Chapter 25: A message from Evelyn?
“Dinner is ready,” Christopher’s voice cuts through my thoughts, his sudden presence by my side startling me.
“Dinner? I didn’t see anyone coming here,” I say, looking around, half-expecting to find a cook or someone else he might have called.
“If you mean the delivery guy, he already left,” Christopher replies, turning to walk back inside with relaxed ease, hands in his pockets.
I follow him into the kitchen, expecting a fancy meal like those at the Houghton mansion. Yet, the smell of pizza greets me before I even see the open box on the table in front of the sofa.
My eyes shift to Christopher, who tosses his phone toward me with a challenging look in his eyes. I catch it awkwardly in the air, nearly dropping it.
“If you don’t like pizza, you can order something else. I’ve left the delivery app open for you,” Christopher says, his tone casual.
“Pizza?” I repeat, my voice filled with surprise. “You, the Houghton’s heir, are eating… delivered pizza?”
Christopher ignores my reaction, turning away to get something from the fridge.
“Wait… you have been eating this?” I ask, unable to hide my surprise. That isn’t the kind of meal I would expect from someone who usually cares so much about appearances and following rules.
“Yes,” he simply answers, like it were the most normal thing in the world.
My eyes scan his body, the tight black T-shirt and sweatpants, and I have to admit that Christopher’s body is… quite impressive. His strong arms are well-muscled, showing he spends a lot of time at the gym and playing sports. I’ve also noticed his six-pack and the attractive V-line above his abs. His thighs aren’t seen often, but they’re muscular as well. Everything about him is strong and well-proportioned… even his soft hands, as expected from someone of his status, are big and veiny. In fact, the veins on all his arms are surprisingly appealing.
But pizza? How does he keep up such a perfect shape on such a terrible diet?
Christopher catches me looking and smirks, amusement flickering across his features. It’s a look that says he knows exactly what I’m thinking and finds it funny.
“You’re really being serious right now?” I ask, truly surprised, still getting used to the simplicity of the moment. It’s weird because Christopher always looked like… a marble statue to me. He’s the kind we admire because it’s so close to reality, but in the end, it’s still made of stone, where there’s no beating heart. Maybe that’s why seeing him be so human is disconcerting to the point of knotting my mind.
“I’m sorry if this isn’t to your liking,” Christopher approaches slowly, and I struggle to hold his gaze. “I should have known that pizza wouldn’t fit the Earl’s favorite’s refined taste.”
He stops a step from me, studying my face carefully, lingering for a few moments on my lips that burn under his gaze.
“I can take pizza just fine,” I mutter, looking away, slightly embarrassed by the proximity and Christopher’s teasing. He’s treating me like I’m a picky child.
Christopher’s smile grows wider, and I purse my lips, watching as he goes back to the sofa, taking a big slice of pizza before sitting down. He grabs the remote and turns on the TV, taking a bite — so easily, so normal... I think I’m hallucinating.
Did I go into a coma, trapped in some kind of dream?
Even during our childhood, I never saw Christopher like this. He always had a misplaced seriousness for such a young boy. His world seemed to revolve around books, lessons, and duties. It was indeed as if there was a wall around him. Still, he used to be kind. He would smile at me... until he went to Cambridge and met Evelyn — that’s when he completely turned his back on me.
But this new Christopher, who comfortably eats pizza and sits on the sofa so carelessly, is a true surprise. Maybe it’s the city, this apartment, or perhaps that’s his true self, away from the pressures of his social role. Honestly, I don’t know…
But I like this one better.
“What?” Christopher’s voice sounds louder, startling me.
“Nothing, it’s just that… hmm… I never thought you’d pick pizza for dinner.”
He laughs — a sound low and genuine that also makes me smile without wanting to.
“I thought it was clear that there are many things we don’t know about each other,” Christopher says, looking at me a striking honestly. “Trust me, pizza is probably the least surprising one.”
“So, liking pizza has always been your secret?”
He smiles again, putting down the half-eaten slice, “Are you curious about me, Charlotte?”
I roll my eyes and cross my arms, and he laughs.
“Yes, I’ve always liked it. But pizza isn’t exactly seen as proper for someone in my position... at least not from a fast-food.”
He finishes his slice and grabs another.
I stay at the entrance to the living room, watching him for a moment longer. The light from the TV casts shadows across his face, changing how I see him. It’s truly both odd and interesting to see this side of him, so different from the controlled, fancy image he always showed to the world.
“So, you like simple things,” I state, understanding a bit more now. Christopher also seems choked by the luxury around us — but unlike me, he can’t escape. I can understand now why Christopher hates me so much. I suffocated him. I trapped him. But the Charlotte of before didn’t understand that, didn’t see the world with today’s eyes.
If only I had chosen differently… if my heart hadn’t been so tied to him…
“Yes, I guess I do,” he admits softly. “Maybe you’ll take a liking to it too.”
“Maybe,” I say with a sigh, clutching the sides of my flared skirt.
I’m tired, my shoulders heavy, and honestly, hungry. The enticing smell of cheesy dough fills the room, making my stomach rumble more than I’d like to admit…
With another sigh, I finally give in and walk towards him, calm and a bit hesitant. The wooden floor creaks under my feet as I sit beside him on the sofa, thanking God it’s comfy…
“Tired of standing?”
“Shut up.” I retort, and even though a slight tension fills the air, there’s an unspoken peace as Christopher keeps eating his pizza.
I watch, captivated, as he casually brings another slice to his mouth, and I can’t help but notice his thick, dark hair styled back smoothly and intense brown eyes.
Up this close, I can see the light stubble around his jaw, chin, and upper lip properly, which gives him a more mature look, even though he’s only 26.
“Do you need a plate and a fork?” he teases, a mocking smile on his lips.
“There’s no need. I’m perfectly capable of eating pizza like a normal person, Christopher,” I retort, turning my face away, feeling a rush of stubborn pride heat my cheeks.
Argh… Why am I checking him out?
Despite my weirdness in thinking that Christopher is handsome, I grab a slice directly from the box and feel the warmth in my hands.
The first bite feels amazing, better than I expected. The cheese, the well-spiced sauce, the crust with just the right crunch — it’s so tasty that I let out a soft moan of pleasure.
This sound grabs Christopher’s full attention; he turns to look at me, his eyes shining with a mix of surprise and something else I can’t quite decipher.
My cheeks get even hotter as I lick my fingers, catching his intense look as it follows every move, especially my tongue, without even blinking.
For a moment, it seems he might say something, but instead, he clears his throat and looks back at the TV, almost stunned.
Suddenly, the sofa feels smaller now.
The silence stretches, heavy and uncomfortable, only broken by the low hum of the TV and our chewing. Christopher eats fast, and again, I wonder how he keeps his muscles so defined with such a diet. Does he often eat fast food? He should eat something appropriate, with nutrients… maybe I should cook something —
My thought is interrupted by his cell phone vibrating in my hand. I almost forgot he tossed it to me earlier.
Without much thought, I pick it up to check the notification, and a wave of shock runs over me as I see the screen… it’s a message from Evelyn — and its contents twist my stomach.