Chapter 51: The truth

Aribella POV

Peyton mounted the horse first, outstretching his hand to me.

I settled between his legs, smiling over my shoulder, “Ever the gentleman.”

He lets out a low chuckle, picking up the reigns, “I don’t know about all that.” Peyton’s words match the shy smile and light pink tinge of his cheeks.

I’ve been around plenty of men since waking up as Aribella Voss, but Peyton is the only man who brings me total and complete peace while in his presence. There is something about him that just…. Feels safe. Like I don’t need to hide behind the walls I’ve built around myself.

The further we ride away from the barn, the fresher the air becomes, and I inhale the pleasant scent of familiarity. It’s not quite as alluring as honeysuckles, but it’s enough.

“The water looks heaven sent,” I all-but moan as I jump off the saddle, making quick work to peel my boots from my sweaty feet. Peyton does the same, rolling his jeans until they’re cuffed around his calves and we both run into the water.

“Heaven sent indeed,” he calls out, scooping some of the lake into his hands, and splashing his face.

I sat down, uncaring that my jean shorts would be soaked, and enjoyed the cooling sensation that washed over me. The water felt nice, as did the sun against my face as I angled my head to take it all in.

“Mind if I join?” Peyton moves closer, and I nod, “You can leave your jeans on shore. I’m sure it’ll be more comfortable when we get back if you’re not soaked.”

Once again, his cheeks flush with the lightest tinge of pink, “Ah, I couldn’t do all that,” he waves his hands around before lowering into the water. “Wet jeans never hurt anyone.”

“There you go,” I tilt my head, smiling. “Being a gentleman.”

“I’m certain that if anyone saw me in my boxers with a pretty lady, they’d get the wrong idea,” he ran a hand through his messy sun-kissed brown locks.

“I don’t care if they got the wrong idea,” I shrugged, nudging him with my leg. “What’s their opinion anyway?”

As soon as the words left my mouth, I realized how they may have sounded to Peyton.

“Can I ask you something that’s been on my mind for a minute?” he mirrors my position, angling his face towards the sun, and closing his eyes.

“I can’t guarantee I’ll answer it.”

He chuckles, but it’s void of the warmth I’m used to coming from him.

Silence settles between us before his head lolls to the side, and his eyelids flutter open, revealing warm, hazel eyes, “I’m not really sure how to ask you this, but I can’t ignore it any longer.”

Peyton’s lips pull down at the corners, the beginning of a frown showing as another silence falls between us.

“Hey,” I find his hand beneath the water, laying mine atop of it, “Whatever it is, you can talk to me. Honestly,” I swallow the emotion that clogs my throat, “You’re the only person who makes me feel safe, Pey. So, whatever you have to ask, ask, and I promise you I’ll answer. Ignore what I said before.”

“That right there,” he lets out a heavy exhale, turning his face back towards the sun. “You and I weren’t close before, you know?” he chuckles. “And then you woke up one day, and it was like everything was different.”

“How do you mean?”

“You’re not really Aribella, are you?” Peyton didn’t look at me, keeping his face towards the rays of the midday sky.

The words that came from his mouth were not at all what I was expecting, and the look on my face must have screamed shock, and I couldn’t even bring myself to school my expression.

Do I tell him the truth? Do I confide in him even if it means everything I’m building for myself goes up in smoke? I just promised him honesty, but I never expected those to be the words that came from his mouth.

“No,” my voice is barely above a whisper. “I’m not.”

He doesn’t tear his hand from mine or run away. Peyton just sits in the same spot, his lips pulling into a deeper frown, “But you look like her. And sound like her.”

“I don’t know how to explain it in a way that makes sense,” I huff out a humorless laugh, sitting upright, and allowing my face to fall into my hands, “It doesn’t even make sense to me.”

“Please try,” his voice sounds so broken, and I hate it.

I start at the beginning, on that fateful night where I died as Charlotte Sinclair. I tell him about the story I read, and how I figured out where I was. I tell him about everything that I can without putting Sacaris in jeopardy, and he listens without interrupting.

When I’m finally finished, I feel equally free and terrified, which has my brain conflicted.

He was silent for what felt like a lifetime before I finally spoke again, “What gave it away?”

“For a moment, I felt like I had a chance with you,” he smiled sadly. “You listened and smiled when you were with me. You accepted my invitation to ride the horses. You worked hard in the barn, and stood up for what you believed was right,” Peyton’s head lolled to the side once more, meeting my eyes, “I thought I was in love with Ari, but that day, I realized that I was just infatuated. But you,” he swallowed thickly, “You were everything.” His cheeks were flushed deeper than before.

“How long have you known?”

“Since that very first day, I think,” he whispers. “I didn’t want to believe such a thing was possible, but the more time I spent with you, the more I realized that it had to be the truth. And then when you left, you told me you’d tell me the truth someday,” Peyton rubs the back of his neck. “Is she dead?”

“I uhm,” I chewed on my bottom lip. “I don’t know. I think so, but I don’t know how I ended up here in her body. I was dead one moment and here the next.”

“Does anyone else know?” Peyton’s elbows were resting on his knees, his head hung low.

“Just you.”

“Your secret is safe with me,” he whispered, glancing over at me. “Thank you for being honest. I’m sure it wasn’t easy. And for what it's worth, having you in any capacity is better than none at all.”

“I wasn’t lying when I said you feel safe, Pey,” but as the words left my mouth, the hairs on the back of my neck stood, and a shiver rolled down the length of my spine.

I felt eyes on me, and a beat later, the scent of honeysuckles carried through the air.

How was that possible?

“We need to get out of here,” I turned towards Peyton, who’s brows furrowed, but we didn’t even have a chance to stand up before the sound of a cackle sounded behind us.

“I knew I’d smelled that scent before, sweet smelling one.”