Chapter 11: Love Is Strange
Chapter 11: Love Is Strange
Ivy
“You’re not serious, are you?”
Poppy didn’t even try to hide the disbelief in her voice. She looked at me like I had just casually announced that I’d rearranged the sky and decided to keep the sun for myself.
I opened my mouth to answer, but nothing sensible came out. Because the truth was—I didn’t know how to explain what I had just done.
I stood there in the middle of her room, feeling strangely detached from my own decision, like I had watched someone else make it and was only now being forced to deal with the consequences.
Agreeing to Leo’s proposal had felt impulsive, heated, almost justified in the moment—but saying it out loud now, trying to make it make sense, stripped it down to what it really was.
Reckless. Embarrassing. A little bit insane.
“I just…” I started, then stopped, pressing my lips together as frustration bubbled up inside me. “It’s not like that.”
Poppy slowly sat up on the bed, adjusting the shiny pink cushion propped behind her back, her eyes never leaving my face. The look she gave me was part curiosity, part concern, and entirely too perceptive for my liking.
“What do you mean you agreed to be his?” she asked, her tone slower now. “What does that even mean, Ivy? What exactly did you agree to?”
Her words landed heavier because I didn’t have a clear answer.
I started pacing, the soft carpet muffling my steps as my thoughts spiraled in circles that led nowhere useful. “I don’t know,” I admitted finally, the words slipping out before I could dress them up into something more reassuring. “I really don’t know.”
Poppy’s eyebrows shot up.
“So it’s up to him?” she asked, incredulous. “He gets to decide what ‘being his’ means?”
The way she said it made something twist uncomfortably in my stomach.
I brought my hand up to my mouth, biting lightly on my thumbnail as anxiety crept in around the edges of my confidence. “Don’t say it like that, Pops,” I muttered. “You’re making it sound… worse than it is.”
“Worse than it is?” she repeated. “Ivy, you just told me you agreed to belong to someone for a month without even knowing what that involves. How is that not bad?”
I exhaled shakily, dragging a hand through my hair. “It’s not like he’s some random stranger,” I said quickly. “He’s your brother. It’s not going to be anything crazy. I just need to—”
“Stepbrother,” she cut in immediately. “Not blood-related,” she continued, her gaze sharpening slightly. “And I can’t exactly vouch for him, Ivy. Not fully. We’re not that close. You’ve seen that yourself.”
I hesitated. Because she wasn’t wrong.
Everything I knew about Leo was surface-level at best—his confidence, his sharp tongue, the way he looked at me like I was something he’d already decided to claim. Beneath that… there was a lot I didn’t understand.
“I know,” I said softly. “I know all of that.”
My shoulders sagged as I dropped onto the bed beside her, the weight of my decision settling more heavily now that I was forced to examine it.
“But I couldn’t say no,” I admitted. The confession came out quieter than I intended.
Poppy snorted softly. “That,” she said dryly, “sounds like the beginning of a very toxic love story.”
I shot her a look, though there wasn’t much heat behind it. “That’s not funny.”
“It’s a little funny,” she insisted, her lips twitching. “In a concerning way.”
I sighed, falling back slightly against the mattress before pushing myself upright again, restless energy refusing to let me stay still.
“It’s not just about Leo,” I said, my voice tightening as the real reason surfaced again. “Andy—”
The name alone made something ache in my chest.
“He hurt me tonight,” I continued, the words tumbling out faster now. “I know that sounds stupid because he didn’t actually do anything wrong, but it still hurt. One minute he’s acting like he cares about me, like there’s something there, like he sees me—and the next minute he’s down on one knee asking Maddie to marry him.”
Poppy didn’t interrupt. She just listened. And somehow, that made it easier to keep going.
“It’s like I imagined everything,” I said bitterly. “Or worse, like he let me imagine it. Like he gave me just enough to hold on to, and then—” I snapped my fingers softly. “Gone. Just like that.”
A quiet laugh escaped her, not mocking—just knowing.
“That’s boys for you,” she said lightly. “They’re chaotic. They say one thing, do another, and then act surprised when people get confused. You really shouldn’t take it so seriously.”
“I don’t even know what he sees in Maddie,” I muttered, the jealousy slipping out before I could stop it.
That earned me a proper laugh.
Poppy shifted closer and wrapped her arms around me from behind, her chin resting lightly on top of my head as she held me in place.
“I’m the one he saw first,” I continued, unable to stop the small, childish rant building in my chest. “I’m the one he talked to first. I’m the nicer one—”
“The nicer one?” she supplied, her voice laced with amusement.
I rolled my eyes, catching her reflection in the mirror across the room. “Okay, maybe not always nice,” I admitted. “But I try.”
She snorted again.
“But you know what I mean,” I insisted. “I’ve always been there. I’ve always—”
My voice softened slightly as memories crept in.
“He made me soup once,” I said quietly. “After I fell into the pool.”
Poppy’s arms tightened around me just slightly.
“He was grounded at the time because of a fight at practice,” I went on. “And he still snuck into my room just to bring it to me. He didn’t have to do that. No one asked him to.”
“I remember,” she said gently.
“And the flower crown,” I added quickly, almost desperately. “From the red roses? He said the color suited me. You took pictures of it, remember?”
“I do,” she nodded.
“And when Dennis called me a ‘carrot’ because of my hair…” I hesitated, then pushed through, “Andy punched him. Hard enough to knock out a tooth.”
Poppy went quiet for a moment.
“I think he does care about you,” she said finally. “More than he probably understands himself.”
I let out a long breath, my body sinking back against her. “This is exhausting,” I admitted. “It’s messy and immature and… I thought I had my life more together than this.”
She laughed softly, the sound warm.
“No one has their life together, Ivy,” she said. “Not completely. Not even my dad, and he pretends he does for a living.”
That pulled a small, reluctant smile from me.
“And it’s not embarrassing,” she continued. “It’s human. You feel things. You react to them. That doesn’t make you weak—it makes you real.”
I tilted my head back slightly to look at her. “You really think so?”
She nodded without hesitation. “I know so.”
There was a quiet certainty in her voice that settled something restless inside me.
“And if I were you,” she added, gently gathering my hair and pulling it back, “I’d stop focusing so much on Andy and Maddie.”
Her fingers moved skillfully, beginning to braid my hair into a neat French plait, leaving my bangs loose around my face.
“I’d take this situation for what it is,” she said. “An opportunity.”
“An opportunity?” I echoed faintly.
“To live a little,” she clarified. “To feel something different. To step outside whatever this… triangle is and just exist in the moment.”
Her hands worked steadily, comforting me with each gentle tug.
“Spend time with Leo,” she continued. “Not as a weapon. Not as a plan. Just… as an experience. Make memories, Ivy. Good ones.”
I stared at my reflection in the mirror, watching as she finished the braid, my thoughts quieter now but no less complicated.
“Love is strange,” Poppy said softly behind me. “It doesn’t follow rules. It doesn’t grow where you expect it to.”
She rested her chin lightly against my head again.
“It’s like a seed,” she murmured. “You don’t always know when it’s been planted… or where it’s going to bloom.”
Her words lingered in the air between us.
And for the first time since I said yes to Leo, a different kind of unease settled in my chest.
Not fear. Not regret. Something else entirely.
Because deep down, beneath the jealousy and the impulsiveness and the stubborn need to prove something to Andy…
I had a quiet, unsettling feeling that this one-month arrangement wasn’t going to stay simple.
And that whatever had just been planted tonight… was already beginning to grow.