Chapter 40: Chapter 40
Kieran POV
I stand there watching her walk away from me, my eyes following her until she disappears back into the stadium. She never looks back, and somehow that hurts more than if she'd yelled at me again. I'd come down here hoping we'd finally clear the air, but all I'd managed to do was remind her why she'd stopped trusting me in the first place.
A few moments later Liam and Zaire walk over to me.
“How did it go?” Liam asks.
I shrug. “I think I made things worse,” I admit, rubbing the back of my neck.
“Well, her being mad is a good sign. It means she cares,” Zaire says, shrugging his shoulders.
I cut my eyes to him.
“Not helping.”
“I mean, you have it the hardest. Now she knows you purposely made it seem like you didn't know her... when you wanted her before her sister,” he adds.
“Why did you lie though? And what did you do freshman year?” Liam asks.
“At the time, I didn't want Aliza to turn me down because I knew her sister,” I say. I tell them about the summer program and about the note when the school year started, and somehow saying it all out loud makes everything sound worse. I'd spent an entire summer getting to know Kaelani only to spend years pretending none of it had happened.
“So you cared more about her looks and how other people saw her?” Liam asks.
“Yes,” I admit quietly. “Being an Alpha heir going into high school... I cared way too much about my image.”
“But you already liked her,” Zaire says.
“I know that,” I snap, immediately regretting my tone.
“So then why care? I'm sure she's always been beautiful. She just hid behind the clothes.”
He's right.
I thought Kaelani was pretty the first day I saw her walk into that classroom. Then I got to know her, and somehow her personality made her even prettier. But at fifteen, I cared more about what everyone else would think than what I actually wanted.
You were stupid, Atlas says with a laugh.
I was young and dumb, I admit to both him and myself.
“So on the first day, you really didn't know why she was acting that way with you?” Liam asks.
I shake my head. “I didn't remember. Kaia told me at the party on Friday. Then when I went to talk to her, she was drunk.”
Zaire smiles.
“She's fun when she's drunk,” he says, laughing.
A laugh escapes me before I can stop it, and Liam joins in.
“At least you didn't get assaulted,” Zaire adds, shaking his head at the memory.
That only makes us laugh harder. For a few seconds, everything feels normal again... until reality settles back over us.
A she-wolf whose name I can't remember walks over, a confident smile already on her face. Normally I'd know exactly who she was, but right now I couldn't remember what pack she even belonged to.
“Hey, boys,” she says seductively.
“Hey,” we answer together.
“So... is it true that all three of you are dating Aliza's sister?” she asks.
“Why?” Zaire asks.
Her eyes lock onto me.
“Well, a lot of us girls have been waiting for Kieran to be single.”
“I’m not interested,” I say without hesitation.
She pouts.
“Oh, but why not? I'm sure I can be more fun than Aliza... and her sister.”
She slowly runs a finger down my arm.
I gently take her wrist and move her hand away.
“Please don't do that,” I say quietly.
“So you'd rather share the tomboy turned girly girl?” she asks.
My jaw tightens before I even realize it. Hearing someone reduce Kaelani to that irritates me more than it should.
“Nobody is sharing anyone,” Liam says.
“Well, rumor has it that you three are sharing her.”
“Well, you shouldn't believe everything you hear,” I reply, my voice noticeably tighter than before.
“Are you done? Because he already told you he wasn't interested,” Zaire says.
She sucks her teeth.
“I'm done... for now. I'm sure you'll get tired of the nerd soon. I'll be waiting. See you around, Kieran.”
She turns and sashays down the hallway without another glance.
Zaire lets out a laugh, pointing after her.
“I thought the girls at my school were bad. That was crazy.”
“So... are you actually leaving in two months?” Liam asks.
Zaire shrugs.
“I don't want to. But she doesn't want me to stay, so I don't want to if she doesn't want me here.”
“She wants you here,” Liam and I say at the same time.
We glance at each other before laughing.
“She said it multiple times,” He points out.
“Yeah,” Liam says. “Because she isn't used to all of the attention. She thinks if you leave it'll lessen, but the damage is already done.”
“Yeah. The skate party just made everything worse,” I add. “You kissed her and everybody saw it. Then she danced with all three of us together.”
“That dance was hot,” Zaire says, looking like he's replaying it in his head.
I can't help but picture it too. Kaelani laughing, completely carefree as she danced between the three of us. It was the happiest I'd seen her in a long time.
“I didn't think she had that in her,” Liam says with a smile.
“It was the alcohol,” Zaire replies. “It dropped some of those walls she has up.”
Silence settles over us again, but this time it isn't awkward. We're all caught in our own thoughts until Liam finally breaks it.
“Why don't we hate each other?” he asks, looking between me and Zaire.
Neither of us answers immediately.
“We're three Alpha wolves all interested in the same girl,” he continues. “We should be at each other's throats, yet we're standing here talking about how to fix your relationship with her. The two of us watched Zaire kiss her, the three of us danced with her together, and nobody lost it. What's that about?”
I frown, replaying everything that's happened over the last week in my head. When he says it out loud, it really does sound strange.
“I should probably hate both of you,” Zaire says with a laugh.
“Same,” Liam admits. “But I don't.”
“Me either,” I say, and the words surprise me as much as they seem to surprise them.
The three of us fall quiet again, each trying to make sense of something none of us can explain. Every instinct says this shouldn't be possible, yet here we are.
“Do you think she's mated to all three of us?” Liam finally asks.
The question hangs in the air longer than I expect. It sounds impossible, almost ridiculous... yet none of us laugh.
“My dad always said if an Alpha wolf meets their mate before their eighteenth birthday, they'll naturally want to be around them. Looking back... I've kind of been drawn to her since the first day of school.”
“Honestly, same,” I admit. “I just never questioned it.”
“I think it was the same for me,” Zaire says. “The first time I saw her at Mitzy's, something told me to sit with her and Kaia. I didn't even think about it.”
“Three mates?” Liam mutters, rubbing the back of his neck. “That's never happened. Hell, two mates rarely happen.”
“It has to be something else,” I say, shaking my head. “Nobody has three mates.”
“Hey, guys... we're up.”
The second I hear her voice, every thought in my head disappears.
Funny. We'd spent the last few minutes trying to make sense of why three Alpha heirs weren't acting like three Alpha heirs.
Instead of rivals, we'd somehow become allies.
The three of us turn toward her at the same time.
She raises a brow.
“You three good?”
“We're good,” Liam answers.
“Well, the four of us are up.”
“Together?” all three of us ask.
She rolls her eyes.
“Unfortunately. Now go change.”
She turns and heads toward the locker rooms, leaving the three of us standing there for another second before we finally start moving.
Whoever put this schedule together had a cruel sense of humor. Because somehow the four of us were about to compete against each other... and I had a feeling the obstacle course was about to become the least complicated part of my day.