Chapter 19: Thin Ice
I do not look at him when we step off the ice. If I do, I might see what almost happened, and that would make it too real. My skates click against the rubber flooring as I head for the bench. George is a shadow behind me, silent but too close.
In the locker room, I peel off my gloves and grab my water bottle. My hands are still shaking, though I tell myself it is from the drills, not from him.
“What’s your problem?” he asks finally.
The words are sharp enough to make me turn. “My problem?”
“You’ve been staring at the floor like it insulted you since we left the ice.”
“Maybe I’m just trying to avoid talking to you.”
His mouth tips into something halfway between a smirk and a frown. “Sure. That’s why you were fine skating with me ten minutes ago.”
“That was different.”
“How?”
“Because it wasn’t about you,” I snap.
He tilts his head like he is considering whether to push. “If you say so.”
I turn away, stuffing my gloves into my bag with more force than necessary. “I don’t need your commentary.”
“You do if you want to stop choking when it matters.”
That makes me whirl back to face him. “I’m not choking.”
“Yes, you are.” His voice is low, steady. “You play safe until the second it counts, and then you pull back. You’re scared to go all in.”
My jaw tightens. “And you’re not?”
“I’m not talking about me.”
The way he says it, like my fear is a fact carved into stone, makes heat rise in my chest. “You think you know me? You think a couple of practice sessions and a few half-truths make you some kind of expert on Cassandra?”
His eyes sharpen. “I think I know what I see. And I see someone who’s better than the way she’s been playing.”
Something inside me twists. Maybe because I know he is right, maybe because I hate that he is right. “You’re so sure you have me figured out? Fine. Let me guess something about you.”
“Go ahead.”
“You’re using me.” The words come out before I can stop them. “You’re digging into Connor’s story, my story, so you can—what? Clear your name? Feel better about whatever happened between you two? You act like you’re helping me, but you’re just helping yourself.”
His expression changes so fast I almost miss it, like a shadow passing over him. “That’s not what I’m doing.”
“Then what are you doing?”
He steps closer, the air between us tightening. “Trying to make sure Connor doesn’t get turned into a ghost no one remembers.”
“You think you’re the only one who cares about that?”
“No. But I think I might be the only one willing to tell you the parts you don’t want to hear.”
The words land like a slap. For a moment, neither of us speaks. The hum of the overhead lights fills the space where my heartbeat should be.
Finally, I shake my head. “You’re not the hero here, George.”
“I never said I was.”
He picks up his stick, slinging it over his shoulder. The way he moves, like he’s done with the conversation, makes my chest ache with something I can’t name.
I grab my bag and follow him out, the tension between us trailing like smoke.
The walk to the parking lot is quiet, but it is not a peaceful quiet. Every step feels like it is leading somewhere I am not ready to go.
When we reach his car, he turns to me. “You want to know the truth? You scare me.”
The admission throws me. “What?”
“You play like you’ve got nothing to lose until the second you remember you do. And that’s when you pull back. You don’t scare me because you’re not good enough. You scare me because you’re better than you let yourself be.”
I do not know whether to be insulted or grateful. “You’re still assuming you know me.”
“Maybe I am. But I’m also right.”
I want to argue, but the words stick. I hate that he is looking at me like he sees more than I want him to.
He opens his car door. “If you’re going to keep playing scared, fine. But don’t expect me to skate alongside you when you do.”
The door shuts before I can answer. He pulls out of the lot, taillights fading into the dusk.
I stand there long after he is gone, the cold biting through my jacket. My breath fogs in the air, uneven.
In my pocket, the napkin with Connor’s name feels heavier than ever.
By the time I get home, the shop is closed and the lights are off. My mom’s car is gone. The house is too quiet. I toss my bag on the floor and sink onto the couch, trying to make sense of the last two hours.
But my brain will not let go of the way George looked at me when he said I scare him. It will not let go of the almost-kiss on the ice. It will not let go of the possibility that he might be telling the truth, even if I do not want to hear it.
I fall asleep without meaning to, and when I wake up, the living room is dark except for the glow from the streetlamp outside. My phone buzzes.
One new message.
It is from an unknown number.
You’re asking the wrong questions. Meet me tomorrow. Alone.
There is no name. No location. Just a second text that comes five seconds later.
If George finds out, it’s over.