Chapter 15: A Convincing Liar

Chapter 15: A Convincing Liar

Ivy

I would later realize—much later, when the moment had already passed and there was nothing left to fix—that the exact point where everything tilted slightly off balance, where something invisible but important shifted between truth and lie, was the second Leo opened his mouth and called me his girlfriend. Right in front of his father.

That was the moment I should have stepped in. That was the moment I should have laughed it off, corrected him, drawn a clean line between whatever this was and whatever he was trying to make it look like.

I should have said something simple, something firm, something that would have dissolved the lie before it had the chance to settle into something real.

But I didn’t. I stood there. Completely still.

Like my feet had been glued to the polished floor beneath me and my voice had been stripped away without warning, leaving me with nothing but the rapid, uneven rhythm of my heartbeat and the sharp awareness of his hand still wrapped around mine like it belonged there.

I could feel the weight of it, the warmth of his skin against mine, the quiet, almost possessive firmness of his grip, and for some reason I couldn’t explain—even to myself—I didn’t pull away. I didn’t correct him. I didn’t do anything except stand there and let him lie.

And that was worse. Because now it wasn’t just his lie. It was mine too.

His father didn’t look impressed.

If anything, the introduction seemed to do the opposite of what Leo intended, because the man’s expression shifted almost immediately into something far more scrutinizing, his eyes narrowing just slightly as they moved over me from head to toe in a slow, assessing sweep that made me painfully aware of every single thing about myself.

My clothes, my posture, the way I was standing just half a step too close to his son like I didn’t know where I was supposed to be.

His mouth turned down at the edges, not dramatically, not rudely, but enough to communicate something unspoken but understood.

Disapproval. Clear as day.

“Since when?” he asked, his tone even, but carrying an undercurrent that made the question feel heavier than it should have. “I haven’t even seen you both together.”

There was something in the way he said it—not just curiosity, but expectation, like he was used to knowing everything about his son’s life and didn’t appreciate being left out of something that, to him, clearly didn’t make sense.

I felt Leo’s grip tighten around my hand.

“It happened rather quickly, Dad,” Leo replied without missing a beat, his voice smooth, controlled, slipping into the lie with an ease that made something in my chest twist. “We’d both been chatting on Snap, and luckily for us, she turned out to be a friend of Marcel’s daughter.”

The words flowed so naturally that for a brief, disorienting moment, I almost believed him.

My mind actually tried to make sense of it, scrambling backward through every conversation I’d ever had, every random message I’d responded to, every username I might have ignored or forgotten, searching for something—anything—that could connect me to Leopold Teague before yesterday.

I went through faces, names, fragments of chats that meant nothing now, trying to find him in the mess of it all.

But there was nothing.

Because he wasn’t there. He had never been there. I had never spoken to him, never seen him, never even known he existed until the airport.

Which meant one thing.

He was just a very convincing liar. And for some reason that unsettled me more than it should have.

His father’s brows drew together slightly. “Snap?” he repeated, the word sounding awkward in his mouth, unfamiliar. “What is that?”

Leo let out a small chuckle, the sound lighter now, almost amused. “It’s short for Snapchat, Dad.”

That didn’t help. If anything, the confusion deepened.

Leo tried again, shifting his weight slightly as he glanced up at him. “The yellow app with the ghost on it?”

Still nothing.

For a brief moment, the atmosphere felt almost normal again—like a strange, slightly awkward introduction between two people from very different worlds—but then something changed.

It wasn’t loud. It wasn’t obvious. It was subtle. A shift in energy. A tightening of something invisible. And the first place I felt it was in his hand.

Leo’s grip changed.

What had been firm but comfortable turned into something else entirely—something rigid, something unyielding, something that pressed too hard, too suddenly.

His fingers tightened around mine with a force that made my breath hitch, the pressure sharp and immediate, like he wasn’t even aware of what he was doing.

Pain shot through my hand. Quick and hot.

