Chapter 19: Should We Date

\[Lilah’s POV\]

I pretend to sleep. Listening silently as Jeremiah speaks.

His words are a bit painful because they are the true feelings that he never lets out, and he wouldn't have said them if he wasn’t convinced I was fast asleep.

Jeremiah. I think silently, hating how much sadness I hear in his voice.

I continue to pretend to be asleep until I feel him get up and head into the bathroom, and when I hear the sound of the shower turning on, I open my eyes and stare in the direction he went.

For a moment, I feel myself wanting to follow and talk to him about what he said, but I know that right now isn’t the time because anything I said he would consider being pity.

What should I do? I wonder, turning over and staring at the roof. Should I continue with this ambiguous relationship?

It wasn’t a secret that I was definitely attracted to him, and the sex was great, but did I see him as boyfriend material?

I wasn’t certain.

I never even considered it because I didn’t want to ruin what we have.

Sighing, I try to picture what things would be like if we were to ever start dating, and then I find myself wondering why I’m even considering it all of a sudden.

Because of what you did earlier. The small voice in the back of my head says causing me to flinch as I remember masturbating to the image of my new stepfather.

Fuck.

That was so messed up, and then to see him afterwards, I couldn’t take it.

That’s why I packed some things and fled as soon as the man in question went to work.

For now I would really think about my feelings and how I would deal with the situation, and once I came to a conclusion, I would go back home.

Until then I would simply convince myself that I felt that way because of the sexual tension I felt from stopping midway with Jeremiah and my lack of a relationship with anyone.

Right.

That was what was happening, and that was also why I was suddenly considering giving Jeremiah a chance.

“Should I?” I whisper, once again wondering what Jeremiah as a boyfriend would be like. “It isn’t like we don’t already act like a couple when we are together.”

The only thing that would change is our status. There wouldn’t be that invisible line or these ambiguous feelings that I don’t have the courage to consider.

Hmmm.

Rolling over, I stare at the bathroom door once more until I hear the tap turn off, and when I’m certain he is getting ready for bed, I turn over and pretend I’m asleep once again.

It is only when Jeremiah emerges and climbs in bed beside me and pulls me against him that my pretending turns into the real thing.

I don’t know how long I sleep before I’m prying my eyes open and finding myself face-to-face with Jeremiah’s sleeping face.

He’s handsome even when he sleeps, maybe a bit more handsome because that mouth of his isn’t running and ruining everything.

“You should stay like this,” I murmur, reaching out and touching the tip of his nose. “It would be easier to make a decision.”

“What kind of decision?” Jeremiah asks, his eyes opening and taking me by surprise.

“You were awake?” I demand, attempting to sit up only to be stopped by the strong arms still wrapped around me. “Let go.”

“Not until you answer my question.” He chuckles, pulling me closer. “What decision were you talking about while touching me without permission?”

“You’re one to talk,” I huff. “Aren’t you doing the same thing?”

“I was asleep,” he counters. “So it doesn’t count.”

“It still counts," I argue. “You touched me without permission, so I simply returned the favor.”

At my words a chuckle escapes Jeremiah, and it makes my whole body vibrate. It’s a nice sound, one that I like very much.

“Don’t change the subject,” he says now, drawing me to the present. “What decision were you considering?”

I remain silent as I consider his question and what it was that I was considering before falling asleep.

Should I? I wonder as I stare at the man in front of me. Would it be so bad?

If it is only to stop yourself from falling too deeply for your stepfather, it is. The small voice in the back of my head says, but I ignore it.

“Jeremiah,” I say now, making a decision. “Should we try dating?”

There. I said it, and now I couldn’t take it back or continue to dwell on it.

“What?” Jeremiah hisses, his eyes widening. “What did you just ask me?”

“You heard me,” I tell him. “I asked if we should try dating.”

“I know that,” he says slowly, and I can see the disbelief and then hesitance in his eyes. “But I’m wondering where exactly that came from.”

You don’t need to know. I think silently. It’s better that we don’t talk about the reasons we have reached this point and we simply discuss whether or not we should further explore the things between us.

“Do I need a reason?” I ask.

“Yes.”

Jeremiah’s response is almost instantaneous, and it makes me feel a bit bad because I know that I’ve been shitty with using him when it fit my need, but I was being sincere in my own way here.

“Would it really be that bad?” I ask, deciding to explain a little. “We’ve already been sleeping together and going out together.”

“All things that friends do,” Jeremiah says.

“Friends don’t fuck,” I counter.

“Friends with benefits do,” he argues. “But are you saying that you like me?”

That’s another good question. I think, taking him in.

I did like him. I was attracted to him. But did he make my heart flutter?

For a moment, I consider this, trying to find one instance where Jeremiah has made my heart flutter, and when I can’t find one, I shake my head.

“I don’t know,” I admit. “But I’m willing to find out.”

If we were actually a couple, we would do more things that couples did, and as we did those things, I would get a better grasp on my feelings.

“Are you saying you don’t want to date me?” I ask, bracing myself for whatever he may say. “If not, then just…”

“No,” he says quickly. “Just… give me a minute to process.”

Nodding, I don't say another word as I wait for Jeremiah to make a decision.

"Alright," he finally says, giving me a serious look. "Let's try dating."