Chapter 32: Blurred Lines

\[Leo’s POV\]

I stare down at Rue, my body humming with feelings I thought I would never feel again.

I know I shouldn’t be feeling like this, but since the beginning I was certain that I wouldn’t be able to stop it.

I couldn’t deny that I was attracted to the full-grown version of Rue.

With her babydoll looks, her curvy figure, and her confident nature, how could I not?

When we met again I expected to meet that scared teenager who couldn’t even fight back, but when she wasn’t there I felt something in me shift.

For a while, I found myself wondering if that meant that maybe I married Darlene a bit too fast. I mean, how could I possibly be attracted to another woman when I was supposed to be in love?

That was why I denied these feelings.

I ignored them the best I could, but every time I looked at Rue, I just felt my resolve starting to crack.

And then Darlene got sick, and I was all that she had.

I felt guilty.

I felt like the biggest piece of shit.

And I swore that no matter what, I would keep the growing feelings I had for Rue in check.

I intended to do that.

I intended to never let myself indulge in them, but then Darlene died, and Rue was all I had left of her.

Maybe that was why I became so dependent on her and expected her to stay by my side, but I knew deep down it wasn’t right.

I was aware of Rue’s feelings. How could I not when she spilled them all to me and then left? And still, I used her for comfort, but that wasn’t fair to her, especially when I got drunk and accidentally mistook her for Darlene.

I couldn’t blame her for leaving.

I told myself that I was going to let her go, but in the end, I came to her determined to win her back.

Now, here we were, together, both of us naked, both of us baring it all, and all I can feel is a mixture of guilt and excitement over what is about to happen.

Slowly, I begin to push into Rue, hissing in shock by how tight she is.

I noticed it when I was fingering her, but now that my dick was experiencing it, I almost felt like I was doing something I shouldn’t.

“You aren’t a virgin, are you?” I ask and Rue’s gaze narrows.

“Do you really think I’m incapable of being with anyone?”

For a moment, I don’t speak as I take in the expression she is giving me because it is so fucking endearing that I want to see it more.

“Understood,” I murmur, starting to move again until I’m almost completely buried. “You’re just so tight that I…”

“Please,” she hisses, and I realize too late what it sounds like I’m saying. “Don’t compare me to any of the other women you’ve been with.”

At her words, I feel guilt slam into me because I know exactly who it is that she is thinking of, and even though I wasn’t necessarily thinking of that woman, I wasn’t not thinking of her either.

Fuck. This was becoming more awkward than it should be.

There shouldn’t be anyone else here with us while we are doing such things, and yet… Even now with Rue beneath me, her pussy swallowing my dick beautifully, I can’t stop myself from remembering.

Stop it, Leo. I hiss, pushing aside the memories that are threatening to come.

Don’t think of anyone but Rue.

As I tell myself this, I start moving, giving Rue the chance to stretch around me, and when moans start to escape her lips, I know that she isn’t hurting, and when I’m certain of that, I let the need and desire I’m feeling take over.

I start to move, my thrusts hard and deep, and when it doesn’t seem like enough to make me stop thinking of anything but Rue, I hook an arm under her leg and pull her harder against me.

“Ah!” she gasps, her back arching. “Leo, that’s it.”

Fuck, the way she calls my name is beautiful. Much more beautiful than it should be, and despite myself, I want to hear it more.

“Say it again,” I murmur, remembering how in the beginning she wouldn’t address me as anything other than Mr. Owens. “Keep saying my name.”

“Leo,” she repeats, her eyes rolling into the back of her head. “Leo,” she says again. “Leo.”

Again and again she says my name like a beat that gives pace to my thrusts until I feel her squeezing around me, but when a lovely scream escapes her lips, I don’t stop. Instead, I pull out of her and twist her around, then once she presents her ass to me, I push into her again.

“Fuck, that’s it,” I hiss, loving the way her ass shakes as I fuck her mercilessly. “Arch your back more.”

“Yes,” she gasps, clawing at the sheets beneath her. “Just like that.”

She’s enjoying it. That much is clear, and if she is enjoying it and not thinking that I’m doing exactly what I should, but even now, I can’t fully focus on her because the lines between reality and my fantasies blur until there is a mixture of Rue and Darlene beneath me.

Eyes widening, I stop my thrusts, and when Rue turns her gaze to me, I feel so fucking sorry that my dick immediately deflates.

“What is it?” She asks, eyeing me. “What’s wrong?”

“I…” I begin, knowing if I told her what I just did, she would hate me. “I’m sorry.”

“Sorry,” she repeats, hurt clear in her voice. “Are you really saying that to me?”

I was, and I felt like the biggest piece of shit for doing it, but now that I was calmer, I realized that I moved too quickly.

“What was this then?” Rue demands when I don’t speak. “Was this just your way of trying to chase a ghost that will never be here again?”

As she speaks, she sits up and then slides off the bed, and when she starts looking for her clothes, I know that she is about to leave.

“Let me,” I say, moving and grabbing my own clothes. “This is your place after all.”

“Then leave,” she whispers, her gaze snapping to the door. “Get the hell out of here!”

Nodding, I throw on my clothes and then do as instructed, and when I reach the door and grab the knob, I hear a sob rip through Rue, but I don’t turn around.

Right now, I was the reason that she was breaking down, and because of that, I had no right to comfort her.

That’s why I turn that knob and then head out, and only when I reach the street do I let my guilt engulf me.