Chapter 17: Questioning myself

The living room buzzed with the energy that only Auntie Nicki and Auntie Beth could bring. Nicki, now settled into the couch with a glass of wine in one hand and a thin cigarette poised elegantly between her fingers, exhaled a stream of smoke and turned her sharp eyes on me.

“So, Emma,” she began, her voice lilting with curiosity and just a hint of mischief. “What’s going on in your love life, darling? I heard about the breakup.”

Mom, still nursing her own glass of wine, jumped in before I could respond. “Oh, Nicki, it was for the best. That boy, Josh, was no good for her. Possessive, controlling. He deserved to be dumped.”

Nicki let out a scoff, her bracelets jingling as she waved her cigarette dramatically. “Of course he deserved it. Men like that think the world revolves around them until someone knocks them off their pedestal. Good on you, Emma.” She raised her glass as if to toast me, and I gave her a weak smile.

“But now,” Nicki continued, her gaze narrowing, “what’s next? Got your eye on anyone? Or are you focusing on school?”

Before I could think of how to answer, Beth chimed in, her soft voice cutting through Nicki’s brashness. “Emma’s still young,” she said, giving me a kind look. “She should be focusing on herself right now—figuring out who she is, what she wants in life. There’s no rush for love. It’ll find her when the time is right.”

Nicki rolled her eyes dramatically, taking a long drag from her cigarette before replying. “Oh, please, Beth. These are her sweet sixteens! If she doesn’t grab a man now, while they’re still young and sweet, she’ll end up like us—wading through the muck of emotionally stunted older men. Trust me, darling,” she said, looking at me, “you want to catch them while they’re still malleable.”

Beth chuckled softly, shaking her head. “You make it sound like she’s fishing for a pet, Nicki.”

“Isn’t she, though?” Nicki shot back with a playful smirk.

The two of them launched into a lighthearted argument, trading barbs about their wildly different philosophies on love. Nicki insisted I should embrace my youth and throw myself headfirst into romance, while Beth argued that self-discovery and stability should take precedence.

As their laughter filled the room, I took the opportunity to quietly slip away. Neither of them noticed as I retreated to my room, closing the door softly behind me.

Sitting on my bed, I stared at my phone, scrolling through Irene’s recent texts. The photos of her packing, her silly memes, her thoughtful comments—they all swirled in my mind like a kaleidoscope of emotions.

I wasn’t retreating because I thought Nicki or Beth—or even Mom—would judge me. None of them were homophobic or the type to impose rigid expectations on me. If anything, their lives had taught me that love came in all forms, sometimes messy and imperfect, but always worth fighting for.

No, my uncertainty came from within. I hadn’t figured out for myself what this all meant—what I was.

What was going on between Irene and me? Did it mean anything? Did I want it to?

I flopped back onto the bed, staring at the ceiling. Being with Irene was thrilling and terrifying all at once. She was magnetic, drawing me in with her confidence and vulnerability, her humor and kindness. But she was also guarded, hesitant, and frustratingly distant at times.

What are we? I wondered, my chest tightening at the thought. Was this just a fling? A distraction? Or was it something deeper?

I thought about her smile. Her soft lips on my skin. Her fingers inside me that made me scream on the top of my lungs from pleasure.

And where did that leave me? I’d never thought much about labels—straight, gay, bi. I’d always just been… Emma. But now, with Irene, the question lingered like a shadow I couldn’t shake.

I sighed, grabbing the bunny pen from my nightstand and twirling it between my fingers. The small, silly gift felt heavier than it should, a reminder of how much Irene meant to me already.

I don’t have all the answers right now, I thought, staring at the soft pink bunny. But maybe that’s okay. Maybe figuring it out is part of the journey.

For now, I let myself sink into the thought of Irene—her smile, her laugh, the way she made me feel alive. And as confusing as it all was, I couldn’t help but hope that, somehow, it would all make sense in the end.