Chapter 20: Chapter 20

Kieran POV

I use the moment I see Kaelani walk off with Zaire to talk to Kaia.

I tried not to look at her too much when she walked in, but seeing her walk off with him holding hands doesn’t sit right with me.

The worst part is that I don't have a good reason for why it bothers me. She isn't my girlfriend. She isn't even my friend. Hell, she barely tolerates being in the same room as me. Yet watching her disappear behind a closed door with another guy immediately puts me in a bad mood.

“Jealous much” Atlas teases.

“Shut up you stupid wolf” I snap at him.

“Hey I’m going to find Caelum and get a drink” I say to Aliza in her ear.

“Okay, I’m going downstairs to dance come find me when you’re done. Don’t make me come looking for you Kieran” she says before kissing me and walking away.

Guilt immediately settles in my chest as I watch her leave. A good boyfriend would be paying attention to his girlfriend right now. Instead I'm standing here trying to figure out how I managed to ruin things with her sister before we ever even became friends.

The second she walks down the steps I walk towards Kaia.

“Hey Kaia can I talk to you for a second?” I ask tapping her shoulder.

She places both of her hands over her face and groans into them.

“I wish you wouldn’t have approached me but fine, make it quick” she says and we move towards the bar.

“You want to know what you did, don’t you?” she asks

“I’m obviously not going to get the answer from her” I say.

She giggles at that.

“Yeah you won’t, okay but if you makes things worse with this information, I did not tell you" She says.

"So why are you?" I ask

She shrugs "I don't think you’re a complete asshole"

I shake my head "Thanks, I think"

"Do you remember the Summer program we all took before the school year started Freshman year?” she asks.

“Vaguely, why?” I ask.

Freshman year feels like a lifetime ago. Most of what I remember is training, parties, girls and trying to prove I belonged among the future Alpha heirs. None of those memories include Kaelani. At least I didn't think they did.

“That was the first time you two met and she had the biggest crush ever on you the entire Summer” she says.

That truth slams into me like a truck.

Kaelani had a crush on me.

How the fuck did I not know that.

I replay every interaction I can remember from that summer and come up with nothing. Not because she wasn't there, but because I probably wasn't paying attention. Back then there were always she-wolves around me. I never had to notice who was quietly standing in the background because somebody louder was always demanding my attention.

“When school started I convinced her to tell you but Lani has always been quiet, shy and not used to attention. So she wrote you a note and stuck it in your locker. I guess she heard you find the note with your friends. They joked about you dating the geeky tomboy with the oversized clothes. Your exact words were she’s not my type, maybe if she spent more time focused on how she looked and less on her grades, boys wouldn’t run from her” she says.

My eyes go wide.

That’s why she won’t speak to me.

The memory hits me immediately. Not because I remember Kaelani, but because I remember saying things like that all the time. Back then I thought I was funny. I thought making jokes for my friends made me look cool. I never stopped to think about who might hear them or how much damage they could do.

The worst part is that I know Kaia isn't exaggerating. Those sound exactly like something fourteen-year-old me would have said without thinking twice about it.

“Then the next year Aliza came to the school, you basically followed her around like a lost puppy until she agreed to date you and that was after she begged Ezra” she says.

And somehow that probably made everything worse. From Kaelani's perspective I rejected her and then immediately started chasing her sister. No wonder she looks at me like I’m an idiot every time I open my mouth.

“How do I fix it?” I ask her.

She shrugs.

“Not sure, you were the only boy she openly admitted to liking and then you embarrassed her in front of all of your friends. I do know it’s not as easy as a simple apology especially not while dating her sister. Good luck Kieran.”

That answer hits harder than I want it to. I've spent all week thinking there was some magic combination of words that would make her forgive me. Now I'm realizing there probably isn't. Some mistakes don't disappear because you're finally sorry about them years later.

“Oh and if you are actually interested in pursuing my friend maybe break up with her sister first. Also remember you aren’t the only boy who sees her, but you are the only one at a disadvantage” she says before walking away from me.

My eyes immediately drift toward the door Kaelani disappeared through with Zaire. Then I think about Liam smiling every time she walks into a room.

Kaia is right. They didn't spend years giving her reasons to hate them. They aren't trying to overcome three years of resentment and one very stupid comment made by a fourteen-year-old boy who thought he knew everything.

Now I'm no longer wondering why Kaelani won't talk to me and start wondering if I already missed my chance before I even knew I wanted one.

I stand there for a second stuck.

I spent the entire day convinced there was some misunderstanding. Some forgotten argument. Some stupid joke that got blown out of proportion. Instead I find out I was the problem all along. Not just a little bit either. I took the one girl who actually liked me for me probably and gave her a reason to never want anything to do with me again.

I don’t even know what to do with this information now.

Caelum walks over with two cups in his hand and hands one to me when he walks up.

“Thanks, how did you know I needed it?” I ask.

“I saw Kaia by the bar, she told me she told you what happened” he says.

“Come on don’t leave me in suspense” he says.

I glare at him.

I exhale sharply.

“Fine, Kaelani had a crush on me Freshman year and she wrote me a letter and I pretty much said if she worried more about her looks and less about her grades boys wouldn’t run from her” I say getting even more annoyed repeating it myself.

The words sound even worse coming out of my mouth now than they probably did back then. I don't know what bothers me more, the fact that I said it or the fact that I can barely remember saying it while she's clearly been carrying it around for three years.

Caelum whistles low.

“Yikes yeah man I wouldn’t talk to you either, then to turn around and see you dating her sister. I’m shocked she didn’t punch you the moment you walked up” he says.

Honestly, so am I. Looking back at every interaction we've had this week, Kaelani has shown way more patience than I deserved. Most people would have told me exactly where to go the second I approached them. Instead she kept giving me opportunities to leave it alone and I just kept pushing.

“You’re not helping” I say through gritted teeth.

He shrugs.

“I’m not supposed to that’s what friends are for. Besides you know I’m right” he says.

“He is right” Atlas chimes in.

“Okay so what should I do?” I ask and he laughs at me.

“First thing break up with Aliza because you don’t stand a chance otherwise, hell you probably still won’t” he says.

That one lands harder than everything else he's said tonight because deep down I already know he's right. Even if I broke up with Aliza tomorrow, it wouldn't erase what happened. It wouldn't erase three years of avoiding Kaelani. It wouldn't erase the fact that the first real conversation we've had ended with her telling me to leave her alone.

He’s right again, knowing only made things much more worse than better.

At least before I had questions. Questions were easy because they came with the hope that the answer would somehow fix everything. Now I have the answer and all it's done is show me how badly I screwed up.

The worst part is that Kaia wasn't wrong either. Liam doesn't have this baggage. Zaire doesn't have this baggage. Neither of them spent years giving Kaelani reasons to dislike them. While they're starting at zero, I'm already buried under a mistake I made three years ago and didn't even remember making.

The even messed up part is that Liam and Zaire never had to earn a chance with her. I did have one and I threw it away before I even realized it mattered.