Chapter 36
Lyra's POV
My breath hitched.
Standing beside Marcello—arm looped casually through his—was her.
The woman from the mirror.
The ghost, the enigma, the whisper in the air that had vanished like fog on glass. Only she wasn’t vanishing now. She was right here. Tangible. Alive. Wearing a gown that shimmered like starlight and a smile far too polite to be real.
Marcello’s gaze locked on mine the moment I froze. His brows drew together, concerned flickering beneath his polished composure. I didn’t speak. I couldn’t. My mouth felt like it was full of sand.
“Lyra,” he said, gently tugging me closer. “This is Rebekah. She’s an old family friend.”
Old didn’t even begin to cover it.
Rebekah extended a graceful hand, her expression as smooth as porcelain. “It’s nice to meet you, Lyra.”
I stared at her hand for a beat too long. The memory of her touch—cold, knowing, impossibly ancient—still clung to my shoulder.
I reached out, hesitating just a second before our palms met.
The moment her fingers brushed mine, it was like static ran through my bones.
My voice wobbled. “We’ve… met.”
Her smile didn’t flicker, but I saw something in her eyes—something sharp. “Oh? I don’t think so, dear. I’d remember.”
My breath caught. Liar.
I forced a tight smile. “Right. Must be my mistake.”
I felt Marcello’s gaze flick between us like a chess player watching two opponents silently plot their moves. I didn’t look at him. Didn’t dare.
Because if I did, he’d see everything.
The doubt. The dread. The burn of truth I wasn’t ready to voice.
His hand found the small of my back, warm and grounding. “Lyra, are you okay?”
“I’m fine,” I said quickly, too quickly.
He didn’t believe me. I could feel it in the tension that rolled off him like storm clouds.
I was saved—momentarily—by the devil himself.
Vincenzo appeared beside me, his eyes flicking to Rebekah with a glance that was all kinds of complicated before settling on me.
“Lyra. A word?”
I hesitated. My gaze slid to Marcello, then to Rebekah—who looked mildly amused, as if she already knew how this scene would unfold.
“Sure,” I muttered, needing air more than answers.
Vincenzo didn’t wait. He turned, walking briskly toward the back doors that led out to the garden.
I followed, heat prickling under my skin. I felt Marcello’s stare on my back like a weight.
We stepped into the cool night. Fairy lights hung from branches above, casting a soft golden glow over the ivy-covered stone walls. The air smelled like roses and tension.
Vincenzo didn’t speak until we were deep in the shadows, where no one could hear.
Then he turned to me.
“Tell me the truth,” he said. “Do you choose him?”
“What?” I blinked. “We’re not doing this right now.”
“We are,” he said, stepping closer. “Because I can’t keep pretending I don’t feel it. I know you do too.”
I folded my arms, trying to build some kind of shield. “I’m not answering that.”
“I’m not asking to start a war. I’m asking because I need to hear you say it.”
I looked away. “That’s not fair.”
“Life isn’t fair. But I’m here. I’ve been here, Lyra.”
His hand came up, brushing my cheek—and before I could stop him, before I could even process the movement—
He kissed me.
It wasn’t soft. It wasn’t gentle.
It was possessive. A silent claim made in moonlight.
My hands flew up to push him away, but a snarl ripped through the air before I had to.
Marcello.
He grabbed Vincenzo by the collar and shoved. Hard.
Vincenzo stumbled back, crashing into the stone bench behind him. I gasped, heart pounding, caught between fury and shock.
“What the hell do you think you’re doing?” Marcello’s voice was a growl, barely restrained. His wolf flickered behind his eyes like a match ready to ignite.
Vincenzo wiped his mouth, blood at the corner of his lip. “Asking the question you’re too afraid to.”
Marcello surged forward, but I stepped between them.
“Stop it!” I yelled, palms against Marcello’s chest. “Both of you! This is insane!”
His chest rose and fell under my hands, the heat of his fury radiating into my skin.
Vincenzo looked at me. Just me. “Tell him.”
I shook my head. “There’s nothing to tell.”
The lie tasted bitter on my tongue.
Marcello didn’t say anything. His fists clenched at his sides, and the muscles in his jaw worked like he was holding back a thousand words.
Then he said the one I hated most: “Let’s go.”
Back inside.
Back to Rebekah.
Back to pretending nothing had just happened.
\---
The ballroom was alive with music and chatter, but it all sounded hollow now.
Rebekah stood where we’d left her, sipping something from a crystal flute. She smiled when she saw us return, but her eyes zeroed in on me like she could smell the chaos clinging to my skin.
Marcello kept a hand on me—possessive, protective, fragile. I felt the question still simmering in his silence.
He led me to a quiet corner, leaning in close.
“What happened out there?”
I shook my head. “Nothing.”
“Don’t lie to me.”
I stared at my hands. “I’m not ready to talk.”
Marcello didn’t push. He just nodded once, jaw tight.
But I could feel it. The wall building between us. Brick by brick.
And when I glanced across the room, Rebekah was still watching.
Still smiling.
I hesitate before leaving the room, I need to speak to the lady. She quickly rushed upstairs, guess she wants me to follow her up there.
I rushed upstairs, catching up with her, she was standing on the balcony, hand wrapped around the balcony rail.
“What do you want?” She asked, facing outside.
“Who the hell are you?” I asked walking closer to her.
“Sorry I scared you earlier, my name is Rebekah, Marcello's ex.”
She said, gesturing her hand towards me, but Marcello just introduced her as a family friend, man are fuckin demonic when lying.