Chapter 50: A Hunter And His Prize
Chapter 50: A Hunter And His Prize
Leo
She came barreling down the stairs without looking, crashing straight into my chest like the world was on fire behind her.
The force of it knocked a soft “Oof” out of her, and she immediately started apologizing in that quiet, flustered voice that always made something twist in my gut.
Her eyes were glued to the floor, shoulders hunched like she was trying to disappear into herself. But I saw everything.
The faint tremor in her hands. The way her breathing was uneven. And the single tear that slipped free before she could stop it.
I reached out without thinking, catching that tear on my thumb. It was warm. Real. “You’re crying.”
She shook her head too fast, wiping at her face with the back of her hand like the motion could erase the evidence. “No. I wasn’t. I just… got something in my eye—”
“Your lips are swollen.” My voice came out low, almost casual, but there was an edge underneath it that made her freeze. I tilted her chin up with two fingers, studying the slight puffiness again, the faint redness. “Got a little something in your mouth too?”
Her eyes went wide, panic flickering across her face. “No. No, it’s not that—”
Before she could finish, Anderson stepped out of the bedroom behind her like he owned the hallway. His hair was a little messy. His shirt was slightly wrinkled. The bastard looked satisfied with himself.
I smiled. “Anderson!” I called out, loud enough to carry but not enough to bring the whole house running. My eyes sparkled with dark amusement as I looked over her head at him. “You’re alive. How unfortunate.”
Ivy nearly gasped beside me.
Anderson’s voice was rough. “That must be distressing for you.”
“Not at all.” I kept the smile in place. “Just another opportunity for me to try harder. Trust me, I won’t fail twice.”
“Leo…” Ivy whispered, eyes huge with warning.
I shrugged, playing it off. “Just joking.” Then I let the pause stretch, watching the color drain from Anderson’s face. “I’m relieved you didn’t kick the bucket. Yet. If you had, Madison would have been terribly sad.” Another beat. “To not have known what her fiancé was up to.”
Ivy looked like her heart had stopped.
She glanced around frantically—down the stairs toward the voices floating up from the kitchen and dining room, then back at me.
Madison was down there. Poppy. Marcel. My mom. All of them were close enough to hear if I raised my voice even a little.
I knew that. I was counting on it.
Anderson’s jaw tightened. “What nonsense are you talking about? Get out of my way. I’m going downstairs.”
“Should I call Madison?” I grinned wider, leaning in just enough to make it feel intimate and threatening at the same time. “Or maybe I should call everyone present here so you can explain what you’ve been doing in Ivy’s bedroom—”
Ivy’s hand shot out, fingers wrapping around my wrist in pure fear. She shook her head slowly, another tear slipping free. “Don’t. Maddie can’t find out.” Her voice cracked. “Leo, please.”
I looked down at her. The way her lower lip trembled. The way she was still clutching that damn duffel bag like it was a lifeline.
My chest tightened with something possessive and protective all at once. I hated seeing her like this—scared, guilty, caught in the middle of a mess Anderson had created.
“Fine,” I said quietly. Then I took the bag from her hands and slung it over my shoulder. “You’re coming home with me. Get in the car. I won’t be long.”
She opened her mouth like she wanted to argue, but one look from me had her nodding. She stepped past me, head down, and made her way down the stairs without another word.
I waited until her footsteps faded and the front door clicked shut behind her.
Then I dropped the bag to the floor, grabbed Anderson by the collar, and walked him backward until his back hit the wall just outside Ivy’s bedroom door—hidden from the staircase, out of sight from anyone below.
“Get your hands off me!” he hissed, struggling.
“You were kissing my girl.” I laughed, low and cold, tightening my grip on his shirt. “You knew I was watching from the lawn. You wanted me to see. You’re that desperate for her affection now that you’ll resort to harassment and straight-up assault.”
“Ivy loves me,” he said with that same delusional conviction he always carried. “I know she does. She’s only mad at me because of the lake. She’ll come around. She’s loved me for half her life. You think you can compete with that?”
I laughed harder, the sound scraping out of my throat. My free hand came up to grip his jaw, forcing him to look at me. “Love? Ivy loves you? How romantic.” I leaned in closer, voice dropping to a dangerous whisper. “Is that what you tell yourself every time you force your lips on hers? Hmm? She loves me so I just have to shove my tongue down her throat for her to realize it.” Another sharp laugh. “Pity.”
“You just wait till this whole… nonsense you both have going on fizzles out after the summer,” he spat, trying to shove me back. “Ivy will come back to her senses.”
“And then what, Anderson?” I asked, smiling like we were discussing the weather. “Will you leave your perfect fiancée for her? Or are you just planning to keep Ivy around so you can sneak into her bedroom when your wife isn’t looking? That’s what the thrill is all about, isn’t it?”
