Chapter 145
Sarah's POV
Destiny was staring now, her curiosity barely concealed behind a veneer of disinterest, and I could practically hear the questions forming in her mind, could already imagine the gossip she'd spread to the other evening-shift workers about my mysterious visitor in the expensive suit.
I grabbed the cleaning rag from beneath the counter, needing an excuse to move, to do something other than stand frozen like a deer in headlights, and walked over to the condiment station near where Cole sat, wiping down surfaces that didn't need cleaning while my heart hammered against my ribs hard enough to bruise.
"What are you doing here?" I kept my voice low, barely above a whisper, not wanting Destiny to overhear, not wanting this moment to become part of the store's collective memory, something that would linger and fester long after Cole left.
He took another sip of water, his eyes tracking my movements with that unsettling focus, and when he spoke, his tone was mild, almost amused. "I'm a customer. Is there a problem with that?"
I wanted to scream at him, wanted to throw the rag in his face and demand to know what sick game he was playing, but I forced myself to breathe, to count to three before responding. "Don't pretend this is a coincidence. You want something. Say it and leave."
"Here isn't really the place for the conversation we need to have," he said, and there was something in his voice now, an edge beneath the smoothness that made my pulse spike with fresh alarm. "It's about Linnet."
The sound of my daughter's name in his mouth was like a physical blow, stealing the air from my lungs and making the edges of my vision blur with sudden, visceral fear.
Linnet. He knew about Linnet—of course he did, he'd hired her to tutor his son, but hearing him say her name with that same proprietary tone he'd once used when talking about me, as if she were already part of his world, already caught in the web he wove so expertly, made something primal and protective surge up in my chest, made my hands curl into fists around the damp rag.
"What about her?" The words came out sharper than I'd intended, edged with the panic I couldn't quite suppress, and Cole's expression shifted, a flash of satisfaction crossing his features so quickly I might have imagined it.
"Not here," he repeated, his gaze flicking meaningfully toward Destiny, who was now openly watching our exchange with undisguised interest. "This is important, Sarah. You'll want to hear it."
I stood there, trapped between the instinct to tell him to go to hell and the terrible certainty that whatever he knew about Linnet, whatever he'd come here to tell me, was something I couldn't afford to ignore.
"I'm working," I said, hating how weak my voice sounded, how much it betrayed my fear. "I can't just leave."
"Then take a break." He gestured toward the door with his water bottle, the motion casual, as if he were suggesting we step outside for fresh air rather than whatever confrontation he had planned. "Fifteen minutes. That's all I need."
I looked back at Destiny, at her curious, slightly suspicious expression, and made a decision I knew I'd regret. "Destiny, I need to step out for a bit. Family emergency."
She frowned, glancing between me and Cole, and I could see her trying to piece together our relationship, to figure out who this well-dressed stranger was and why I looked like I'd seen a ghost. "Your shift doesn't end for another hour—"
"I know. I'll make it up. Please." The desperation in my voice must have convinced her, because after a moment's hesitation, she nodded, her expression softening into something that might have been sympathy or might have just been relief at getting some juicy gossip to share later.
I stripped off my red vest with shaking hands, grabbed my coat from the hook behind the counter, and followed Cole out into the November evening, the cold air hitting my face like a slap, crystallizing my breath into white clouds that dissipated almost immediately. His car was parked at the curb, its sleek lines and tinted windows radiating the kind of wealth that had always seemed like a fantasy to me, something that existed in movies and magazines but never in the messy, struggling reality of my actual life.
He walked to the driver's side, and after a moment's hesitation, I opened the passenger door and slid inside, the leather seats soft beneath me, the interior smelling of new car and that same expensive cologne, and when the door clicked shut behind me, the sound was so final, so absolute, that for a wild second I felt like I'd just sealed myself inside a tomb.
"What do you want?" I demanded before he could start the engine, before he could drive us somewhere even more isolated, somewhere I'd have even less control. "You said this was about Linnet. Talk."
He turned the key in the ignition, and the engine purred to life, smooth and nearly silent, a stark contrast to the rattling wheeze of the buses I rode every day. "I will. But not in a parking lot where anyone walking by can see us. We're going somewhere private."
"No." I reached for the door handle, my heart racing, but he hit the central lock button before I could pull it, the click of the mechanism engaging sending a fresh spike of panic through my system. "Cole, let me out. Right now."
"Relax, Sarah." He put the car in drive and pulled away from the curb, his movements calm and controlled, as if he were taking us on a pleasant Sunday drive rather than effectively kidnapping me from my workplace. "I'm just taking you home. We can talk there."
"You don't know where I live—" I started, but the words died in my throat as I saw the route he was taking, the turns he made without hesitation, heading directly toward the aging apartment complex on the edge of the old town where Linnet and I had lived for years.
He knew. Of course he knew. He'd probably known for months, had probably been watching and waiting and planning this exact moment, and the realization made bile rise in my throat, made my hands shake so badly I had to clasp them together in my lap to hide it.
"How?" I whispered, and I hated how small my voice sounded, how utterly defeated.
"I needed to know who was tutoring my son," he said, his tone matter-of-fact, as if conducting surveillance on the people in his orbit was the most natural thing in the world. "Background checks are standard procedure, Sarah. Surely you understand that."
I stared out the window at the familiar streets sliding past, at the bodega where I bought milk, at the laundromat where I spent Sunday mornings, at all the markers of the life I'd built in the ruins of my shattered dreams, and I felt something inside me crack, felt the careful walls I'd constructed around my past beginning to crumble.
Cole knew where I lived. Cole knew about Linnet's tutoring arrangement. And if he knew that much, what else had he discovered? What other pieces of my carefully guarded privacy had he violated?