Chapter 35: She’s Like Barbie

Chapter 35: She's Like Barbie

Ivy

“What are you saying? Andy is in love with Maddie. Not me.”

The words tumbled out of my mouth, but my heart was hammering so hard I could feel it in my throat. The denial felt necessary, like a defense I had to hold up even as cracks formed in it.

Leo lounged on my bed, propped up on one elbow, watching me with that knowing gaze. “That’s what he thinks,” he said calmly. “I’m still trying to figure out why.”

“He sees me as a sister. Nothing else.” I insisted, almost trying to convince myself more than him. My fingers fidgeted with the hairbrush at my vanity. “Maddie is the girl of his dreams. She always has been.”

“True,” Leo conceded, but his tone suggested he didn’t fully believe it. “I knew you wouldn’t believe me right away. But I still had to put it out there. He’s becoming more aggressive, more forceful, because he’s finally realizing what he’s losing. Doesn’t matter now though. It’s too late for him.”

I met his eyes through the mirror, searching for any hint of jealousy or manipulation. Instead, I found only confidence. The kind that made my stomach warm.

“After me, there’ll be nobody else for you, Ivy.” He stated it so matter-of-factly, catching my gaze in the reflection. “You’ll never be happy with anybody else.”

I tried to laugh it off, the sound coming out shaky and forced. “That oddly sounds like you’re cursing me.”

“It’s both a blessing and a curse,” he replied, his voice dropping lower as he rested his head more comfortably on his elbow. “After you’ve let me inside you, no other man will ever be able to match up. You’ll crave this. Crave us.”

“You sound way too confident,” I said carefully, my entire body heating up at the implication.

He just smiled. “You should leave your hair down. You look like a goddess.”

I put the clip down, grinning like an idiot despite the whirlwind in my chest. “Thanks.”

“So what should I do about Anderson?” he asked casually, as if discussing the weather. “Should I break his hands? His legs? His nose? Or would you prefer I grabbed Madison and kissed her too? All’s fair in love and war, right?”

My eyes widened, and I spun around immediately. “No. Don’t hurt him.” The words came out sharper than I intended. “He apologized. That’s in the past now.”

“Is it?” Leo raised an eyebrow, unconvinced.

My nails scratched nervously against the back of the vanity chair. “And I don’t want you kissing Maddie either. Just… let it go.”

“Why? Afraid I’ll fall for her once I do?” There was a teasing lilt in his voice, but his eyes were serious.

“Every guy falls in love with Maddie,” I admitted, the words tasting bitter on my tongue. Jealousy coiled in my gut like a living thing. “She’s like… the ideal girl that boys want. Beautiful, confident, put-together. She's like Barbie. And I'm Annabelle.”

Without warning, Leo burst out laughing. “That's crazy.” He said in between. “You're my Merida, Ivy. Definitely not Annabelle.”

I smiled. “I'd need more courage. Those are really big shoes to fill.”

“Teenage boys?” Leo asked, his lips trembling with amusement. “They're the ones who made you think you weren't perfect, right?”

I shook my head, standing up and crossing the room to pick up my sundress from the bed. “Never mind. I’m taking too long, aren’t I?” I huffed, reaching for the knot on my robe.

That’s when I noticed Leo was still watching me intently.

“You’re not gonna turn around?” I asked, a mix of curiosity and nervous excitement. “Or close your eyes?”

If possible, he relaxed even further into the mattress. “Turn around for what?”

“I’m about to change,” I stated, holding the dress against my chest like a shield.

My heart raced. I had never undressed in front of anyone like this before Leo. Except Poppy.

He laughed before getting up from the bed with fluid grace. I stood frozen as he walked over to me. When he reached me, he cupped my face and kissed me slowly, his tongue tracing my lower lip until I parted for him.

The kiss was sensual, unhurried, melting away some of my shyness.

Then I felt the robe sliding off my shoulders. I hadn’t even noticed when he’d undone the knot.

It pooled at my feet, leaving me standing there in just my black bikini—the one I’d chosen for whatever secret adventure he had planned. The urge to cover myself didn’t come this time. Instead, a strange boldness took over.

I met his eyes steadily, chin lifted.

Leo took a moment to drink me in, his gaze tracing every inch of me with reverence. “God, Ivy.”

