Chapter 24: The Wrong Story

The envelope feels heavier than it should. My fingers hover over it, but George does not let go. His eyes are locked on mine, and the silence between us stretches long enough to make my stomach twist.

“You have been carrying this around,” I say.

“Waiting,” he answers.

“For what?”

“For you to stop running.”

The words land hard. My instinct is to throw them back at him, but before I can, the door creaks open. I flinch, shoving the envelope behind my back like it is something dangerous.

Two voices drift in from the hallway, laughing, low and close. It is Tyler and Mason from the team. They do not step inside, but I hear one of them say, “Told you they were in here together.”

The laughter sharpens into something knowing.

George’s jaw tightens. He does not move until their footsteps fade. “You might want to get used to that,” he says.

“What is that supposed to mean?”

“That people are going to start making up their own story about us.”

I shake my head, stepping back. “No one cares.”

“You think that until it is all they talk about.”

I do not answer. My heart is already pounding from the way Tyler’s voice had sounded, half amusement and half certainty.

George lets go of the envelope. “Take it. But do not open it here.”

“Why not?”

“Because once you see what is inside, you will not be able to stand still. And I think you are already holding it together by a thread.”

The stubborn part of me wants to rip it open just to prove him wrong, but I slide it into my jacket pocket instead.

When I leave the trainer’s room, the hallway feels colder. I can feel eyes on me even when there is no one there. By the time I reach the locker room, a couple of my teammates are sitting on the benches, still in half their gear.

“Late morning practice together?” one of them says with a grin.

“Working on drills,” I mutter.

“Yeah, sure,” another chimes in. “That what we are calling it now?”

They laugh, not in a cruel way, but in a way that makes heat rush to my face. I keep my head down and stuff my gear into my bag.

The whispers follow me out to the parking lot. They are not loud enough to catch every word, but I do not have to. I know the tone. I have heard it before about other people.

By the time I reach the apartment, my skin feels too tight. Mom is not home, which is both a relief and a small ache I do not want to think about. I drop my bag in the corner and pull the envelope out of my pocket.

I sit on the edge of my bed, the paper cool in my hands. I could open it right now. I could know. But my phone buzzes, and when I check the screen, it is a message from Jessie.

Saw George leaving with you. Want to talk about it?

I stare at the message until it blurs. Jessie does not send texts like that unless she has already heard something.

The rumors are moving faster than I thought.

I toss the phone aside and press my palms to my eyes. If I open the envelope now, it will not just be my head spinning, it will be the entire day unraveling.

The knock at my door makes me jump.

It is soft, hesitant. When I open it, George is there.

“You should not be here,” I say.

“Too late,” he replies, stepping past me into the room. He glances at the envelope still in my hand. “You did not open it.”

“I will.”

“When?”

“When I am ready.”

His gaze searches mine. “Ready or not, the rumor mill is already turning. I heard three different versions of our story in the locker room before I left.”

My chest tightens. “And you are just fine with that?”

He shrugs. “People talk. Let them. It will distract them from the real reason we are spending time together.”

I fold my arms. “And what is that reason exactly?”

He leans in, close enough that I can feel the faint chill from the rink still clinging to his clothes. “Finding out the truth about Connor. About your mom. About how it all fits together.”

My breath catches. “You sound like you already know.”

“Parts,” he says. “But it is the part I cannot prove yet that is going to matter the most to you.”

Before I can ask what that means, another knock echoes from the front door. Louder this time.

We both freeze.

George’s eyes flick to the hallway. “Expecting someone?”

“No.”

The knock comes again, sharper.

Something in his expression shifts. “You might want to hide that envelope,” he says quietly.

My fingers tighten around it. “Why?”

“Because if it is who I think it is, they are not here to be friendly.”

The third knock rattles the frame.

And in the back of my mind, I already know. Whatever is on the other side of that door could blow the rumors wide open or make them irrelevant compared to what is coming next.