Chapter 157

Noah

After that night we spent together, everything changed.

We’d said “only tonight,” I know, but yeah, not a fucking chance… I hadn’t believed it for a second—not really. You don’t hold someone like that, you don’t look at them that way, and then go back to pretending it meant nothing.

I woke up the next day with my chest full of him, my head full of him, and this stupid, stubborn hope that maybe, just maybe, he was done fighting us.

Every risk I took after that came from love.

I started saying no—no to seeing Lexie daily, no to her endless invitations, no to her parents’ picture-perfect dinners. I told them I needed to study, that my body was too sore, that I had to rest before the finals. Truth was, I just wanted time. Time to find him again.

Sometimes it worked—the looks, the smiles, the subtle touches...  Finally, I managed to sneak into his office after a practice—and after declining William’s invitation to dinner—heart pounding, just to feel him for a second. For a kiss, stolen between fear and guilt. His hands trembled when he pushed me away, but that didn’t scare me anymore—it only made me believe we still had a chance.

And we might have kept going like that, pretending we could get away with it—if William Hart hadn’t finally lost his goddamn mind and gone all psycho on me.

I had just left Aiden’s office still shaking, adrenaline humming under my skin. I told myself I’d go back to the dorm, shower, rest a little—but by nightfall I’d probably end up at his door again. I was running on hope and bad decisions, and both felt better than the emptiness that came without him.

A knock broke through my thoughts.

For one insane heartbeat, I thought it was Aiden.

It wasn’t.

William Hart stood at the threshold, eyes cold, jaw tight. He didn’t wait for an invitation. He pushed past me, the scent of his expensive cologne mixing with the sharp chill of the hallway.

“Mr. Hart?” My voice cracked. “Is… everything okay?”

His answer came with the sound of his hand striking the wall beside my head. The air shifted—predatory, dangerous.

“No,” he said, voice low and vibrating with fury. “Everything is not okay.”

My pulse spiked. “What—what are you doing?”

“Don’t play dumb.” He stepped closer, close enough that I could feel the heat of his anger. “I warned you once. You will not make a fool of me, and you will not disrespect my daughter.”

“I don’t know what you—”

This time, his hand struck me across the face. I stumbled, half-stunned, half-disbelieving. He leaned in until his breath brushed my cheek, his voice sharp and bitter.

“You think I’m stupid? You think I don’t know what goes on when you disappear? When you refuse our invitations? Every lie you tell my daughter, every excuse you feed your teammates, every time you sneak out after practice and straight into his office—I see it all.”

Holy shit—how? How can he…?

My blood turned to ice at the realization that William Hart wasn’t an ordinary man. He was a new kind of psychopath—more dangerous than my father or any I’d known, because unlike the others, he had money, power, and everyone’s respect. That made him untouchable.

Somehow, he’d had me followed. Watched. But I wasn’t about to admit any of it.

I shook my head. “You’re wrong.”

“Don’t lie to me.” His voice dropped to a whisper that was somehow worse than shouting. “Before, you were just a player. Now you’re an investment—and my daughter’s reputation. I’ll destroy you before I let you ruin either. Is that clear?”

The room tilted. I could barely breathe. “Y-yes, sir.”

“Good.” He straightened his jacket, calm again, the transformation almost elegant. “Because you seem to forget your place from time to time. Maybe you need an incentive to remember.”

His smile didn’t reach his eyes.

I had no idea what kind of “incentive” he had in mind, but I wasn’t ready to find out. “No, sir. I’m sorry…”

“That’s alright, son.” His voice softened, which somehow made it worse. “You seem to have a lot on your mind. Let’s meet this weekend, like reasonable people, and set up a date, shall we?”

“A date?” I frowned.

“For the wedding, of course.”

My heart skipped. “But, sir, I can’t—”

“You can, and you will, if you want me to keep our little secret.” He smiled again, that cold, controlled smile. “Any concerns you might have can be addressed and taken care of. Remember, I’m not against you. You’re family now. Your problems are my problems as well. You understand?”

“Yes, sir.” I bit my tongue to keep from saying that he was my number one problem at the moment.

And then he left—door closing with a soft, final click that felt louder than a gunshot.

I stayed against the wall long after he was gone, every nerve still trembling, realizing that whatever hope I’d been clinging to was about to cost me more than I could afford.

After that lovely chat, everything changed again. Not in the way William expected.

I’d thought I’d learned fear before, but that man redefined it. Still, even as my hands kept shaking, a single thought took root in my head: I just needed to be smarter. More careful. That was all.

I wasn’t about to stop seeing Aiden. I’d die before I gave him up.

If this town was compromised, fine—then we’d take our chances somewhere else. Even after the season ended, there would still be away games, hotel trips, whole weekends where no one could track where we went or who we were with. And if that wasn’t enough, we’d go further. Across the country if we had to.

I’d stay here, renew my contract with the school—just like everyone kept begging me to do. I just needed to make sure Aiden went nowhere without me, that he stayed my coach, my anchor.

In the meantime, I could take a trip home—or pretend I was. William wasn’t going to follow me all the way to fucking West Virginia, was he?

All we needed was a plan.

That evening, I called Aiden. I knew he hated when I broke the rules, when I reached out instead of waiting, but I didn’t care. I needed to hear his voice, to remind myself he was still real.

“After the season,” I said, trying to sound casual. “We should get away. Just a few days. Somewhere no one knows us.”

He was quiet for so long I thought the line had gone dead. Then he exhaled.

“Alright, we’ll see,” he said.

He didn’t say no.

And that was enough to keep the fire alive in me. Dreamer or not, William or not—I was going to make it happen.