Chapter 84

Lily’s POV

The headmaster’s office door slams shut behind me, like the sound of a gunshot in the quiet hallway, sealing the weight of my father’s threats inside that suffocating room.

My chest is aching as my heart pounds so hard it feels like it’s shattering my ribs, my eyes swollen from tears that won’t stop falling. Principal Andrews’ words—you’re the cause—echo like a curse, but it’s my dad’s voice that cuts deepest, his venomous hiss still ringing in my ears: “You’re a slut, just like your mother. I’ll beat the sin out of you.” The promise of his fists, his cold, controlling rage, looms like a storm I can’t outrun, and I’m breaking, my body trembling, my breath hitching in shallow, panicked gasps.

I’m not just scared—I’m broken, my world collapsing under the guilt and shame of Crew’s fight, the video sent to my dad, the driver coming to drag me home to a punishment I might not survive.

The hallway stretches out ahead, lit by bright fluorescent lights and filled with soft shadows. Every step feels heavy as I grip my bag tightly, my legs shaky and my eyes blurred with tears. I wish I could vanish, to make this moment go away, to return to the straight-A student I used to be, back before Crew, before Brandon, before everything turned upside down.

I spot him then—Crew, slumped by a locker, his battered knuckles a sharp contrast to his jeans. His dark eyes meet mine, filled with a longing that hits me right in the heart. His face tells a story of guilt and love, his shoulders are tight, and I can feel it—the love I have for him, the support he gave me during June’s struggles, through it all. But that love gets swallowed up by anger, fierce and burning, because he’s the one who let me down, the one who turned away when I needed him, and now I’m the one suffering for it.

“Lily,” he says quietly, his voice trembling with feelings as he moves closer, his hand reaching out to me. “I need you to hear me. I’m really sorry, I never wanted—”

I burst out, my fury releasing like a flood, my voice shaking with rage. “Enough, Crew! Just enough!” I yell, my hands trembling as I take a step back, my tears feeling like fire, my heart shattering into countless pieces.

“I told you to stop bothering Brandon! I pleaded. I said it was dealt with, but you didn't listen! You had to save the day, you had to show off, and now look at me!” My voice breaks, a sob spills out, and I show him the disaster that I’ve become—self-destructing, red-eyed, shaking all over, a girl who appears as if they are on the verge of bursting into tears.

"My father already knows, Crew. Someone sent him the video, and now he is sending a driver to pick me up this weekend. He called me a slut, said he’ll deal with me, and it’s because of you!"

His face falls, pain clouding his eyes as he makes another attempt to reach me. His voice is a whisper. “Lily, I was keeping you safe. Brandon hurt you, scared you—I couldn’t let that slide. I love you. I—”

“Love?” The words choked me as I scoffed, interrupting him as I stepped forward towards him.

“Is this what love looks like? Getting me in trouble? Putting me in my dad’s death book? I’ve never been in trouble, Crew, never! I was fine before you, before you decided I needed your help, your protection!” My words are spitting out fast, each one aimed at his heart, and I hate myself for it, hate the way his eyes flich, but I can’t stop, the pain , the fear is too overwhelming.

“I don’t need you, Crew. I don’t need your fists or your fights or whatever you’re trying to prove!”

He flinches, his hand dropping, his voice barely a whisper.

“Lily, please, I didn’t mean to hurt you. I just—”

“No,” I snap, my voice breaking, tears streaming as I back away, my heart tearing apart. “You don’t get it. You’ve ruined everything. My dad’s going to destroy me, and I can’t… I can’t do this with you.” I take a shuddering breath, my chest aching, and the words spill out, a final, desperate blow. “When our psychology project is over, I’m done. I don’t want anything to do with you. Stay away from me.” My voice cracks on the last word, a sob choking me, and I face to see the devastation in his eyes, the way he staggers, like I’ve struck him.

I turn, my sneakers squeaking on the tiles, and walk away, my body shaking, my tears falling faster. Each step is a knife in my own heart, because I love him—I love Crew with a fire that burns, his fire, his heart, the way he fought for me. But this love is a poison, a chain dragging me toward my father’s wrath, toward a punishment I can’t survive.

The hallway blurs, students passing like ghosts, their whispers of judgment, and I feel their eyes—Linda’s, Lucy’s, the ones who called me a slut, a virgin playing games. My dad’s words—just like your mother—claw at me, and I choke on a sob, my hand pressing against my mouth from making a sound.

I want to run back to Crew, to fall into his arms, to beg him to hold me, to tell him I didn’t mean it, but I can’t. Not when his love has cost me everything, not when my dad’s driver is coming, not when I’m staring down a weekend that might break me.

My chest aches, a raw, bleeding wound, and I hate myself—hate my weakness, my fear, the way I’ve pushed away the one person who makes me feel alive. But I have to survive, have to protect myself from my dad, from the shame, from the love that’s tearing me apart.

The psychology project looms, a fate I can’t escape, but after that, I’ll cut him out, even if it kills me. I walk faster, my tears soaking my face, my heart is shattered.

Crew’s face—his pain, his love—haunts me, but I keep moving, each step a vow to endure, to face my father’s rage, to hold onto myself.

My father has always shoved me away from guys like Crew.

Now I know why my father calls guys like Crew Forbidden fruits.

I have eaten from Crew's forbidden and tempting fruits.

Now, I'm stuck and obsessed with him.

Fucking me.

Claiming me.

“I'm in trouble” I say to myself slowly as I walk away.