I inhaled sharply through my nose, my body tensing instinctively as I tried not to react too visibly, tried not to draw attention to it, but it was difficult—God, it was difficult—because he was actually hurting me. It wasn’t playful nor steady anymore.

It was crushing.

“Do you remember when she was obsessed with flower crowns and the dog face thingy?” Leo said suddenly, his voice cutting through the moment, and something about it made my head lift despite the pain still pulsing through my hand.

There was something off about his tone. It was tight. Controlled. Like he was holding something back.

My attention shifted, the discomfort in my hand fading just slightly into the background as I focused on the exchange unfolding above me.

His father’s reaction was immediate and unexpected.

I had expected recognition, maybe even amusement—something light, something nostalgic—but instead, his expression darkened, the faint lines around his mouth deepening as his gaze dropped slightly, like he was looking at something that wasn’t in front of him anymore.

“Oh,” he said after a moment, his voice quieter now, stripped of its earlier firmness. “Was that it? I thought she’d never get out of that phase.”

There was something in the way he said it. Something heavy. Something sad.

It lingered in the space between us, settling into the air like a memory neither of them wanted to fully touch.

My mind raced immediately, questions forming faster than I could catch them.

Who was she?

Why did it sound like they were talking about someone who wasn’t here?

And why did it feel like whatever—or whoever—they were referring to carried weight that went far beyond a simple memory?

Leo let out a small chuckle, but it didn’t reach his eyes. “I guess she finally did,” he said.

And then his grip tightened again. Much harder this time. Sharp enough to drag the pain back into the forefront, forcing a quiet hiss out of me before I could stop it.

“Leo,” I whispered, my voice strained despite my effort to keep it low. “You’re hurting me.”

Everything stopped.

He froze.

Not just his hand—his entire body went rigid, like the words had snapped him out of something he hadn’t even realized he’d fallen into.

Slowly, almost hesitantly, he turned his head toward me, his eyes dropping to where his fingers were wrapped tightly around my hand, where the skin had already begun to flush red under the pressure.

For a split second, he just stared. And then he let go so fast it was almost violent. Like he had been burned.

I pulled my hand back immediately, clutching it to my chest as the throbbing set in properly now, a dull, persistent ache that made my fingers curl instinctively.

“You nearly broke my hand,” I said, the words coming out sharper than I intended, carried on the tail end of the pain.

He shook his head, his expression shifting into something I hadn’t seen before—something unsettled, something almost… shaken.

“I’m sorry, Ivy,” he said quickly, his voice lower now, stripped of its earlier ease. “I just—”

I don’t know why I looked up. Maybe I wanted to see if someone else had noticed. Maybe I wanted confirmation that what had just happened wasn’t normal.

That it clearly wasn’t okay. Nor normal.

His father was still standing there. Exactly where he had been. Hands resting lightly against the railing, his posture relaxed, his expression… calm.

Too calm.

He had seen it. Of that, I was certain. There was no way he hadn’t.

And yet there was no urgency in his face, no concern, no question, no reaction that matched the situation that had just unfolded right in front of him.

“Ivy, I’m so sorry,” Leo continued, his voice cutting back in, still tense, still carrying that thread of disbelief. “I just lost—”

“Save that anger for the next match, son.”

The interruption came smoothly. Almost casually. And it was almost more surprising than anything else that had happened.

I blinked.

My gaze snapped back to his father, trying to process the words, trying to understand how we had gone from that—to this.

He sounded… proud. Like what he had just witnessed wasn’t something alarming, something worth addressing, but something expected. Acceptable.

Encouraged.

“I’ll call Anton and let him know you’ll be ready for him by noon,” he continued, his tone steady, businesslike now, like the conversation had already moved on without waiting for anyone else to catch up. “Is that okay?”

Leo didn’t argue nor question it.

“Yes,” he said quietly, though there was still something off in his voice, something that hadn’t fully settled back into place. “Tell him I’ll be waiting.”

His father gave a small nod, satisfied, like everything had gone exactly as it should.

And just like that, it was over.