Chapter 56: Starting the operation

I turned the burner phone over in my hand again, its cheap plastic case cool against my fingers. Jane had passed it to me earlier, casually slipping it into my backpack like it was no big deal. But it felt heavy, weighed down by what we were about to do.

We sat in Jane’s car, parked down the block from Diana’s house. It was evening already, shadows stretching long over the empty street. Boris leaned forward between the front seats, his broad frame cramped in the tiny car. His presence felt comforting somehow—steady, like he was ready to handle whatever happened next.

“You think this will work?” Jane asked quietly, glancing at me from the driver’s seat, her brown eyes wide with anxiety and anticipation.

“It has to,” I answered, but even I heard the uncertainty in my voice. I straightened my shoulders, feigning confidence. “She needs to feel what it’s like—to know what it means to be afraid.”

“But remember,” Boris spoke up calmly, “we keep it subtle. We don’t cross the line.”

I nodded slowly. “Subtlety. That’s the point.”

Alice’s instructions echoed in my head. She’d been clear—too clear—about what each step entailed. I pulled out the burner and double-checked our messages, heart fluttering a little as I read the first one again.

I saw you today. You looked nervous. I like that look on you.

It sounded like a whisper in the dark, a shadow brushing by. Enough to unsettle without being explicit. Alice had crafted it perfectly, her knowledge of subtlety both fascinating and a little unsettling. But I trusted her—and we needed exactly that.

Anna leaned forward anxiously from the passenger seat. “What if Diana figures out it’s us?”

“She won’t,” Jane reassured her. “We’ve been careful. Burner phone, ghost numbers—Alice said it’s untraceable.”

Boris nodded, confident. “Diana won’t suspect a thing. She has plenty of enemies at school—no one will think it’s us.”

I glanced toward Diana’s house, framed neatly by trees that looked darker now as the sun faded away. The lights inside were on, casting warm yellow squares across her yard. Her life looked peaceful from out here, but I knew better. Underneath the surface, Diana was all poison and sharp edges, hidden beneath that perfect facade.

“Time to send the first message,” Jane said, breaking the silence. She turned to look at me expectantly.

I hesitated only for a second before pressing send. The phone vibrated softly, confirming the delivery. We all stared at the small screen, waiting.

We didn’t have to wait long.

Only a minute passed before a reply buzzed back, making us all jump. Jane reached over eagerly. “Give it to me,” she whispered, taking the phone. She rolled her eyes as she read it aloud: “‘Who is this?’”

I swallowed, a small thrill racing up my spine. She sounded unsettled. Good. That meant it was working.

“Don’t answer yet,” Boris instructed. “Wait. Let her wonder.”

Minutes ticked by slowly. The screen stayed silent.

“Should we drive past again?” Jane asked impatiently, her fingers tapping the steering wheel.

I shook my head. “Not tonight. She can’t see us here too often. It has to be spaced out, or she’ll guess.”

Anna’s eyes were glued nervously to Diana’s house. “This feels risky.”

“We agreed,” Jane reminded her gently. “Emma’s been through hell because of Diana. This isn’t revenge—just a little taste of her own medicine.”

At the mention of Emma, my chest tightened. I pictured her soft eyes, pleading with me not to do anything rash. She’d asked me explicitly to leave Diana alone, to walk away from this fight. But I couldn’t. I could handle Diana’s insults thrown at me, but seeing Emma humiliated, hurt, broken... it had become my line in the sand. Emma deserved peace—and if Diana wouldn’t give it to her, I’d force it.

I returned my gaze to Diana’s house, squaring my shoulders. “She needs to know that actions have consequences.”

As the sky deepened to navy, we waited, nerves buzzing beneath the forced calm. Then Boris nudged Jane. “Time for the second message.”

This one was more personal. My pulse quickened as I typed carefully:

Be careful walking home tomorrow. You never know who might be following.

We pressed send and fell silent, holding our breaths as we watched for a reaction. This time Diana’s reply came quicker, frantic:

Whoever you are, this isn’t funny.

I felt a strange satisfaction mixed with guilt. I didn’t enjoy seeing her scared, not really. But Emma’s tear-stained face after Diana’s attack—the black marker, the locked closet, the filthy water—flashed vividly in my mind. That pain far outweighed any hesitation I felt now.

One more message, to push a little further:

Neither is what you did.

That was enough for tonight. I turned the phone off, stuffing it deep into my pocket. Jane turned on the engine, and as we drove away, I glanced back at Diana’s illuminated window, imagining her panicked expression as she stared into the darkness, wondering who had finally decided to fight back.

We dropped Anna and Boris off first, each bidding quiet goodbyes filled with unspoken anxiety. When it was just Jane and me, she hesitated at my driveway.

“Are you sure you’re okay?” Jane asked softly, eyes searching mine.

“I’m fine,” I answered shortly, looking down at my hands clenched tightly in my lap.

“You’re thinking about Emma?”

“Always.” The word slipped out without permission.

Jane sighed gently, “You know, Emma wouldn’t like this.”

I glanced sharply at her. “That’s exactly why she won’t find out.”

Jane nodded slowly, eyes sympathetic. “Just be careful, Irene. I don’t want you to regret it later on.”

I met her gaze, sincerity shining through the darkened car interior. “I’ll be fine,” I repeated, quieter this time. “It’s all under control.”

But as we drove further I felt the weight of our actions, my thoughts swirled uneasily. Jane was right: playing this role, even for the right reasons, felt strange and heavy. My throat tightened as I imagined Emma’s disappointed face if she ever found out.

I shook it off as best as I could. Tonight was only the beginning, and we still had a long way to go.

Still, a small voice inside wouldn’t be quiet, whispering doubts and fears:

What if, in trying to protect Emma, I ended up becoming someone she wouldn’t want at all?