which we’re not going to do." I fixed him with a look. "Remember what you told me? Let hurtful words roll off your back? Maybe you should follow your own advice."

"I didn’t say it in a flippant tone, but sure," he replied, his voice sharp and dripping with it now. "Goodnight, Arian." And with that, he turned and walked inside.

I sighed, frustrated, and quickly followed after him. I caught up just before he reached his bedroom and stepped in front of the door to block him.

"I’m sorry," I said softly. "I didn’t mean to be a jerk. It’s just... I’ve never done this before. Being friends with someone."

He tilted his head. "What do you mean? You never had friends growing up?"

I looked down, slowly shaking my head. I didn’t want his pity, so I forced a smile, ready to lie—only to catch the warning in his eyes. He knew.

"I didn’t have time for friends," I admitted. "They were a luxury I couldn’t afford. Between piano lessons, ballet, voice coaching, and studying... there was no time left."

"I wish you’d tell me more," he said quietly.

"I’m sorry. I can’t." My voice barely rose above a whisper.

"One day?" he asked, lifting his pinky.

A smile tugged at the corners of my mouth. I hooked my pinky with his and sealed it with a thumb press.

"One day."

He gave me a gentle smile, patted my shoulder, then headed into his room. "Goodnight, Arian."

"Goodnight, Mr. Cruz."

I waited a moment, then made my way downstairs, locking the sliding door behind me. They accused us of sleeping together—even though all we did was share a bed.

If I were the kind of woman who still believed in love—or anything close to it—I might've let the rumors come true. He’s the kind of man women ruin themselves for. But not me. I’ve been gutted by promises, shattered by lies dressed up as affection. Men? I don’t trust them.

Marriage? Just a beautiful word for a slow death. And sex? That’s just another battlefield where I lose pieces of myself. It would take a miracle—no, a resurrection—to make me forget the damage, to make me feel safe enough to want... to need... anything again.