Chapter 44

Lily’s POV

The classroom hums with the low buzz of restless chatter as the bell rings, almost signaling the end of English class as I shove my notebook into my bag, my hands trembling slightly. I can feel Crew’s eyes on me as he sat behind me.

I don’t dare look back—not yet—because I know what I’d see: his beautiful blue eyes which are now softer, something that keeps me up at night replaying the way he kissed me in his car and now we kissed this morning in an empty classroom.

“Lily.” Mr. Fig’s voice cuts through my thoughts, low and deliberate, stopping me cold as I stand. He’s beside my desk, too close, his shadow falling over me. “A word?” He doesn’t wait for an answer, turning sharply toward his desk at the front, expecting me to follow. My stomach twists, a knot of dread and curiosity tightening as I trail after him, my sneakers squeaking silently on the plushed floor.

I didn't glance at Crew—I can’t. I already know he’s watching, jaw clenched, fists probably balled under his desk. It’s a look I’ve memorized, one that makes my chest ache with guilt and longing.

I can’t stop thinking about him, even though I’ve told myself a hundred times it’s a dead-end road. That kiss in his backseat haunts me—his lips firm and desperate, the soft tease of his tongue, the way my body responded like it had been waiting for him forever. It replays every night, a vivid loop I can’t escape: the fashion store where he’d held up a dress and grinned like I was the only girl in the world, the lunch that felt like a date with a boy who might actually care. And today, in that empty classroom, when he’d kissed me again—hard, punishing, then soft—I’d melted into him, wanting more despite myself. But he hasn’t pushed since, hasn’t tried to cross the line I drew when I said we should stay friends. Part of me hates that I said it, hates that I’m disappointed he’s listening.

“Lily?” Fig’s voice snaps me back. He’s already at his desk, perched there like a predator, while I’m stalled out halfway across the room, looking like a fool caught daydreaming. I hurry over, clamping my lips shut to keep the confused words inside from spilling out.

My heart’s racing, not just from Crew but from the way Fig’s eyes linger, too perceptive, too knowing.

“Is everything okay?” I ask, forcing my voice steady as I stop beside his desk, close enough to catch the faint cologne clinging to him—something sharp and expensive.

.

“I was going to ask you the same.” He rests his clenched fists on the desk, leaning in, his voice dropping to a low whisper. “I can tell something’s bothering you.” His gaze is piercing, and it sets my nerves on edge.

He’s dangerous—not in the obvious way Crew is, with his brooding intensity, but in a manipulating, more insidious way. Like he can smell vulnerability, prey on it. I’ve seen the rumors about him, the whispers about girls like June, and I wonder if he thinks I’m next.

“I’m alright. Really,” I say, but it sounds weak even to me.

“Is someone bothering you?” His eyes flick over my shoulder, toward Crew, and I feel the air shift.

I sneak a glance back—Crew’s staring, unblinking, not caring he’s caught. My breath is coming fast. “I can talk to him if you want.”

“No,” I say too quickly, shaking my head. “Crew isn’t bothering me.” I’m not hiding who he means—I don’t need to.

Fig’s brows lift, suspicion etched into his face. “Are you sure? I know he can be intimidating. He’s got a reputation—bullying girls, pushing them around.”

I’m not surprised. Crew’s tried that with me over the years—taunts, smirks, little jabs to get under my skin. I had brushed him off, and it only made him try harder, until it shifted into something else, something real. “He doesn’t bully me,” I say firmly. “Crew’s my friend.”

“Friend?” Fig’s tone drips with disbelief, and it stings, like he thinks I’m some stupid naïve kid who can’t see the truth. “Oh, Lily. Please tell me you don’t actually believe that.”

“What do you mean?” I ask, hurt, sharpening my voice.

I’m not that girl anymore—too trusting, too easy to break. I’ve been there, lived through it, and I’m still clawing my way out.

“If Crew claims to be your friend, it’s just code for something more.” He pauses, letting it hang, and I hate how it sounded—heavy, accusing.

“Code for what?” I play dumb, leaning into the innocent act everyone expects from me. Let him think I’m clueless; it’s safer that way.

“He’ll take advantage of you,” Fig says, his voice low and serious. “That’s how boys like him operate.” The hypocrisy burns—here he is, warning me about Crew, when he’s the one who preys on girls, picking out the weak ones like a vulture.

I’ve seen it with June, the way he’s strung her along, and I wonder if he saw me that way too—breakable, manipulable—before I shut him down.

I meet his gaze, my own hardening. “I know exactly how boys like him operate,” I say, dropping my voice to match his. “Maybe that’s what I want him to do. Have you ever thought of that?” The words slip out, bold and firm, shocking even me. His face fades in his calm mask, and I feel a rush of power.

“Very well,” he says, recovering. “I just wanted to warn you.”

“Thanks, Fig. Appreciate it but I've told you to back off before.” My tone’s sharp, edged with an attitude I didn’t know I had, and I like it.

I spin away from his desk, my skirt flaring out, flashing thigh, and I catch Crew’s eyes drop to my legs. Heat floods my skin as I stride back to my seat, his gaze pulling me in. Why am I holding him at arm’s length again?

I drop into my chair, glancing at him—he’s already watching, intense and unwavering. “What the hell did he want?” he growls, his eyes flicking to Fig.

“He asked if I was okay,” I say, shrugging, but Crew’s not buying it.

“Trying to make a move on you?”

“Never.”

“I’ll kick his ass if he says or do anything inappropriate, Lily. I mean it.” His voice is fierce, protective, my name rolling off his tongue like a vow, and goosebumps erupt over me.

“I blew him off,” I say, and his jaw unclenches slightly.

“He can pick up on girls going through shit,” he mutters.

“I know. I figured that out.”

His eyes soften, the anger fading. “You’ve got this handled, don’t you?”

I nod, a small smile tugging at my lips. “I do. I’m going to be okay. But thank you for watching out for me.”

“Anytime,” he murmurs, and as Fig starts lecturing, I turn forward, a thrill sparking through me. Crew trusts me—sees me as strong, not broken—and it’s a push I didn’t know I needed.