Chapter 21: Help Me
\[Collin’s POV\]
I look from Jeremiah to Lilah while they exchange a glance, and I can’t help but wonder what exactly the two were up to before now.
Even if they tried to play it off like nothing happened, it was pretty obvious from where I sat.
“Thank you again for looking after Lilah,” I say slowly, deciding to test the waters while wondering why I even cared what was between the two.
“It isn’t that big of a deal,” Jeremiah assures me. “It’s what I should do.”
“Really,” I say, raising a brow. “Because of the two of you being friends?”
What the hell was I doing? Poking and prodding for information in something that didn’t even concern me.
Wasn’t this a good thing?
If there was something more going on between the two of them, then Donna could at least be satisfied, but…
Wasn’t she calling my name while she masturbated just last night?
The thought and image of Lilah sprawled on that bed come unbidden, and with it a thrum in my nether regions.
Stop it. I hiss at myself, hating that I was even getting excited by such a thing, but then again, wasn’t it already too late for that?
I jacked off to the image of Lilah in that bed.
I pictured what she would look like while I fucked her.
I already crossed the line more than I should have, but if she and Jeremiah were an item, then I at least wouldn’t consider such a thing again.
“That’s…”
“Right,” Lilah gasps as Jeremiah attempts to answer. “We’re friends, and since we are friends, he is always looking out for me.”
As she speaks, I don’t miss the slight blush that covers her cheeks and travels down to her neck, where I spot a hickey that she didn’t do the greatest job of hiding.
So, they aren’t just friends. At least, not in the sense that they kept boundaries like friends.
“Right,” Jeremiah agrees, though he doesn’t look pleased about the answer. “I’ve been keeping her out of trouble since we were young.”
“That’s right,” Donna agrees, approaching the table with a large bowl of salad. “These two have been attached at the hip since they were young.”
Nodding, I look from one to the other again while wondering why they were trying so hard to hide the fact that they’re dating.
It wasn’t that big of a deal since the two were adults and could do whatever they wanted. So, why were they trying to keep it a secret?
“That must make dating difficult.”
The words leave my lips before I can stop them, and once again I wonder why the fuck I even care so much about what goes on between them.
Pure curiosity?
A slight annoyance that she was picturing me instead of him while she shoved that damn dildo into herself?
Or was it because she roused me enough to make me do something so embarrassing while my own wife slept soundly?
What the hell is even wrong with me?
This is the only thought that flashes in my head as Donna continues to fill the table with food, and once she finishes, she takes a seat beside me.
“Eat up,” she says, smiling brightly, and I feel a bit of guilt over what I’m feeling. “I’ve made plenty.”
After that, there isn't any more talk about the relationship between Jeremiah and Lilah while everyone eats their fill.
Instead, Donna spends the time grilling Jeremiah about his life, his family, and his possible relationships.
As he responds, I don’t miss the way that Lilah squirms, and I’m almost certain that the two are definitely something.
Once everyone finishes, I stand and stretch, then turn my attention to Jeremiah, who is whispering something in Lilah’s ear.
“Jeremiah,” I announce, deciding that this would be a good time for Donna and Lilah to talk. “Mind joining me for a smoke?”
For a moment, Jeremiah doesn’t respond as he stares at me, his eyes questioning, his expression annoyed.
From the way he acts, I’m almost certain that he doesn’t want to agree to such a thing, but after Lilah whispers something, he just nods.
“Alright,” he announces, standing and reminding me once again just how big he is. “Let’s go.”
Nodding, I give Donna a quick pat on the shoulder before heading around the table and then in the direction that Jeremiah disappeared, and when I step outside, I find him pulling out a pack of cigarettes.
“Want one?” He asks as I just take him in. “I figured that you would have your own since you’re the one who asked me to come out.”
“I do,” I tell him, producing my own. “I was just thinking.”
“About?” he asks. “Hopefully not about me because I don’t swing that way, bro.”
At his words, I let a bark of laughter escape me before growing serious.
“I was hoping that you could help me with something.”
"Help you," Jeremiah repeats, frowning ever so slightly. "And what exactly would you need my help with?"
"I want to try to get closer to Lilah, but I'm not quite sure how to do it," I admit.
In a way, I was once again testing the waters to figure out the relationship between the two, but I was also telling the truth.
Since we were now family, it would be best that we got along for Donna's sake, and I was certain that if anyone could help me achieve that, it would be Jeremiah.
"Why?"
At his question, I flinch ever so slightly because honestly I wasn't expecting him to ask me such a thing, but I guess it was to be expected.
"Since we are going to be seeing a lot of each other, I thought it best that we try to bridge this gap between us."
Growing quiet, I wait while Jeremiah considers what I have said, and when his lips twitch into a deeper frown, I know that he isn't exactly going to go along with what I'm asking.
"What if I said it was for Donna's sake?" I continue, not wanting to give up so easily. "Would you help me then?"
Once again, I wait while Jeremiah just stares at me, really taking me in, and when he lets out a huff, I brace myself for rejection.
"I don't really get it," he admits, taking me by surprise. "Since you're both adults and Lilah doesn't live with you full time, it isn't exactly the end of the world if she doesn't come to like you."
"That may be," I agree. "But even then, I'd like to develop a relationship with her."
Now I was just being selfish and sounding like an old creep, but I couldn't drop it. I didn't want to just let things continue like they were.
"And I know that is what Donna wants as well," I continue. "She has been really stressed because of the distance that she has been feeling from Lilah."
"I know." Jeremiah sighs. "And Lilah has been feeling it too, but there's one thing that you should know about Lilah. She's stubborn, and when she sets her mind to something, it takes a while for her to move on from that thing."
"And what might that thing be?" I ask, my curiosity piquing.
"She is convinced that you and her mother had something going on before her father even passed."