Chapter 197: Olivia Horace’s Arrest
Isabella’s POV
The TV was still frozen on that last frozen frame…the chaotic swarm of reporters and protesters outside the precinct…when the feed suddenly jolted back to life.
A black cargo van had screeched to a stop right in front of the station steps. The side door flew open. Two figures…hooded, moving fast…shoved a bound woman out onto the concrete.
She hit the ground hard on her knees, hands zip-tied behind her back, ankles bound together, duct tape wrapped tight across her mouth. A large white poster board was duct-taped to her chest in big black marker letters:
I AM THE MASTERMIND
The van peeled away before anyone could react.
The crowd exploded.
Reporters surged forward like a tidal wave, cameras flashing, microphones thrusting toward her face. Phones were held high, live-streaming everything. Protesters pushed against the barriers, screaming questions. “Who are you?!” “Why did you target Damien Voss?!” “Talk!”
The woman struggled against the restraints, muffled sounds coming from behind the tape, eyes wide with terror above the gag.
One bold reporter…a woman in a bright red coat…reached her first, ripped the tape off in one brutal yank. The woman screamed as the tape came free, blood flecking her lips.
“Is that—” Ellie’s voice cracked from the couch. “Is that not…Olivia?!”
My head snapped toward the screen. “Olivia?”
“Yes! My brother’s best friend and biggest cheerleader!” Ellie was already on her feet, hand over her mouth. “Olivia freaking Horace!”
I squinted at the screen. The camera zoomed in as security and officers finally pushed through the mob. Someone tore off the black face mask that had been covering the lower half of her face.
It was her.
Olivia Horace…the same sharp cheekbones, same auburn hair now tangled and wild, same terrified hazel eyes I’d seen in this same house. The same girl that joined forces with Alicia to torment me.
The room went dead silent for half a second.
Then chaos.
“Why the hell would she turn against Damien?” Jace muttered.
“Why would Olivia side with Carlos Osmond? She knows our family history with them. Why would she do this?” Ellie echoed, horrified. “She’s been family to us for years.”
On screen, Olivia was screaming now, voice raw and cracking.
“I’m innocent! I’m being framed! I would never betray Damien…never! Please, listen to me!”
Officers swarmed her, grabbing her arms, trying to lift her to her feet. Reporters kept shouting over each other: “Did you kill the woman in the river?” “What’s your connection to Carlos Osmond?” “Why turn yourself in now?”
She kept yelling over them, tears streaming. “I didn’t do anything! This is a setup! Carlos…he’s the one! He planned everything!”
The officers finally managed to hustle her up the steps and through the precinct doors. The heavy glass doors slammed shut. Cameras were blocked. The feed cut to the reporter outside, breathless.
“We’ve just witnessed a dramatic self-surrender…or forced delivery…of a woman who claims to be the mastermind behind the framing of Damien Voss. Her identity is still unconfirmed by authorities, but social media is already identifying her as Olivia Horace, a close associate of the Voss family…”
I turned to Ellie, pulse hammering. “Call Jaxon. Right now. We need to know what’s going on.”
“Already on it.” Ellie’s thumb was flying across the screen. It rang…and rang…and went to voicemail.
“Damn it,” she hissed.
I looked around the room. “Why are we sitting here? Let’s just go to the station ourselves.”
Agnes shook her head fast. “And do what, Bella? Add to the mob outside? There are like five hundred people out there already. Plus, Carlos…or whoever’s still pulling strings is out there somewhere. What if this is bait? What if they try something while we’re all exposed? Better we stay put. Safe.”
Jace nodded grimly. “She’s right. We’re useless in that crowd. We wait for Jaxon or Gerald to feed us real info.”
Ellie sank back onto the couch, eyes glued to the muted TV where the same clip of Olivia being dragged inside was playing on repeat.
“But… Olivia? She was the one who sat with Damien in the hospital each time my worthless ex beat me to a pulp. She helped him through the worst breakup of his life. Why would she do this?”
