Chapter 79
Lily's Pov
Only a few weeks ago, he hated me. Antagonized me every chance he got. Who’s to say it isn’t some
sort of trick on Crew’s part? A way for him to get close to me, only to make me the laughingstock of the entire school?
My stomach roils at that thought. God, I think I’m going to be sick.
I’m frozen, my chest heaving with sobs I can’t contain, my hands trembling as security takes Crew away, his eyes finding mine, blazing with a fierce devotion that both protects and terrifies me.
He fought for me, broke Brandon’s nose for me, and now he’s paying the price, and it’s all my fault.
The crowd’s whispers are sharp and loud, phones flashing, capturing every moment of my humiliation. Then Marcus and Luke shove through, their faces filled with venom, and my stomach turning as they turned on me. “This is your fault, Lily,” Marcus spits, his voice loud, slicing through my grief. “You knew he’d lose it. Why’d you tell him? Now Crew’s fucked because of you.” Luke’s glare is colder, his words like a blade. “You should’ve kept quiet. He’s gone because of you.”
Their accusations crush me, guilt crashing like a wave. I open my mouth to scream that I begged Crew to stop, that I never wanted this, but my voice chokes, drowned by tears. “I didn’t mean this,” I whisper, my voice breaking, but they've already turned away, leaving me in the wreckage.
The crowd parts, and I see Linda and Lucy, their giggles sharp as glass, their phones still recording. “Oh, look at the pure, innocent virgin,” Linda sneers, her voice dripping with malice. “Dating Crew now, huh? Guess you’re not so innocent after all, getting boys to fight over you.”
Lucy laughs, her eyes glittering. “Such a show-off, acting all shy and innocent while Crew breaks noses for her. Pathetic.”
Their words are like poison, seeping into the cracks of my shame, and I can’t breathe, can’t think. I’m not dating Crew—not officially—but their taunts twist the truth, making me feel dirty, exposed.
My dad’s face flashes in my mind, his cold, controlling rage, and I know if he hears about this, he’ll kill me, blame me for tarnishing his perfect image and bringing shame to him.
I turn, my vision blurring with tears, and flee, my sneakers pounding the tiles as I run to my dorm, their laughter chasing me like a pack of wolves.
In my room, I collapse onto the bed, my sobs wrenching, tearing me apart. The shame is like a living thing, clawing at my heart—shame for telling Crew what Brandon did, for Crew’s fight, for the way I’ve become the center of this storm. I love Crew, love his fire, his heart, but this… this is too much.
He’s in trouble because of me, because I told him what Brandon did, because he had assured me to. My fingers clutch my pillow, my tears soaking the fabric, and I hate myself—hate my weakness, my fear, the way I’ve let this gol out of control. Brandon deserved it, but Crew’s the one paying, and the guilt is twisting deeper with my every breath.
I cry until my eyes are swollen, my chest hollow, the weight of the day pressing me into the mattress. I want to disappear, to erase this moment, but I can’t. Crew’s face—his tears, his love—haunts me, and I know I’ve hurt him, even if I didn’t mean to. I fall asleep, exhausted, praying tomorrow will be better, but dread coils in my gut, whispering that it won’t.
The next day, English class is a battlefield of whispers and stares, the air heavy with the fallout of yesterday. I slip into my seat, my head down, my heart pounding as I feel eyes on me—people giggles, the curious glances of classmates who saw the fight.
Crew’s already there, his bruised knuckles stark against his notebook, his gaze searching for mine. I can’t look at him, can’t face the love and pain in his eyes, not when I’m drowning in guilt. He leans toward me, his voice low, desperate. “Lily, talk to me. Please. I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to—”
I shake my head, my throat tight, my eyes fixed on my desk.
“Not now, Crew,” I whisper, my voice trembling, barely holding back tears. I want to tell him I love him, that I’m grateful, but the shame is too heavy, the fear of what’s coming is too real. He fought for me, and now we’re both sinking, and I can’t bear it.
He tries again, his hand brushing mine, but I pull away, my heart breaking at the hurt in his eyes. Mr Fig stares and smirks as he writes on the board and talks about the test, but I barely hear him, my mind racing —Dad’s rage, the school’s judgment, Crew’s sacrifice.
Then the door opens, and a TA steps in, her voice cutting through the haze. “Lily Carter? Principal Andrews needs you in his office. Now.”
My blood runs cold, my breath catching as the class turns to stare, Figs smirks and it feels like daggers. My hands shake as I grab my bag, my legs unsteady as I follow the TA, Crew’s worried gaze burning into my back. The hallway feels endless, each step a march to my doom. Andrews’s office means trouble, and trouble means my father. If he finds out boys are fighting over me, if he hears I’m the reason Crew fought, he’ll destroy me—his words, his fists, his cold, suffocating control. I’m not just scared—I’m terrified, my chest so tight I can barely breathe, my tears threatening to spill again.
The TA leads me to the office door, and I pause, my hand trembling on the knob. I see my dad’s face, his icy rage, hearing his voice: “You’re a disgrace.”
I take a shaky breath, my heart pounding, and step inside, bracing for the consequences of a fight I didn’t start but can’t escape.
The office looms, Andrews’s stern face waiting, and I feel like I’m falling, my life unraveling with every second. I’m not just fighting for myself—I’m fighting for Crew, for the love we haven’t named, for the strength to survive this.
But as the door closes behind me, the fear is overwhelming, and all I can do is hold on, praying I’m strong enough to face what’s coming.