Chapter 46

Ava’s pov

I stepped into Dale’s bedroom and gently closed the door behind me. I had tiptoed into the house not wanting to be met by my aunt. Thankfully, I did not run into her.

This was the first time she wasn’t up waiting for me when I got back from Studio Casanova and I wondered if she was asleep or was held up at the resort where she was frequenting recently.

“Hey.” A voice said in the dark room and the lights came on immediately.

My soul flew out of my body in that instant. My hand flew to my heart as I doubled over in shock.

Dale was seated on his bed, facing the door. He had the stance of someone who had been waiting for a while and I wondered how long he had been back home. We had left the house at approximately the same time.

“You scared the shit out of me,” I said, sucking in some air, getting my heart to calm down and beat normally.

“I am sorry about that, but it was worth it.” He said with a smirk and I flashed him a glare.

He responded with a smile and I couldn’t help but smile back.

“You are back early. How was your night?” I asked, dropping my bag on the bed.

“It was okay, but I had to rush back early because I kept thinking of you.” He said.

The moment the words came out of his mouth, I shot him a surprised look. That was odd because he had been the one who insisted that I go to Studio Casanova that night.

“Are you sure you really missed me? Because the last time I checked, you were the one who asked me to go out and have sex with a mysterious man.” I teased him.

His smile grew wider and he gestured his fingers my way, asking me to come over. Slowly and slyly, I walked over to him.

He tapped his thigh and I lowered myself down. His legs spread to carry my weight and I placed my hands around his neck.

“You see, you having sex with a mysterious man is exactly the main reason why I could not stop thinking about you. I wondered if he was making love to you better than I would and honestly, the thought did not sit well with me.”

A proud smile played around my lips at his confession. So he was jealous? Well, that was a good thing to see. It meant that he liked me well enough not to be comfortable sharing me with another man.

“Well, I guess you have a legit reason to be worried, because this Mystery Man of mine is very good at ensuring I achieve my pleasures,” I said to him without feeling one bit bad about the truth.

Mystery Man was good and as much as I liked Dale, I could not take that away from the mysterious man.

“I see. So how does he get to be different from me? What makes him better than me?” He asked with hooded eyes and I could almost touch the jealousy that was emanating from him.

“I never said that he was better than you,” I said, still standing on the truth.

“Hmmm. So, I am better than him then huh?” The corners of his lips lifted up into a smile.

“I didn’t say that either.” I chuckled and got up from his leg.

His hand wrapped around my wrist, preventing me from stepping away from him.

“At least, let me know who you prefer between the two of us.”

There was a plea in Dale’s eyes and I could not believe that this enigma for a man was really bothered at the possibility that a strange man would be satisfying me better than he does.

I let out a sigh and returned my butt to his leg. Well, if he wanted the truth, then I would tell him the truth no matter how hard it might sound.

“You see, the truth is that I can not bring myself to actually pick a favourite between the two of you. You both touch me in ways that I can not explain. You have your unique way of making me feel pleasure and he equally has his. While you take charge of our lovemaking session, he allows me to take charge.

He allows me to express my deepest wildest desires. He is a strange person, but he touches me. It is as if he has known me for a long time and that is exactly how he feels so familiar to you.

He reminds me of you and even when I am having sex with him, I constantly think of you. Both of you are intertwined in my life in a very complex manner and you asking me who is better is hard to answer, because both of you are special to me.” I said with all honesty.

“Hmmm.” He scoffed and pulled me closer to his body. “This doesn’t make it any easier, but I would not argue. We all have our needs and ways of satisfying them. So tell me, how was your session with him tonight?”

A bright smile appeared on my face as my sore vagina throbbed with remembrance of all the pleasure she had endured that night. “It was beautiful. We role-played and I was the teacher, while he was the student. It was so much fun and he fucked me really good.”

There was a thick hood of jealousy in Dale’s eyes and I wondered if it was such a great idea to tell him how well Mystery Man made me feel.

“Hmm, how good did he fuck you?” He asked.

I stayed silent for a few seconds and said, “I don’t know if it would be a good idea for me to tell you all about it.”

“I don’t want you to tell me all about it, Ava. I want you to show me.” He said and directed my palm to my core. “Explain every detail to me and fuck yourself while you do that. That way, I can really see how good he is.”