He didn’t answer. He couldn’t.
“What future can you give her?” I continued, relentlessly. “A mistress? Your dirty little secret? A sinner she has to hide in the shadows?” I shook my head. “You’ve never even told her how you feel. You just keep insisting she’s in love with you because your fragile ego can’t handle the truth that you messed up. You can’t stand knowing that she laid her heart out for years, hoping you’d finally see her… only for her to fall into my hands in one day.”
“You pursued her relentlessly,” he hissed. “You left her no choice but to say yes.”
I stared at him like he was the stupidest man alive. “Isn’t that what a real man does? He sees a woman he wants and he goes after her. Relentlessly. Without apology.” My smile turned feral. “I’m a hunter, Anderson. I don’t expect you to understand what that means.”
“You talk about giving her a future like you’re not just going to use her, fuck her, and throw her away the second she stops being convenient,” he shot back. “Just like every other girl before her.”
I held his gaze, letting the silence stretch until the weight of my next words landed like a hammer.
“I’m going to marry her.”
The color drained from his face so fast I thought he might actually pass out. His mouth opened, closed, opened again. “What?”
I nodded slowly, enjoying every second of his reaction. “Yeah. We’re going to get married. I already marked her as mine. She can never belong to anyone else.”
“You’re bluffing.”
I cocked my head, my smile never wavering. “Am I? She’s never going back to you, Anderson. Ever.” I reached up and slapped his cheek lightly, mockingly affectionate. “But before the wedding… She's going to have my baby. Call it insurance, if you want. Something that ties her to me forever.”
His eyes went wide with genuine horror. He tried to lunge forward, hands pushing at my chest. “You’re fucking crazy. I’m going to warn her—she needs to stay the hell away from you—”
I slammed him back against the wall, hard enough to knock the wind out of him, then drove my fist into his gut in one clean, discreet punch. Not enough to send him to the hospital again. Just enough to remind him who he was dealing with.
He wheezed, doubling over. I kept him upright by the collar, my face inches from his.
“She’s barely twenty-one, you lunatic!” he gasped. “She’s not thinking about marriage or babies now!”
“And who the fuck are you to decide that for her?” I laughed, low and dangerous. “If you so much as hold her hand again… if you kiss her… if you even think about making her cry…” I tightened my grip until he was forced to meet my eyes. “I’ll send you back to your doctor in pieces. Do you understand me?”
“I’m not afraid of you,” he wheezed, but the fear in his eyes said otherwise.
I smirked. “You should be. You really don’t want to see what I look like when I’m actually mad.” I let the threat hang for a second. “Piss me off enough and I might just fuck Madison on your wedding day to prove a point. The last thing you want to do is test me, Anderson. I have zero morals when it comes to protecting what’s mine.”
“Guys? What’s going on up here?”
We both turned at the same time.
Madison stood at the top of the stairs, maybe ten feet away, her expression a mix of confusion and growing suspicion as she took in the scene—me still gripping Anderson’s collar, him looking pale and winded.
I met Anderson’s eyes one last time, arching a brow with a clear warning: Don’t push me.
Then I released him, smoothing down his shirt with deliberate care like we’d just been having a friendly chat. “Nothing. We were just talking.”
Anderson pushed me away roughly and immediately pulled Madison close to his side, one arm wrapping around her waist like a shield. She leaned into him, still watching me warily.
I smiled at the picture they made. “I’ll take my leave now.”
Madison’s gaze flicked toward the front door. “I saw Ivy walk out. Is she leaving with you? Why?”
I kept the smile easy, casual. “Yeah. My dad’s out of the country for a while. The house is too big and quiet, so she’s coming to keep me company. Besides, she needs a break from everything.”
She nodded, her expression softening into something almost friendly. “If you want, we can drop by sometimes. So you both don’t get too bored.”
The offer hung in the air like a trap. I could see the calculation behind her eyes—Madison was smart. Too smart. She was already wondering why Ivy was running out with a bag and why Anderson looked like he’d seen a ghost.
I gave her a polite nod. “We’ll see. Enjoy the rest of the party.”
I turned without waiting for a response, grabbed Ivy’s duffel from the floor, and headed down the stairs. Every step felt lighter. Anderson’s face when I told him about the marriage and the baby… that was going to live rent-free in my head for a long time.
At the bottom, I glanced back once. Madison was still watching me. Anderson had his arm around her, but his eyes were locked on mine with pure hatred.
I winked at him.
I had Ivy beside me. Safe. Mine.
And soon—very soon—Anderson Douglas was going to learn exactly what it meant to come between a hunter and his prize.