Chapter 15: Confusion

\[Lilah’s POV\]

When we return home, I’m hopping out of the car before it is completely stopped, and even then I don’t dare turn to see Collin. Instead, I head inside and upstairs into my room, where I collapse.

Rolling over, I stare up at the ceiling while memories of the night start to return to me, and when my uneasy feeling starts to become almost unbearable, I slide my hand down into my pants and begin rubbing.

However, when I close my eyes, I don’t allow myself to see Collin. I allow myself to see Jeremiah since I was more than familiar with the way he moved, the way he touched, and the way he worked me.

“Jeremiah,” I whisper, letting my mind wander to our time together while I shove my fingers into me and start moving them. “Oh… Jer…”

Fuck, this felt good, much better than usual.

It most certainly had to be because I got so worked up and then got nothing.

“More,” I whisper, wishing that I had gone to Jeremiah’s to finish what we started. “I want more.”

As I speak, I reach into my bedside table with my free hand and produce the vibrator that I keep stored there.

Opening my eyes, I stare at it and then remove my hand from my pants.

“Let’s get rid of these.” I announce, wriggling out of my clothes and throwing them on the floor. “And now…”

I quickly push the vibrator into me and then turn it on, and when it starts working its magic, I prepare to let my mind wander back to Jeremiah, but in the end it doesn’t. Instead, the man who joins me in my naughty fantasy is the very man that up until today I was trying to avoid.

“Collin,” I whisper, testing his name on my tongue as my vibrator does its thing. “Oh god… Collin.”

\[Collin’s POV\]

The house is empty as I step inside and realize that not only did Lilah rush out of the car to avoid any more alone time with me, but she even rushed to her room for that very reason.

Sighing, I shake my head while wondering how to stop her from being so wary of me.

After our heart-to-heart I thought that we were making some progress, but now that our time alone was over, things were going right back to the way that they were originally.

“Dammit,” I sigh, imagining the disappointment on Donna’s face when she finds out that my attempt at getting closer to Lilah didn’t work as it should. “What can I do to make things better?”

Repeating this thought again and again, I head up the stairs and then prepare to sneak into mine and Donna’s room to shower and change, but before I can reach it, I find that Lilah’s door is cracked and I can hear something vibrating from within.

Stopping, I listen quietly, wondering what exactly it was that I was hearing, and when I hear a whimper leave Lilah’s lips followed by the vibration increasing, I know what is happening.

Shit. What the hell was I doing standing here listening in while Lilah was doing such a thing?

Was I some kind of pervert who was creeping on my own stepdaughter?

No. I needed to continue on my way and leave her be, but before I can even take a step, her voice reaches me.

“Collin.”

My name leaving her lips is quiet, and I’m not completely sure if I heard correctly, but when she speaks again, I know that I have.

“Oh Collin,” she moans, causing a torrent of confusing emotions to rush through me. “Collin,” she repeats, and I know that I should start moving, but it is like my feet are glued to the floor beneath me.

Again and again she repeats my name like she is making passionate love with me, and to my surprise, each time she says my name, I feel my dick throbbing.

Get a grip. I hiss inwardly, knowing that what was happening right now was wrong. Donna is asleep in the next room over and could come out and find us like this any minute.

Move. I command my feet as Lilah’s moans and exclamations grow louder. Move, damn you!

As I speak, I manage to make myself move, one step and then two, and when I am standing directly in front of Lilah’s room, I can’t stop my gaze from drifting inside the room, where she lies on her bed with her legs spread wide enough to allow anyone to see her pussy.

She’s working a vibrator in that pussy, moving it with such vigor while she repeats my name again and again.

“Shit,” I hiss, feeling a bulge form in my pants. “What am I doing watching?”

This is wrong. This is wrong on so many levels, and yet… I can’t take my eyes away as her back arches and a loud groan of ecstasy escapes her as she cums strongly.

It is only when her body starts to relax that I start moving again while hoping that she didn’t possibly see me standing there watching her masturbate, and when I reach my room, I move toward the bathroom immediately.

Turning on the tap, I rip my clothes off and then step into the shower so steaming hot water starts to fall against my body.

“Fuck,” I hiss, looking down at my erect dick. “What the hell were you thinking?”

I have Donna, and Lilah is my stepdaughter. How could I have possibly allowed myself to watch that scene and even get excited over it?

“Disgusting bastard,” I growl, willing my erection to go away. “Sick bastard.”

But even as these exclamations escape me, Lilah’s image remains burned in my mind until I’m so uncomfortable I can’t think of doing anything else other than wrapping my hand around my dick and pumping.

“Dammit,” I hiss, groaning from pleasure. “You’ve gone crazy.”

Or have you?

If I thought about it rationally, Lilah was a good-looking woman with her long red hair and mesmerizing eyes. Add in her hourglass body and spicy personality, and she was certainly the type of woman that any man would want to chase vigorously.

It wasn’t necessarily a sin to be attracted to a woman like that, especially when she was doing that while calling my name.

What mattered most was that it never happened again, and I stayed loyal to Donna, who was sleeping soundly in the bed that we shared without knowing anything that was happening.

Right. I just needed to make sure that I dealt with my attraction toward Lilah, and then everything would be fine.

Says the man masturbating to the image of that very woman. The small voice in the back of my head mocks me. You’ve already crossed the line, and now that you have, there is no going back.