Chapter 9: I Want Her

Chapter 9: I Want Her

Leo

The moment I laid eyes on Ivana Lennon, I wanted her.

It hadn’t been gradual. There had been no slow realization, no gentle curiosity building over time.

The attraction had hit me the instant our eyes met.

Some people might call that shallow. Lust, maybe. A momentary fascination with a very pretty face.

But I knew the difference between fleeting attraction and the kind of pull that made your instincts sit up and take notice.

This was the second kind. Which only made the entire situation stranger. Because standing in the same room with her earlier—laughing softly, wrapped around Anderson’s arm like she belonged there—was Madison Lennon.

Anderson’s choice. Ivana's older sister.

The golden girl.

From a distance, Madison was exactly the type of woman people expected men to fall for. Blonde hair that curled softly around her shoulders, a body so slim it looked like she had never eaten anything that came from a kitchen rather than a salad bar, pastel sweaters that made her appear permanently sunlit and sweet.

She was just a physical representation of every teenage boy's dream girlfriend.

She had the kind of smile that photographers loved. Perfect teeth, perfect timing, perfectly placed laughter. High school had probably worshipped her. So I heard.

She was prom queen. Cheer captain. The kind of girl whose photos lived forever in framed yearbooks.

Society loved girls like Madison. Girls who looked effortless and polished and safe. So, Anderson choosing her made perfect sense on paper.

But standing there tonight, watching both sisters move through the same space, I couldn’t understand it. Because Madison might have been the obvious choice.

But Ivana? Ivana was the one you noticed.

Madison’s blonde waves were soft and pretty, sure—but Ivana’s fiery red hair cut through a room like a flame. The soft bangs framing her face only made her eyes sharper, brighter, impossible to ignore once they locked onto yours.

Where Madison looked carefully maintained, Ivana looked real. Alive.

Her body didn’t scream starvation and strict diets. It was curved in ways that made a man’s attention settle without permission, hips and waist forming the kind of silhouette people pretended not to stare at but absolutely did.

And beyond the obvious physical differences, there was something harder to define. Something beneath the surface.

Madison looked like the kind of woman people admired.

Ivana looked like the kind of woman people wanted.

And apparently, I wasn’t the only one who noticed.

I leaned back in the corner of the living room, a red plastic cup dangling loosely from my fingers, quietly observing the scene unfolding across the room.

Madison and Anderson were still fussing over the decorations.

“No,” Madison laughed, tugging at a strand of fairy lights. “Place it over there. Right there.”

“No,” Anderson countered, holding the other end of the wire. “They’re going to look better over here.”

They went back and forth like that, smiling and arguing softly, the kind of affectionate disagreement couples had when they were too comfortable to worry about looking ridiculous in front of other people.

Watching them felt like eating something far too sweet. Eventually it made your stomach turn.

I took another sip of the punch in my cup, the sugary liquid doing absolutely nothing to improve my mood. If anything, it made the scene in front of me feel even more nauseating.

The loving glances. The casual touches. The quiet laughter.

Jesus.

I set the cup down on the table with more force than necessary and stood up before I lost my patience entirely.

Fresh air sounded like a better option.

A few minutes later, I stepped onto the front porch and descended the short staircase, the cool night air greeting me like a splash of water to the face.

I reached into my pocket, pulled out my cigarette pack, and slid one between my lips. The familiar flick of the lighter followed.

The first drag burned pleasantly in my lungs. I exhaled slowly, watching the smoke curl upward into the warm summer night.

“Holy hell,” I muttered to myself. “What a summer this is going to be.”

“You’re still here?” The voice came from behind me.

I didn’t even need to turn to recognize it. A laugh slipped out of me before I could stop it. “Are you asking me to leave?”

I glanced over my shoulder.

Anderson stood at the top of the porch steps, shoulders tense, hands clenched loosely at his sides. Even in the dim light, I could see the irritation written across his face.

He looked exactly like someone who had been waiting for an excuse to confront me. His eyes flicked briefly toward the front door behind him, as if making sure no one else was listening.

Then he stepped forward. “You shouldn’t even be here,” he said flatly.

I took another slow drag from my cigarette, enjoying the way the tension between us seemed to thicken the air.

“My mom lives here,” I replied lazily. “You’re aware of that, aren’t you?” I tilted my head slightly. “Or are you planning on claiming my mother too?”

His jaw tightened immediately.

“Don’t twist this,” he snapped. “You know exactly what I’m talking about.”

Of course I did. Anderson had never been particularly subtle when something bothered him.

I exhaled another thin stream of smoke and smiled faintly. “Relax,” I said. “I just want to talk to Ivana. Get an answer from her and I’ll be gone before you know it.”

His eyes narrowed. “An answer for what?”

I shrugged. “That’s none of your business.”

He stepped down one stair, tension radiating from him now like heat from a fire.

“We’re not friends, Anderson,” I added calmly. “Don't butt in.”

For a moment, it looked like he might actually lunge at me. “Are you messing with her to get to me?” he hissed. “Is that what you’re doing? You’re trying to get back at me for what happened to her?”

The words hit harder than I expected. For a split second, my chest tightened. The memory he’d dragged into the open wasn’t one I liked revisiting.

Even after all these years. Especially not tonight. But there was no chance I’d show him that. Not in a million years.

“You’re insulting Ivana again,” I said instead, pointing the cigarette toward him. “You think she’s so undesirable that the only reason a guy could notice her is because he’s trying to annoy you?”

I shook my head slowly.

“That’s harsh, man.”

Anderson’s expression darkened. “I know what you’re doing,” he insisted. “I know the kind of games you play. You’re not interested in Ivy. Not for real.”

I laughed outright this time. “Why wouldn’t I be?”

“Because you’re stuck in the past,” he shot back immediately. “And I’m not going to let you drag Ivy into your evil messed up plans.”

He descended the remaining steps quickly, stopping just a few feet away from me.

“Stay away from her,” he said firmly. “Stop talking to her. Stop trying to get close to her just to get my attention.”

I dropped the cigarette to the ground and crushed it beneath my shoe. “That’s a pretty serious accusation,” I said.

He stepped closer. Close enough that our shoulders were nearly touching.

“I’m warning you,” he muttered. “Stay away from her if you’re just going to hurt her.”

For a moment, I simply looked at him. The anger vibrating through him wasn’t subtle anymore. He was barely holding it back.

And honestly? That was exactly what I wanted.

“I want her,” I said calmly. “What you believe about my motives doesn’t really matter.”

His jaw clenched harder. I could practically see the restraint snapping thread by thread.

Perfect.

If he threw the first punch tonight, I’d happily return the favor. It would be incredibly satisfying to break that carefully composed pretty-boy face of his before he went inside and dropped to one knee for Madison.

So I leaned in slightly. Just enough that only he could hear the next words.

“Besides,” I murmured quietly, “I know I’m not the only one curious about what ‘Ivy Lennon’ looks like when she’s not wearing anything.”

The reaction was instant.

Anderson’s restraint finally snapped. And in less than a second, he retaliated.