Chapter 15: Fractures

I am still thinking about what he said.

Not just the words but the way he said them “She knew him before you were born”. Not a taunt. Not a threat. Something heavier. Something like a truth that had been burning a hole in his mouth for too long.

I try to push it out of my head during practice, but the thought clings like damp fabric. It drags at me when I skate, catches on my edges when I turn. I tell myself to focus on drills, on the simple rhythm of movement, but my brain is stuck in the hallway with him, stuck on that single sentence.

By the time Coach blows the whistle and calls us off the ice, my legs ache and my patience is thin. I head to the locker room, ready to peel off my gear and disappear before George can say a word to me.

But he is already there.

Not sprawled in his usual lazy posture, but crouched near one of the younger players, showing him how to adjust the angle of his stick. His voice is low, patient, steady. Nothing like the sharpness he usually aims at me.

“Try shifting your grip here,” he says, demonstrating. “See? Now when you lift, you’ve got more control.”

The kid tries it, and his face lights up. George claps him on the shoulder, nods once, and moves back toward his own stall.

I watch without meaning to. He doesn’t notice me. Or maybe he does and just doesn’t care.

I drop onto the bench and start untying my skates.

“That was nice,” I say without looking up.

He glances over. “What?”

“With the kid. You didn’t have to do that.”

He shrugs, pulling off his gloves. “He’s been struggling. I thought maybe it’d help.”

“You don’t usually… help.”

That earns me a faint smirk. “You mean I don’t usually help you.”

I roll my eyes, but he doesn’t push it. Instead, he sits down across from me, elbows on his knees, hands clasped loosely. He’s calmer today. Softer. The sharp edges are still there, but they’re tucked away, like he’s trying to give me space to see something else.

And I do. I see it in the way he holds himself, in the way his voice has lost that automatic bite.

It makes me uneasy.

“You’re different today,” I say before I can stop myself.

He tilts his head. “Is that good or bad?”

“I’m not sure yet.”

Something flickers in his eyes, but he doesn’t comment. Instead, he leans back against the wall, stretching his legs out in front of him. “You ever think maybe we don’t get to stay the same? That people change whether they want to or not?”

The question feels like it’s about more than just mood swings.

“Sometimes,” I say carefully. “Why?”

“Because I think I’ve been trying to hold on to who I was before everything went to hell. And maybe that’s why it’s been so hard.”

I pause. “Before Connor?”

He nods once. “Before him. Before I got stuck in this mess where I’m the bad guy no matter what I do.”

“You’re not…” I stop myself. I don’t want to give him that out.

But he hears it anyway. His eyes soften, just a fraction. “You don’t have to say it. I know what I am in your head.”

I busy myself with peeling off my pads. “You don’t actually know what’s in my head.”

“Then tell me.”

The locker room feels smaller all of a sudden, the air warmer. “You wouldn’t like it.”

He gives a humorless laugh. “I already don’t like most of the things people think about me. Might as well add yours to the list.”

I shake my head. “You think everything is a game.”

“And you think everything I say is a lie.”

The truth of it stings. “Because half the time it is.”

He leans forward again, elbows on his knees. “And the other half?”

I don’t answer. I don’t want to tell him that the other half — the half that slips through when he isn’t guarding himself — is what throws me off balance.

He studies me for a moment. “You know, Connor used to say you were the most stubborn person he’d ever met. I didn’t believe him until now.”

I freeze, my hands stilling on my laces. “Don’t talk about him like you knew him better than I did.”

“I didn’t,” he says, his tone quiet now. “But I knew parts of him you didn’t. Just like he knew parts of me nobody else does.”

The silence that follows is thick. I can feel my pulse in my throat.

He finally stands, grabbing his jacket from the hook. “I’m not asking you to trust me. I’m asking you not to decide who I am before you’ve seen all of me.”

I want to tell him I’ve seen enough. That nothing he shows me now can undo the damage he’s already done. But the problem is, that’s not entirely true.

Because I just saw him be patient with a kid who couldn’t get his stick right. I saw him quiet and still instead of sharp and biting. And now I’m stuck with the truth that maybe, maybe, there’s more to him than the version I’ve been holding onto.

And I hate that it matters.

He heads toward the door, and I turn back to my gear, willing myself not to watch him leave.

I almost succeed.

Almost.

“Cass.”

I look up. He’s at the doorway, one hand braced on the frame. His eyes are unreadable, but his voice is steady.

“Don’t go into Connor’s room without me.”

The words sink in slow, like ice melting down my spine.

“Why?”

He hesitates just long enough to make my skin crawl. “Because there’s something in there you’re not ready to see.”

And then he’s gone.

The sound of the door closing is sharp in the quiet.

I sit there, my skates half-off, my pulse pounding in my ears.

Not ready to see.

My first instinct is to defy him, to march straight home and open that door just to prove I can. But the way he said it, not as a warning, not as a dare, but as a fact is the thing that stops me.

If George Hale thinks I’m not ready, that means whatever is behind that door isn’t just a memory. It’s a fracture. And once I see it, I might not be able to unsee it.