He took the sundress from my hands and gently spun me around to face the full-length mirror. In the reflection, Leo looked like my dark knight—tall, intense, all sharp edges and power—standing behind me with one hand on my arm. The contrast between his dark presence and my softer form sent a thrill through me.

“Hands up.”

I obeyed without thinking. He slipped the dress over my head, helping me into it with tenderness. His fingers lingered on my back, tracing my spine before drifting lower. He slid one hand beneath the hem of the dress, cupping a handful of my ass and squeezing firmly.

“You're the sexiest woman I’ve ever seen,” he murmured against my ear, voice husky.

“No one’s ever said that to me,” I whispered, cheeks flushing.

“They’re all fucking blind.” His hand stayed there, possessive. “I’ve been with a lot of girls, Ivy. They all pale in comparison to you. The way you respond to me… it’s addictive.”

“I haven’t been with anyone,” I admitted in a barely audible whisper. “You’re my first. Aside from when Andy pulled me out of the water that one time… you’re my first real kiss too.”

Leo’s breath hitched. He pressed closer, his hardness evident against my lower back. “You were saving yourself for him, weren’t you?” he whispered in my ear, voice tinged with dark amusement.

I nodded, too embarrassed to say it out loud.

“There’s a dark side of me that wants him to watch while I take it,” Leo confessed, his hand sliding around to the flat planes of my stomach, resting just below my navel. “While I claim what should’ve been his.”

I shook my head firmly, even as my mind conjured forbidden images without permission—Andy’s shocked face, Leo’s powerful body moving over mine. “No. I don’t want that.”

He chuckled, the sound vibrating through me. “We’ll see.”

I turned in his arms, searching his face. “Are you using me to get to him? Is this all a game? Or a bet between you two?”

He folded his arms, watching me with amusement dancing in his eyes. “What do you think?”

I searched his expression, my heart twisting. “It feels like you’re using me to piss him off,” I admitted quietly. “Are you?”

“How does that make you feel?” he asked instead, sidestepping the question effortlessly.

“I don’t know,” I said honestly, stepping closer. “But I feel important. For the first time in my life, I feel wanted. And maybe that’s why it’s overshadowing the fact that this might be wrong. That I shouldn’t be caught in the middle of your step-sibling rivalry.”

Leo’s expression softened. He reached out and tucked a strand of hair behind my ear. “I like you, Ivy. A lot. More than I expected to. This stopped being about Anderson the moment I kissed you.”

I looked at him warily, desperately wanting to believe him. His words wrapped around my insecurities like a warm blanket, but the doubts lingered at the edges.

He extended his hand. “You ready? Let’s go make some memories.”

By the time we made it back downstairs, Marcel and Julia were nowhere to be found. Only Maddie and Andy remained in the kitchen.

My sister was perched atop the marble island like a queen, feeding Andy grapes one at a time. They looked lost in their own world, whispering and laughing softly, her fingers brushing his lips with every offering.

The domestic intimacy stung more than I cared to admit.

But the moment Andy looked up and saw us—me in my sundress, Leo’s hand possessively at the small of my back—the smile vanished from his face. Cold, hard rage washed over his features instantly, darkening his golden-boy charm into something darker.

“Leo,” Maddie called out immediately, her voice bright and oblivious. “It’s so good to see you again.”

Leo smiled warmly, ever the charmer. “That pink looks fantastic on you, Madison.”

“Oh my God, thanks!” Maddie beamed, clearly delighted. She was so happy at the compliment that she hadn’t even noticed me—her own sister—standing right there beside him.

“My pleasure. We’ll be leaving now,” Leo said smoothly, guiding me toward the door.

“Where are you guys going?” Maddie asked, finally glancing at me. She laughed lightly. “Ivy is all dressed up. That's cute.”

I frowned, not liking the slightly condescending tone, but it paled in comparison to the way I could feel Andy’s eyes burning into me. His stare was heavy, possessive, filled with everything he wouldn’t say out loud.

“We’re going on a date,” Leo announced proudly, squeezing my waist.

“A date?” Maddie’s eyes lit up with excitement. “Can Andy and I come along?!”

I stood there, caught between the past I thought I wanted and the future that was pulling me forward with irresistible force.

Whatever happened next, one thing was clear: nothing would ever be simple again.