Chapter 13: Stepsibling Rivalry

Chapter 13: Stepsibling Rivalry

Leo

I could feel her eyes on me long before she said anything, long before she shifted in her seat or let out that small, restless breath that told me she was thinking too much, connecting dots that weren’t meant to be connected yet, asking questions she wasn’t sure I would answer even if she gathered the courage to ask them out loud.

It wasn’t uncomfortable—not exactly—but it was… persistent, like the weight of it sat against the side of my face, brushing against my focus, nudging at something deeper that I usually kept locked away.

I kept my gaze on the road anyway, one hand resting loosely on the wheel, the other drumming lightly against my thigh in a rhythm that had nothing to do with the music playing faintly through the speakers and everything to do with the awareness of her beside me.

She lasted longer than I expected.

Most people didn’t.

Most people filled silence too quickly, rushed to speak just to prove they weren’t affected by it, but Ivana… she held onto it, sat in it, turned it over in her mind like it meant something, like it deserved to be understood before she broke it apart with words.

I could practically hear her thinking, hear the questions forming one after the other, stacking, waiting their turn, and I knew—without even looking at her—that she was trying to decide which one to ask first.

“Where are we going?” she finally said, her voice cutting cleanly through the quiet.

There it was.

I almost smiled.

I shrugged slightly, keeping my eyes forward, letting the answer come out as easily as the question had. “I don’t know,” I said, glancing at her briefly before returning my attention to the road. “We’ll both figure it out together.”

The reaction was immediate.

She turned toward me fully, her expression shifting so fast it was almost impressive, like I had just confessed to something far worse than poor planning, like I had just admitted to dragging her into something dangerous and irreversible instead of… this.

And then, without warning, she reached across the small space between us and slapped my arm in a rather intimate manner.

It barely registered as pain—more like a soft tap, a brush of contact—but I still made a show of it, letting out a small “Ow,” if only to acknowledge the intention behind it.

“You pulled me out of my sleep,” she said, her voice laced with disbelief, her brows drawn together as she stared at me, “only to drive me around Weeping Willow aimlessly?”

I let out a quiet laugh, shaking my head slightly as I adjusted my grip on the wheel. “We’re going to have a lot of fun, my lady,” I said, glancing at her again, slower this time, letting my gaze linger just enough to catch the way her hair fell around her face, the faint flush still clinging to her skin from being dragged out of bed too early. “Relax. We’re going to get to know each other… and piss off Anderson. Sounds like a perfect date to me.”

That didn’t earn me the reaction I expected.

Instead of rolling her eyes or firing back immediately, she went quiet again, folding her arms across her chest as she shifted slightly in her seat, one knee drawn up just a little as she angled herself toward me, studying me in a way that felt more focused.

It wasn’t just curiosity anymore—it was assessment.

“Yes?” I said after a moment, letting a small smile tug at my lips. “You want to say something, don’t you?”

She didn’t hesitate this time.

“Why do you hate Andy so much?”

I let out a short laugh, more out of instinct than amusement, shaking my head as I leaned back slightly into the seat. “I don’t hate him,” I said. “I just have a really low tolerance for his ferret face.”

She reacted exactly how I expected—and somehow, still more intensely than I deserved.

Her head snapped back slightly, her eyes widening in mild offense as she looked at me like I had just committed a crime. “Ferret face? No,” she said, almost appalled. “Andy is very handsome. You’re just jealous.”

That made me chuckle, as I tilted my head just a fraction. “Really? Jealous?” I said, tapping a finger lightly against my cheek. “When I’ve got this?” I added, gesturing lazily to my face before flicking my gaze back to her. “Do you think he’s more handsome than I am?”

That threw her off.

I saw it immediately—the way her confidence faltered just a little, the way her lips parted before closing again as she searched for a response that wouldn’t trap her in something she wasn’t ready to admit.

“I… I never said that,” she replied, her voice softer now, more careful. “All I’m saying is that you can both be handsome without tearing each other down.”

I hummed lightly, but she wasn’t done.

“You seem to hate him,” she continued, her gaze steady on me now, searching, pushing. “And I can’t wrap my head around why anyone would hate Andy like that.”

