Chapter 58: Smoke in the mirrors

The music pulsed through my body, a dull throb in my chest like a second heartbeat. The bass vibrated through the floor, through my boots, up my spine. Everything was noise and movement—blurring faces, shimmering lights, the sharp scent of sweat and perfume and weed lingering in the air like a second atmosphere.

Mary’s party, as always, was exactly what I needed: messy, loud, intoxicating.

I needed to forget.

Forget the way Emma looked at me when she was scared and small, curled in a blanket in Alice’s bathroom. Forget the feel of her shivering in my arms when I carried her out of that room. Forget the weight of her eyes on mine when she asked why I helped her, and I couldn’t give her the real answer.

Forget the growing pit in my stomach every time I imagined her finding out what we were doing to Diana.

It was justice. It was what she deserved. Diana had crossed every line, carved her cruelty into Emma’s skin and mind. Someone had to answer for that. I was just the one brave enough to deliver the sentence.

Right?

I threw back another shot, the vodka burning down my throat, and wiped my mouth with the back of my hand. Around me, bodies danced, grinding and laughing and shouting too loud over the music. A strobe of violet light flashed across the room, momentarily blinding me, and then I saw Alex weaving through the crowd with two glasses in hand.

“Here,” he shouted over the noise, shoving one into my hand. “Vodka soda. You’re not getting out of here sober tonight.”

“That’s the point,” I muttered, barely audible even to myself, and tipped it back.

He didn’t ask questions. That was what I liked about Alex. He didn’t dig. He didn’t prod. He was just there. A drink in one hand, a half-sincere joke in the other.

The first part of the plan was done. The mysterious note tucked into Diana’s locker, the photo of her house left on her windshield, the flickering lights she swore were signs someone was watching her—it was all going according to plan. Jane and Anna executed it like pros. Boris hacked the school’s printer system to leave that creepy note in her locker, and Alex, well, Alex had friends who knew how to track down anyone’s home. That scared me more than it should’ve.

But we didn’t hurt her. Not really. Just scared her. Reminded her that sometimes, the shadows bite back.

And still—I felt like I was being chewed from the inside out.

So I took another shot.

Let myself be pulled into the rhythm, the music pounding in my ears, numbing my thoughts. Someone handed me a joint, and I took a long drag, holding the smoke in my lungs until it burned, then let it out slowly, like an exhale of everything I couldn’t say.

And still—Emma’s face crept into the back of my mind.

Her soft voice. Her shy smile. The way she tried so hard to be brave, even when her hands trembled.

I can’t love her, I thought bitterly. I can’t give her what she wants.

She needed someone who had their shit together. Who didn’t wake up with ghosts in their throat and knives in their chest every time they thought about love. Someone who didn’t go to parties like this just to disappear inside them.

Another drink. Another blurry face.

And then—I was on the couch, and a girl was in front of me. I didn’t know her name. She had pink lip gloss smeared just slightly outside the lines of her mouth, and her eyes glittered with something sharp.

“Wanna make out?” she asked bluntly, already leaning in.

I didn’t say yes. I didn’t say no either.

So I kissed her.

Wet, messy, too much tongue. Her hands were on my waist, fingers creeping beneath my shirt. People around us hooted, cheered.

And still—all I could think about was Emma.

The girl’s lips pressed harder, more insistent.

It didn’t feel good.

It didn’t feel right.

I pulled away suddenly, my breath shaky, my heart pounding too fast. “Sorry,” I muttered, standing up and nearly knocking over a lamp. “I can’t—this isn’t—”

She gave me a dirty look and waved me off, already turning to someone else. I stumbled out of the room, up the stairs, found an empty corner in the hallway and slid down against the wall, burying my head in my hands.

I’d kissed someone to forget Emma.

And all it did was remind me of her.

I was such a fucking coward.

I wanted to be the hero. The protector. The girl who stood between Emma and the world. I wanted to believe that the plan with Diana was noble. Righteous.

But I’d lied.

I wanted Diana to suffer. For every bruise, every tear, every panic attack Emma had because of her. And maybe... maybe I just wanted to feel like I had some control over something.

But now I was here. High, drunk, sick to my stomach—and all I could think about was the look Emma would give me if she knew. If she saw what I’d become tonight.

I’m a good person, I tried to tell myself. I’m doing the right thing.

But deep down I knew I didn’t believe it.