We spent the next twenty-five minutes in agony…pacing, refreshing Twitter, refreshing news apps, throwing out every wild theory possible.
“Maybe she’s been blackmailed.”
“Maybe she’s in love with Osmond.”
“Maybe she’s been playing us all for years.”
“Maybe this is a double-bluff to flush out the real killer.”
Every theory sounded dumber than the last.
Then Ellie’s phone rang…Jaxon.
We all crowded around like it was the last lifeboat.
She hit the speaker again.
“Jaxon?” Ellie’s voice shook.
“Massive progress,” he said, sounding breathless, like he’d been running. “They ran Olivia’s prints. They’re identical to the partial found on the body in the river. The previous report lied because Osmond paid them off. And get this…the murder weapon? An anonymous package was mailed to the precinct this morning. Knife. Olivia’s prints were all over the handle.”
The room sucked in a collective breath.
“What?” I whispered.
“Why?” Agnes demanded.
“How?” Jace added.
Jaxon kept going. “She’s screaming she’s innocent. Says she didn’t kill anyone, doesn’t know whose body that is, insists the person she thought she killed is alive because that person called her hours ago…right before the van dropped her off.”
In the background we could hear Olivia’s voice echoing down the hallway…shrill, desperate, unhinged.
“I’m innocent! I didn’t do it! I didn’t kill anyone! She’s alive…I spoke to her! She called me! I’m not going down alone! Carlos Osmond…he’s the mastermind! He’s pinning it on me! Arrest him! He’s leaving the country today…private jet out of the executive terminal! He did everything…not me! I only played along to protect Damien! Please!”
The words kept coming, frantic, overlapping with officers shouting for her to calm down, doors slamming.
Agnes snorted. “That bitch is crazy. Betrayed her own best friend? What is she…Carlos Osmond’s sugar baby or something?”
Jaxon’s voice dropped suddenly. “Oh no… Jesus Christ.”
We all froze.
“What’s wrong?” Ellie asked.
There was a long exhale on the line. “There’s something the police hid from us during the first investigation. They just revealed it now…because of the prints match.”
“Spit it out,” I snapped.
“The body…the body is missing half her tongue.”
Silence.
I blinked. “What does that mean?”
Another pause. “The body…is Damien’s psycho ex-girlfriend. Cleo.”
Ellie and I looked at each other at the exact same second.
“That Cleo?” we said together.
“Yes,” Jaxon confirmed.
My stomach plummeted. “Oh my God. What if they find a way to pin this on Damien because of their history—”
“They’re not,” Jaxon cut in. “Olivia just confessed…on record…to killing Cleo. But she keeps screaming that Cleo’s alive, that she’s been framed, that she spoke to her hours ago. I told the officers what I know and the detectives are losing it. They keep asking Olivia how she could speak to someone who’s probably mute because she’s missing her tongue. Olivia’s babbling about some AI voice app. It’s total chaos in here.”
We were all stunned into silence.
Agnes finally spoke. “What the actual hell is going on?”
Ellie whispered, “What happens now?”
Jaxon’s voice came through steady despite the madness in the background. “It’s a settled case on paper. Olivia’s fingerprints tie her to the body and the weapon. They’re calling her Osmond’s accomplice…they planned the frame job together to bury Damien. But we still don’t have a clear motive for why Olivia turned against the boss. I’ve already submitted everything I gathered from when Cleo was in that monastery…reports, visitor logs. Turns out Olivia knew about Cleo’s escape. She was the one who housed her afterward. They were in close contact for months.”
Olivia’s screams echoed again in the background, fainter now.
“They should arrest Carlos Osmond! He’s probably at the airport right now! Private charter! He’s the one who did it! Not me! I was trying to save Damien! I would never hurt my friend!”
No one seemed to be listening.
Then..sharp and sudden…the mansion’s gate intercom buzzed.
We all whipped our heads toward the hallway in perfect sync.