That made something shift in me.

I let out a quiet snort, my grip on the steering wheel tightening just slightly before relaxing again. “You don’t think he’s hateful?”

“That’s not what I meant—”

“That’s exactly what you meant,” I cut in, my voice sharper now, not loud, not aggressive, but edged with something that hadn’t been there before. “You don’t hate him for playing with your heart? You don’t hate him for constantly putting you down? For choosing your sister over you like it’s second nature?” I glanced at her briefly, my gaze harder now, more direct. “You don’t think—”

“Okay, okay, okay.”

She cut me off quickly, her hands lifting slightly in surrender as she leaned back into her seat, her voice rushing out like she was trying to stop something before it spiraled further than she could control.

“You’ve proven your point, Leo,” she said, exhaling softly. “I get it. Andy is a jerk. But that’s not enough reason for you to hate him so much that you started a fight last night just to punch him.” Her voice dropped slightly at the end, softer now, almost… disappointed. “That’s unfair.”

I didn’t respond immediately.

I just looked at her for a second longer than necessary before turning my gaze back to the road, letting the silence stretch between us again, heavier this time, less curious, more loaded.

“You’re down bad for this guy,” I said finally, my tone quieter now, almost thoughtful in a way that didn’t match the words. “I really should have done more damage on that face of his.”

She turned to me sharply, her glare immediate and unfiltered. “That’s not funny.”

“I wasn’t laughing, Ivana,” I replied, my voice steady, carrying a weight that made the air between us shift again. “Most times, the version of someone that you know isn’t the only version there is.”

That was the closest I could get.

The closest I was willing to get.

I felt her eyes on me again, stronger this time, like she was trying to peel something back, trying to see past what I was showing her into something I had no intention of letting her see.

“What happened between you two?” she asked, her voice quieter now, but more intentional, more determined. “I know something happened. Because if not, why does it feel like you’re both constantly in a competition with each other?”

The question lingered.

I exhaled slowly, my jaw tightening just slightly as I stared ahead, watching the road stretch out in front of us like an escape I wasn’t taking.

“Why don’t you ask your Andy?” I said, the words slipping out sharper than I intended.

“Well, he’s not here, is he?” she shot back immediately, her tone snapping with just enough bite to match mine. “Besides, I doubt he’d tell me. Much like you aren’t telling me anything now.”

That made something flicker in my chest.

Annoyance.

Or maybe something else.

“Then don’t ask,” I said, my voice quieter now, but firmer, more controlled, like I was pulling a line tight between us. “Most things are better left the way they are. In the past.” I paused briefly, my fingers tightening slightly against the steering wheel before relaxing again. “If you go snooping, you might not like what you find.”

The moment the words left my mouth, I felt it.

The way the air changed.

I hadn’t meant to scare her. I hadn’t meant to let that much slip through. But it was too late to take it back.

She went quiet almost instantly.

Not the same kind of quiet as before—not curious, not thoughtful—but something softer, more cautious, like she was suddenly aware that she had stepped closer to something she didn’t fully understand.

We drove like that for a while, the silence stretching out again, but this time it wasn’t empty.

It was filled with everything we hadn’t said. With everything I wasn’t going to say.

And then, after what felt like too long, she spoke again.

“How can I not ask,” she said quietly, her voice threading carefully through the space between us, “when it feels like I’m caught in some sort of stepsibling rivalry?”

That made me laugh.

Not because it was funny. But because it was wrong. So painfully, dangerously wrong.

If only she knew. If only she understood that this wasn’t some petty rivalry, some childish competition over pride or attention or bruised egos.

This was something else entirely.

Something that had nothing to do with her—and yet, somehow, was beginning to revolve around her in ways she couldn’t see.

My gaze lingered on her for a second too long before I looked back at the road, my jaw tightening as a thought settled heavily in the back of my mind.

She thought she was stuck between two brothers fighting for dominance.

She had no idea she was standing right in the middle of something that could ruin her.

And the worst part? I wasn’t sure anymore if I was trying to keep her out of it…

Or pull her deeper in.